Yeah I'm gonna have to second this. I know there are some things people can't live without in games but a character creator shouldn't be one of them. Fact of the matter is that when it comes to RPGs it's totally at the discretion of the developer whether you can create your own character or not, much like you can't choose the overall role of your character. A couple of people did choose not to play TW3 from early on for this reason - their loss honestly.Amaror said:Well if you can get over that, at least in my opinion, somewhat silly requirement then go play The Witcher 3. It's easily the best RPG I have ever played and would be the best game overall if I didn't enjoy Paradox Strategy games that much.Aulleas123 said:...sadly, I don't get to create my own character in The Witcher. I'm sure Geralt is a bad ass, but he's someone else's creation and I like creating my own badasses! That's the challenge!MercurySteam said:My only suggestion is The Witcher 3 - Wild Hunt.
If you can't then I am sorry, there are just not that many good modern RPGs with Character Creator and you seem to have allready tried all the ones that are good or at least ok.
In truth, I actually played through about an hour of the first Witcher game a few years back and thought to myself "What if I could create a character in this world?" or "What would it be like to be a _______ in this world?" How would the story be different? How would this new character navigate the world around them? From that point, I really lost interest quickly, not because the game had bad mechanics or it was a bad story, I just didn't feel too invested in Geralt as a character because he wasn't my creation. I couldn't internalize as him, I couldn't get behind what he'd be thinking. I'm sure that my opinion of wanting a game to allow for me to use my imagination is silly, but it's what I like in a game. That's why I posted it that way in the OP.MercurySteam said:Yeah I'm gonna have to second this. I know there are some things people can't live without in games but a character creator shouldn't be one of them. Fact of the matter is that when it comes to RPGs it's totally at the discretion of the developer whether you can create your own character or not, much like you can't choose the overall role of your character. A couple of people did choose not to play TW3 from early on for this reason - their loss honestly.Amaror said:Well if you can get over that, at least in my opinion, somewhat silly requirement then go play The Witcher 3. It's easily the best RPG I have ever played and would be the best game overall if I didn't enjoy Paradox Strategy games that much.Aulleas123 said:...sadly, I don't get to create my own character in The Witcher. I'm sure Geralt is a bad ass, but he's someone else's creation and I like creating my own badasses! That's the challenge!MercurySteam said:My only suggestion is The Witcher 3 - Wild Hunt.
If you can't then I am sorry, there are just not that many good modern RPGs with Character Creator and you seem to have allready tried all the ones that are good or at least ok.
But its good practise to buy games only if you think you'll enjoy them so it's up to you.
The Witcher is experienced best after reading the books. It's definitely not a "be this guy" story. It's a "travel with this guy (and those other characters you know and love) again" story.Aulleas123 said:In truth, I actually played through about an hour of the first Witcher game a few years back and thought to myself "What if I could create a character in this world?" or "What would it be like to be a _______ in this world?" How would the story be different? How would this new character navigate the world around them? From that point, I really lost interest quickly, not because the game had bad mechanics or it was a bad story, I just didn't feel too invested in Geralt as a character because he wasn't my creation. I couldn't internalize as him, I couldn't get behind what he'd be thinking. I'm sure that my opinion of wanting a game to allow for me to use my imagination is silly, but it's what I like in a game. That's why I posted it that way in the OP.MercurySteam said:Yeah I'm gonna have to second this. I know there are some things people can't live without in games but a character creator shouldn't be one of them. Fact of the matter is that when it comes to RPGs it's totally at the discretion of the developer whether you can create your own character or not, much like you can't choose the overall role of your character. A couple of people did choose not to play TW3 from early on for this reason - their loss honestly.Amaror said:Well if you can get over that, at least in my opinion, somewhat silly requirement then go play The Witcher 3. It's easily the best RPG I have ever played and would be the best game overall if I didn't enjoy Paradox Strategy games that much.Aulleas123 said:...sadly, I don't get to create my own character in The Witcher. I'm sure Geralt is a bad ass, but he's someone else's creation and I like creating my own badasses! That's the challenge!MercurySteam said:My only suggestion is The Witcher 3 - Wild Hunt.
If you can't then I am sorry, there are just not that many good modern RPGs with Character Creator and you seem to have allready tried all the ones that are good or at least ok.
But its good practise to buy games only if you think you'll enjoy them so it's up to you.
I have heard wonderful things about the Witcher series and I'm definitely open to trying them someday, but until then I really don't want to spend money on a game that I won't play.
Still, thank you guys for your suggestion!