Marines posed with Nazi SS symbol in Afghanistan

Recommended Videos

Mycroft Holmes

New member
Sep 26, 2011
850
0
0
Kendarik said:
Mycroft Holmes said:
Hero in a half shell said:
Yeah. Now you're just flat out trolling.
So you have no problems with Turkey, or Tunisia or Algeria using the symbol of a genocidal power as their national flags because the media hasn't told you to do so yet, right?
Ok, I give, what "genocidal power" symbol is on their flag? You can't mean the crescent moon and star unless you are sadly ill informed (stay off of those White Power websites, they make shit up). Or do you somehow think the Turks were an evil genocidal country?
You only ever bothered to learn DWEM history, so I'm the fan of white power?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Armenian_Genocide

Wikipedia is a neo-nazi organization though, right? Right, buddy?
 

Raesvelg

New member
Oct 22, 2008
486
0
0
Ignorant of what it meant? Nah, I can't buy that. Trying to co-opt some of the SS mystique for their role as scout snipers? Yeah, I can buy that.

Let's face it: you get a bunch of males in their early 20's together, give them guns and train them to be very deadly killers, and you're going to wind up with some very aberrant behavior, as a general rule, unless the officers in charge of such a group keep an extremely close eye on things.

And aren't complete idiots.
 

Mycroft Holmes

New member
Sep 26, 2011
850
0
0
Kendarik said:
WWII survivors still exist. People who lost immediate family in WWII still exist. Is the same true for victims of the Ott Empire?
1923, assume someone was 10 years old and their parents were raped and murdered in front of their eyes. 2012-1923 they would be about to hit 90. Someone in their late 70s or early 80s could have grown up with one or both of their parents dead. Someone who lived through it in their 20s who had children later could mean someone currently in their 40s or 50s would have grown up knowing that their grandparents were killed, grown up with parents who have a huge amount of psychological and emotional baggage.

Kendarik said:
Does anyone STILL have that as their primary association when they see the symbols?
Given its still Turkeys flag, and Turkey fosters and encourages a denialist opinion of the whole 'incident' yeah id say Armenians don't like it at all. What if the Germans still had a Swastika on their flag and went around calling the Jews liars?

Kendarik said:
(And yes, that does make the argument that at some point down the road the SS and Nazi symbols may have less weight).
The longer it takes the more power you give their actions. The more power you give their actions the more you open the door to others who would do the same. By ignoring them and moving on you destroy their legacy and you destroy their power over us.
 

Terminal Blue

Elite Member
Legacy
Feb 18, 2010
3,933
1,804
118
Country
United Kingdom
Mycroft Holmes said:
Wikipedia and google image search seems to agree that the actual flag is black and white, while the only case of the flag being blue is some random dudes internet store. So it was all just a miss understanding bro, because the Scout Sniper flag is the wrong color.
Do you know what the words 'not comparing like with like' actually mean?

It's not the wrong colour, just like none of the flags I posted as examples for you are the wrong font. Give me one legitimate reason why changing the colour of the flag would change its meaning? What has writing the double sig rune on a blue flag ever meant which might distinguish it from the more common black flag?

As mentioned, it's a German occult symbol from the turn of the 20th century. It has no relevance to American people whatsoever except that a person ignorant of its origin might read it as a letter 'S'.

Mycroft Holmes said:
So what you're saying is that you don't give a shit about Armenians, because they aren't Jewish? That's pretty insensitive of you to ignore a genocide brought about under an authority that used that flag.
Again.. please compare like with like. I know you were wrong first time and it's hard to deal with, but this is dumb and I can't be bothered with it.

Considering that half a million civilians are estimated to have died in Vietnam due to the widespread of use of defoliants by the US, not even considering the effects of conventional bombing and actual military action in the country. I think we can safely say that that if you're going to follow this line of logic, then we should ban practically all national flags.

I'm not advocating that, because national flags have alternate significance, the double sig rune really doesn't. It has never represented an existing country, group or institution except wherein it has been used as a symbol by certain elements of the extreme right. The association with the marine scout/snipers is strictly informal and clearly wasn't endorsed by anyone in authority, because they've now banned it.

Mycroft Holmes said:
Is there still NO REASON to do it?
Yeah, and you should also support and allow paedophilia because theoretically if aliens arrived and threatened to blow up the planet unless you personally had sex with a small boy, you'd probably do it.

"Unreasonable" doesn't ever mean that. It means unreasonable for the circumstances, for the world we happen to live in and the prevailing context in which these actions might occur. It is unreasonable in that world, and no shitty attempts to invent hypothetical scenarios will cover for that.

Seriously, it's an SS flag. It has no meaning except as an SS flag and symbol of the extreme right. It doesn't represent a country. It doesn't represent a legitimate polical position. It's not even latin script. You aren't going to change that through denial. Accept it, move on, get over it.

If you can't maintain respect for people who make mistakes because they also do an incredibly difficult job under extreme pressure, then I'm sorry to point out that planet Earth is inevitably going to disappoint you. Noone is perfect, and if you're willing to forget that because it's more comforting to imagine that your military personnel can do no wrong, then I think you've lost the right to try and lecture anyone about genocide.
 

Scarecrow1001

Senior Member
Jun 27, 2011
172
0
21
Of for goods sake, this is ridiculous!I mean come on, so what if they had a symbol that way used about 65 years ago, it doesn't matter about what it used to mean, to them, it means Scout Sniper.
 

Darth_Dude

New member
Jul 11, 2008
1,302
0
0
It's always the Marines doing the stupid shit. Makes me wonder if they deliberately recruit the dumbest members of society to be a Marine.
 

QtheMuse

New member
May 23, 2010
76
0
0
Whatever, people just using this to bash the military because they can and it gives them an excuse.

Subjectivity can be such a *****.

Also the SS was a crazy brutal unit but they were an awesome combat unit who got stuff done and had the germans won they would of been the navy seals of the world. Just goes to show that the victor always writes history.

And as said before it does mean Sniper Scout because they are snipers and scouts as their job for all you people who are ignorant about what roles they do in the military look it up before you open your civi mouths.
 

Darth_Dude

New member
Jul 11, 2008
1,302
0
0
Monkeyman O said:
Meh. Get the fuck over it. WW2 was a loooooong ass time ago and no one of worth cares any more.
Dude, are you saying that no one cares about WW2 anymore? Man that's a really dumb blanket statement you've put out there, just because you dont give a damn about the war and the sacrifices those soldiers made, doesn't mean that everyone else doesn't.
 

Helmholtz Watson

New member
Nov 7, 2011
2,497
0
0
3 legged goat said:
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/46329740/ns/us_news/t/marines-posed-nazi-ss-symbol-afghanistan/#.Tzc7zOP-_9o

I found this story when looking for a Current Event for my class, and my first reaction was facepalm. This is way to similar to the SS logo. People have linked pictures of replica SS flags that look exactly like it. I can't believe that no one there thought that it looked like the SS logo. People have also pointed out that the Marines have used this logo for Sniper Scouts for a long time. Their logo is different though. It isn't just the SS, it has Sniper Rifles, Skulls, etc. The SS part of their logo is actually a rather small part of the logo. The least USMC could do is only allow the full logo or change the font.

http://www.armytimes.com/news/2012/02/marine-amos-apologizes-for-scout-sniper-nazi-ss-logo-021012/

This was an apology from the Marines. My thoughts are that if you have to apologize for a logo that you use, you probably shouldn't use it.

What do you think about this?
........why? Why would you pose in a picture with those symbols?
 

Helmholtz Watson

New member
Nov 7, 2011
2,497
0
0
Kendarik said:
Ah yes, I did forget the Ott Empire used that symbol, even though they didn't originate it. Thank you for the reminder.
The Nazi's didn't come up with the Swastika either. Take a look here [https://www.google.com/search?q=buddhist&oe=utf-8&rls=org.mozilla:en-US:eek:fficial&client=firefox-a&um=1&ie=UTF-8&hl=en&tbm=isch&source=og&sa=N&tab=wi&ei=rZk7T_O3HcfqgQfVs8iYCw&biw=1366&bih=644&sei=sJk7T5KAD4rAgQf_uLCZCw#um=1&hl=en&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla:en-US%3Aofficial&tbm=isch&sa=1&q=hindu+swastika&pbx=1&oq=hindu+swastika&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&gs_sm=3&gs_upl=93721l95029l6l95425l5l5l0l0l0l0l96l422l5l5l0&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.r_qf.,cf.osb&fp=54e066ce9c831687&biw=1366&bih=644].

Kendarik said:
I guess that does take you to the question of how long ago the event happened and was that flag specifically linked in people's minds to those events.

WWII survivors still exist. People who lost immediate family in WWII still exist. Is the same true for victims of the Ott Empire? Does anyone STILL have that as their primary association when they see the symbols? (And yes, that does make the argument that at some point down the road the SS and Nazi symbols may have less weight).
As someone who's grandparents survived the holocaust(even though most of my family was murdered), I don't think that what happened to my family is less important because it is more recent. What happened to the Armenian people was a genocide and (imo) should be viewed with the same respect that people give to genocide my grandparents faced. If you think the Arminiean genocide and the emotions associated with it are gone, you [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Armenian_Genocide#Controversies]..are [http://www.nytimes.com/2012/01/24/world/europe/french-senate-passes-genocide-bill-angering-turks.html]..wrong [http://www.euronews.net/2012/01/21/senate-vote-sparks-protests-in-paris/].
 

MaxwellEdison

New member
Sep 30, 2010
732
0
0
Elementary - Dear Watson said:
]
EDIT: Since some people are morons, you don't have to know every single symbol in every military force that roamed the Earth to be considered a history buff. I can name you more information on Nazi Germany political structure at the time, the laws enacted, reasons why it became how it did, offensive tactics, etc, but I do not know every single symbol they used. Especially since *gasp* they actually used a lot of symbols, just like a lot of other militaries at the time for each branch and division. If you honestly believe that because I couldn't recognize that symbol at that moment when I first saw the photo, then you're not worth my time. Just sayin'!
...wut. A lot of symbols?
Just sayin', the SS is probably one of the first things you should know about as a history buff, seeing as it was "one of the largest and most powerful organizations in the Third Reich," to quote wikipedia.
 

MaxwellEdison

New member
Sep 30, 2010
732
0
0
Well, they should get on changing the practice of using the flag.
I lose a lot of faith in the intelligence of our military knowing that none of them made the link in their minds between "two sig runes" and "the two sig runes used by Nazis."
 

Shpongled

New member
Apr 21, 2010
330
0
0
Scarecrow1001 said:
Of for goods sake, this is ridiculous!I mean come on, so what if they had a symbol that way used about 65 years ago, it doesn't matter about what it used to mean, to them, it means Scout Sniper.
And to the afghan civilians watching the US soldiers posing in front of the flag, it means "we identify with nazi's". It's like watching your child run around screaming ****** in a crowded area, just because the kid probably doesn't know what it means doesn't mean it's A-ok. The difference is a child has a good excuse for ignorance, US Marines don't. Seriously, your military is out there representing America as a whole, what people see your soldiers doing matters, and you don't even give a shit?

This "well it doesn't harm us, who cares?" attitude is exactly why 9/11 happened in the first place.
 

Elementary - Dear Watson

RIP Eleuthera, I will miss you
Nov 9, 2010
2,980
0
0
MaxwellEdison said:
Elementary - Dear Watson said:
]
EDIT: Since some people are morons, you don't have to know every single symbol in every military force that roamed the Earth to be considered a history buff. I can name you more information on Nazi Germany political structure at the time, the laws enacted, reasons why it became how it did, offensive tactics, etc, but I do not know every single symbol they used. Especially since *gasp* they actually used a lot of symbols, just like a lot of other militaries at the time for each branch and division. If you honestly believe that because I couldn't recognize that symbol at that moment when I first saw the photo, then you're not worth my time. Just sayin'!
...wut. A lot of symbols?
Just sayin', the SS is probably one of the first things you should know about as a history buff, seeing as it was "one of the largest and most powerful organizations in the Third Reich," to quote wikipedia.
Carefull who you are quoting there buddy... that's not one of mine! :S