omega 616 said:
First of all, love the avatar.
Second, I don't accuse Mario of stagnating, I accuse Nintendo of stagnating. Constantly pumping out the same handful of franchises.
Mario is just the prime target, it's he gets dropped into so many things! He sells games, it doesn't matter what game it is, put a Mario skin in it and it will sell.
Here's the problem with that line of thought. You assume the games sell just because Mario's in it. The games don't sell because of the chubby plumber. The games sell because of Mario and all of his friends, relatives, enemies, love interests, various items/tools and locations. That's right, somewhere along the line Mario's World became an established universe. I'm not quite sure when it happened but it did. Mario's world is HUGE. The amount of characters in Mario's world is staggering. Almost everybody has their favorite Mario character and 9/10 times it's probably not Mario. Some of his friends/enemies even have their own games. Donkey Kong, Luigi, Yoshi, Wario all with mostly different gameplay mechanics. Hell, there's even Mario fan fiction. Go figure.
The problem comparing Mario to COD is that COD isn't an established universe. Well, maybe the Modern Warfare series, but that's a stretch. You're better off comparing it to other established universes. I skipped Nintendo's Wii era however I did recently pick up a Wii U a few months ago. I have been enjoying it so far and there is a lot more to this little box than what I've heard on forums or message boards.
Do I agree that Nintendo needs new IP's? Of course it does. But getting rid of Mario and his world is the wrong thing to do. However I do wish there was a Bowser game where Mario wasn't his enemy. Maybe a civil war or revolt setup in Bowser's army. Bowser Jr. stages a coup with majority of Bowser's Army and it's up to Bowser and his koopalings to restore order.
OT; Good for Nintendo. They did the right thing by offering a free game with the purchase as well. A decent E3 reveal will do wonders at helping the Wii U. Fingers crossed for a new IP.