Because it's a story. A rather good one with deep themes, interesting characters, and better interactive principles than most video games stories have ever hoped to include. There's absolutely nothing wrong with deeply analyzing a story.SFJ said:Why are people treating Mass Effect and its characters like it's a real saga? Like, we're in mourning for this non-existent lizard guy, he was alright really. Hard shell, but deep down...
NO! He was a fucking bad guy in an overrated game. Christ.
Depends on what you consider to be "the perfect villain".MakeLoveNotWar said:*coughs coughs coughs coughs*phenity said:the perfect villain.
No. That's Bowser.
I see your point.. but doesn't it really say more about Mario being a great hero, rather than Bowser being a terrible villain?gjendemsjo said:Depends on what you consider to be "the perfect villain".MakeLoveNotWar said:*coughs coughs coughs coughs*phenity said:the perfect villain.
No. That's Bowser.
If you consider a failure of a monster who fails every time he tries to do something evil to be the perfect villain, then Bowser is the rigth choice.
Now that made me laugh.Thunderhorse31 said:I will remember his two rules.
Rule #1: Never kill someone for no reason.
Rule #2: You can always find a reason to kill someone.
Pretty much this, but if the EMperor had even more control over Vader. I thought it was pretty apparent that Sovereign was straight-up mind controlling Saren, and only lost his grip long enough for Saren to off himself towards the end. I don't think Saren was perfect or anything, but it's kinda hard to find anyone one in the ME universe who isn't a little specist. I think if anyone else had been controlled by Sovereign, Saren would have been the hero. He just got really, really unlucky.meganmeave said:I think he's mostly a good guy, who got taken in by the wrong crowd. There seem to be a fair number of people who look up to him. And I suspect, if he was truly a bad dude who was constantly doing questionable things, it would have been easier to convince the council he was up to no good. (If you discount their blatant stupidity in ME2 that is)
I like to think he's like Vader, and if you are strong enough, you can redeem him in the end.
Well, Bowser doesn't really do anything more than to kidnap the princess, and Mario doesn't really do anything more than to save her. Maybe if he tried doing something evil or smart. Maybe if he elaborated a little bit more, and tried to put a little bit more though behind what he does. He is pretty much a 1-dimensional villain, and i don't know about you, but I like a smarter and tougher villain more than the clumsy not-good-for-anything villains like Bowser.MakeLoveNotWar said:I see your point.. but doesn't it really say more about Mario being a great hero, rather than Bowser being a terrible villain?gjendemsjo said:Depends on what you consider to be "the perfect villain".MakeLoveNotWar said:*coughs coughs coughs coughs*phenity said:the perfect villain.
No. That's Bowser.
If you consider a failure of a monster who fails every time he tries to do something evil to be the perfect villain, then Bowser is the rigth choice.
Yeah, your right. He needs to be more like Atlas from Bioshock.gjendemsjo said:Well, Bowser doesn't really do anything more than to kidnap the princess, and Mario doesn't really do anything more than to save her. Maybe if he tried doing something evil or smart. Maybe if he elaborated a little bit more, and tried to put a little bit more though behind what he does. He is pretty much a 1-dimensional villain, and i don't know about you, but I like a smarter and tougher villain more than the clumsy not-good-for-anything villains like Bowser.MakeLoveNotWar said:I see your point.. but doesn't it really say more about Mario being a great hero, rather than Bowser being a terrible villain?gjendemsjo said:Depends on what you consider to be "the perfect villain".MakeLoveNotWar said:*coughs coughs coughs coughs*phenity said:the perfect villain.
No. That's Bowser.
If you consider a failure of a monster who fails every time he tries to do something evil to be the perfect villain, then Bowser is the rigth choice.
And yeah, I know that Bowser is one of the most famous and well recognized villains in the game industry, but that's only because he's a part of the Mario franchise.
Yeah, a little bit like him. I'm just saying that they should give him a little bit more of a motivation, and at least try to make him menacing.MakeLoveNotWar said:Yeah, your right. He needs to be more like Atlas from Bioshock.gjendemsjo said:Well, Bowser doesn't really do anything more than to kidnap the princess, and Mario doesn't really do anything more than to save her. Maybe if he tried doing something evil or smart. Maybe if he elaborated a little bit more, and tried to put a little bit more though behind what he does. He is pretty much a 1-dimensional villain, and i don't know about you, but I like a smarter and tougher villain more than the clumsy not-good-for-anything villains like Bowser.MakeLoveNotWar said:I see your point.. but doesn't it really say more about Mario being a great hero, rather than Bowser being a terrible villain?gjendemsjo said:Depends on what you consider to be "the perfect villain".MakeLoveNotWar said:*coughs coughs coughs coughs*phenity said:the perfect villain.
No. That's Bowser.
If you consider a failure of a monster who fails every time he tries to do something evil to be the perfect villain, then Bowser is the rigth choice.
And yeah, I know that Bowser is one of the most famous and well recognized villains in the game industry, but that's only because he's a part of the Mario franchise.
Mm. I always did wonder why he would want to steal a princess, especially if the game is G rated..gjendemsjo said:Yeah, a little bit like him. I'm just saying that they should give him a little bit more of a motivation, and at least try to make him menacing.MakeLoveNotWar said:Yeah, your right. He needs to be more like Atlas from Bioshock.gjendemsjo said:Well, Bowser doesn't really do anything more than to kidnap the princess, and Mario doesn't really do anything more than to save her. Maybe if he tried doing something evil or smart. Maybe if he elaborated a little bit more, and tried to put a little bit more though behind what he does. He is pretty much a 1-dimensional villain, and i don't know about you, but I like a smarter and tougher villain more than the clumsy not-good-for-anything villains like Bowser.MakeLoveNotWar said:I see your point.. but doesn't it really say more about Mario being a great hero, rather than Bowser being a terrible villain?gjendemsjo said:Depends on what you consider to be "the perfect villain".MakeLoveNotWar said:*coughs coughs coughs coughs*phenity said:the perfect villain.
No. That's Bowser.
If you consider a failure of a monster who fails every time he tries to do something evil to be the perfect villain, then Bowser is the rigth choice.
And yeah, I know that Bowser is one of the most famous and well recognized villains in the game industry, but that's only because he's a part of the Mario franchise.
Hmmm, I'll get the book tomorrow. It sounds interesting.Nimbus said:If you read the book, you find out that he is, in fact, a GIANT douche, even before being indoctrinated. And a racist.Awake- said:Idea taken off BioWare forum.
Me, I will remember him as an extremely wickedly cool renegade Shepard. Now, he definitely wasn't a saint. Destroying hundreds of innocent lives just for a diversion. I do not, however, think that he was ever truly evil. He merely took the entire "the ends justify the means" thing a little too far. A little like Jack Bauer, but he's willing to go a whole lot further. Bauer wouldn't directly harm an innocent unless he had no better choice, I think.
He was indoctrinated. Okay, he looks like a total ass if you don't charm or intimidate him at the end of the game. But if you do, he thanks you and shoots himself in the head, which is still to me the second best scene in the Mass Effect series. The first being when he attacked you on Virmire.
So, what will you remember him as?