Minecraft beats just about everything with a current 97 metascore.

[Scrustle]

Wow the lowest score is 9/10. I love the game but I think critics have extremely over-rated it. They're just all fapping over it because it's the cool indy hit. The game is great, but really? FIVE 10/10s? The game quite obviously has problems with it, and to be honest there's not really that much to the game itself. It's the players that make it what it is.

 

[Nouw]

It's going to go down. I'd say it'll be about 94 or 93.

 

[JesterRaiin]

I'm no fanatical devotee, but i like tha background : some people came out of shadows and despite all this bullsh*t "experts" try to sell us each and every day (consoles killing PC gaming, no big sucess for indie games, end of creativity and such) did something not only fun, but cheap, and original.

I like to imagine faces of all those "captains of industry" thinking "they did what we couldn't without big budget".

 

[Jitters Caffeine]

I really don't care WHAT score it has, I still find it impossibly boring.

 

[repeating integers]

Good for Minecraft. It'll probably go down (some party pooper will probably come along and complain about the lack of story), but it's nice that the critics in this case are able to overlook graphical shortcomings.

 

[Zhukov]

Good God, I wish people would stop bloody bitching about review scores.

Guys, it's a fucking number. Get over it.

 

[Punch You]

No one will take games seriously as long as the majority of gamers rely on numbers, letter grades and stars to decide whether or not a game is good. Just write a review, and Don't put a score anywhere. If someone passes over your review because there was no score, they probably wouldn't have read the review anyway.

You don't need to be good at making review scores, you need to be good at writing.