Minecraft, My Thoughts

Recommended Videos

moopig66

New member
Feb 1, 2011
92
0
0
Unless you have been living under a rock for the past year it?s safe to assume that you?ve heard of Minecraft. It?s become more popular with nerds than a 12 sided die and it?s just getting more popular from here. Like most people who go outside from time to time I was hesitant to pick Minecraft up at first considering that the nerd taint was practically palpable. My first romp thru the game was, I suspect, similar to most people. After appearing on a beach made of blocks I wondered into a forest made of blocks. Upon realizing I could punch things with my fists of furry I showed some dirt who the boss was, than a tree; but the tree just floated in the air as if it were some kind of demon tree, so, in fear, I fled in the opposite direction. It was at this point that I decided to see if I could use my mighty cube fists to punch my way to the center of the earth, and so I did. I punched and punched, and soon I found myself standing in a strange reddish liquid and-OH GOD ITS LAVA!! And so I died and whatever pitiful possessions I was carrying at the time was incinerated along with myself. It was at this point that I gave into temptation and sat thru several hours of walkthroughs and tutorials on YouTube; where I learned of the ridiculously specific recipes required to make anything actually useful in the game. But I eventually got the hang of things and have been loving on it ever since.

I?m not completely convinced that Minecraft is really a game at all, strictly speaking. Yes there are bad guys that you wave your sword at, and yes there is a rather large challenge involved in it all, but there?s really no endgame to speak of. It?s akin to Lego?s in a way, if every ten minutes or so a green penis kicks down your door and blows itself up suicide bomber style, taking your cherished creation with it. At first many of the desired and exciting resources will feel out of reach, but as you play more and more you will slowly become the master of your blocky, farm animal infested, land. At some point thou you may look back at you castle or city or tower or whatever it is that you built and ask yourself ?what now?? You see Minecraft suffers from a very strong and inherent flaw: there is no real goal to speak of. Ya, the creators did manage to patch in an achievement system, but there?s no real reward for completing any of them, excluding the small pop-up window that?s about as exciting as getting the mail or brushing your teeth, and many of them are really just rewards for completing something as exciting as that. The things you create serve no tangible purpose and you?ll often find yourself abandoning projects midway thru in the search of better conquests.

I do feel however that Minecraft is really a social game at heart. If you manage to create yourself a server and sucker just one of your nerd friends into joining you, you will have substantially more fun than you would have had otherwise. With a friend at your side the sky is the limit (within a set height of course!) and the things you create will feel like they have more weight to them. The two of you well sometimes set goals for yourselves that you wouldn?t have when just playing solo. City?s will spring up left and right, a huge monolith will protrude from the horizon, a deep and well memorized cave system will unfold beneath your feet and you?ll have someone to brag at when you complete your two hundred foot stall statue of a creeper that cries lava. Minecraft is undoubtedly better played as a cooperative system; it?s just too bad the setup necessary for starting a server of your very own is about as fun and easy as removing one of your own extremities with a butter knife. As a brain dead, knuckle dragging, mouth breathing console gamer myself, I find computers as complicated and frightening as women are to the average EVE online player. If I can?t get what I want from the press of just a few buttons I don?t usually bother trying at all; so it?s understandable that it took me several days to actually setup a fully functioning server, but what a reward it was!

No one, I feel, can honestly rate Minecraft at this point considering it is still just in the beta phase, but I can whole heartedly recommend trying it to anyone who willing to try crazy, green penis infested new things. Maybe Minecraft can serve as a glimmering example of the potential future of the industry we all love so much. In a sea of gritty, realistic, modern military themed first-person shooters it?s good to know that there are still people out there who have some real vision and talent. It might even be possible that with the death of Bin Laden the industry will start to move away from military themed shooters; and maybe magic squirrels will fly from my rectum and take me to a land of pure ecstasy where I can please Todd Howard in every way he pleases me!
 

subtlefuge

Lord Cromulent
May 21, 2010
1,107
0
0
I'm unsure who your intended audience is. You insult the existing player base, but you also make vague statements ("green penis" instead of "creeper") and fail to mention anything concrete about the actual game mechanics.

Also, along the lines of insulting, your jokes are a bit off their mark and potentially alienating to readers.

I'm not sure you effectively conveyed the exact point you were going for.

Edit: I'll be polite, but not generous, the review was not good.
 

Aeokirr

New member
Dec 12, 2010
18
0
0
actually, this is a terrible review. half of it is more or less word for word from yahtzees zero punctuation review. the other half is just insulting everyone he can think of. at least when yahtzee does it its an apt comparison, but this is like an angry child just yelling swear words to get attention.
 

NightlyNews

New member
Mar 25, 2011
194
0
0
I'm not gonna lie I just skimmed it, but are your preparing to be a lawyer because you wrote several paragraphs without saying anything.

The only thing close to a point I could see was that you realized a game born from making 8 bit art is more about dicking around than clear objective based gameplay. No ones going to disagree with you because everyone knew that back in alpha.
 

Raikazu

New member
Apr 15, 2009
116
0
0
Might I also add that if you're going to submit a review which contains more material being insulting than reviewing, I'd check that your spelling and grammar wasn't as bad as your attempts at wit.

It's not a bad article I guess, but from a review standpoint it's not really getting to any kind of point. And you've tried to make points out of things that people already know. It's like reviewing a shop by saying "Yeah you walk in and there's some shelves with stuff on and a few cash registers. You walk in, buy something and pay for it". You're not reviewing so much as stating the obious.
 

Liberaliter

New member
Sep 17, 2008
1,370
0
0
If you're going to attempt humour in reviews then... actually just don't that was awful.
 

ZeroMachine

New member
Oct 11, 2008
4,397
0
0
Your attempts are humor were appalling.

If you're going to write a review, please consider the fact that not all your audience (gamers) appreciate self-deprecating jokes.

In fact many, like myself, hate them.
 

steeple

Death by tray it shall be
Dec 2, 2008
14,779
0
41
Im pretty sure, from what Ive read anyway, that most of what you wrote is what yazhee said in his review...

anyway, I've yet to try it, so any opinion I might have on the game is not even existant...
 

Sarcastic_Applause

New member
Dec 1, 2010
159
0
0
yeah, it did seem to use yahtzee's opinion as a basis, and i dont really agree, im not really a die hard geek, but i enjoy this game because its mechanics are simple (to a degree) and its free roaming to the degree that its all entirely up to you what to do with the country you inherited.
I tried Fortresscraft as a comparison to this: taking yahtzee's idea of a 3 story golden wedding tackle, all i had to do for fortresscraft was materialise them into existance, put them all down to make midas' set, went: "yep... thats a penis alright" and turned it off.

Minecraft is awesome, even if you're not a hardcore gamer; for the simple reason that all you need is a computer and an idea for what you'll do on it as a project... Or murder the wildlife and blow it up
 

Catalyst6

Dapper Fellow
Apr 21, 2010
1,362
0
0
Sounds very similar to the general concensus of the game.

On the by, though: Hands up, anyone who has played EVE. (*puts hand up*)

Now, who doesn't have a crippling social disorder? (*puts hand back up again*)

Glad we nipped that one at the bud.
 

artanis_neravar

New member
Apr 18, 2011
2,560
0
0
Pretty sure I heard this before, but Minecraft is played by plenty of people who don't fall into the "nerd" class. Also it doesn't seem smart to insult the only poeple who are actually going to read your review.