Moral discussion: would you?

Recommended Videos

spartan231490

New member
Jan 14, 2010
5,186
0
0
I'm not sure, but probably not. I'm not really interested in any kind of casual sex. If I, for some reason, was interested in a relationship with her and vice versa, maybe I would go for it, but the family awkwardness would be a big down-side.
 

kidd25

New member
Jun 13, 2011
361
0
0
l3o2828 said:
kidd25 said:
l3o2828 said:
God no.
Just no,I hate incest.
Even if it isn't really incest.
Just...No. People who are part of your family one way or another... just no.
but then you could have a family within a family.
That's even worse. XD
But to provide with an acutal, meaningful reply, i would say that my values, incorporated by society and my family lead me to that choice, perhaps i would think differently in other circumstances, but these values related discussion will always find a way to be a discussion since values are as valid as people.
So yeah, continue discussing a matter that will never conclude in a clear answer.
ok lets do this crappy 2 star movie style, you got drunk or high and she raped you guess what she now has your child. so as the nice guy you are and don't want the family to know its your child. you say you will help her until she can find a man, but she keeps on trying to hit on you at every turn.
 

Dango

New member
Feb 11, 2010
21,066
0
0
I don't really think so...

Seems like it would mess up the family a bit.
 

Zaverexus

New member
Jul 5, 2010
934
0
0
I would definitely say no, it might suck to turn it down, but it would be worse to deal everyday with the weirdness of knowing what happened and the concern that some family member would find out. As much as I can deal with other people judging me, if they're people you have to be around for your whole life its still not a pleasant situation.
 

Aurora Firestorm

New member
May 1, 2008
692
0
0
In terms of sexual morality by itself, technically it's not incest so there's nothing wrong. The immoral part would be squicking out the rest of your family, and causing general angst and instability, so I'd say...just don't do it, unless it's Seriously No Really True Love. Even then, give it some really intense thought.
 

SilentCom

New member
Mar 14, 2011
2,417
0
0
If a step sibling were to approach me like that, it would be very awkward. For one, I'm too insecure about getting "physical" with anyone at this point in time. Also, if the relationship turns sour, you can't really escape each other and the scenario could turn much worse once other people find out. Frankly, I think it just isn't worth it to have a "physical" relationship with a sibling, step or not.
 
May 5, 2010
4,831
0
0
Thundero13 said:
OmniscientOstrich said:
Thundero13 said:
You would see no problem in sleeping with your brother?
Well personally I don't want to sleep with my actual brother, i'm just saying that if some other siblings wanted to sleep with eachother i'd have no problem with that, or if I did want to sleep with my brother then i'd see no problem with that either
Um.....

.>

......
...
..Why not?
 

The Virgo

New member
Jul 21, 2011
995
0
0
Why not? She's not related to you!

The way I see it: If she doesn't share the same DNA as you, it's not incest. Oh, by the way, it's kind of obvious that this isn't a hypothetical question. Bow-chick-wow-wow!
 

Thundero13

New member
Mar 19, 2009
2,392
0
0
OmniscientOstrich said:
Thundero13 said:
OmniscientOstrich said:
Thundero13 said:
You would see no problem in sleeping with your brother?
Well personally I don't want to sleep with my actual brother, i'm just saying that if some other siblings wanted to sleep with eachother i'd have no problem with that, or if I did want to sleep with my brother then i'd see no problem with that either
Riiiiight, well all I can say is that I disagree. Step-bro/sis relationships where they are not actually related I have no problem with. But actual incest I just think is wrong. Just my opinion.
Meh, it's not like I really expected anyone to agree with me, i've just never seen the problem
 

Rpground

New member
Aug 9, 2009
229
0
0
Dango said:
I don't really think so...

Seems like it would mess up the family a bit.

ok i dont normally do this but...what is your avatar from? or made of? its hilariously cute P:
 

Philip Petrunak

New member
Apr 3, 2010
63
0
0
Look dude, if you and your step sister want to fuck you don't need to come here for permission. Just use a condom, or agree to have an abortion in the event you manufacture some genetic monstrosity.
 

Dango

New member
Feb 11, 2010
21,066
0
0
Rpground said:
Dango said:
I don't really think so...

Seems like it would mess up the family a bit.

ok i dont normally do this but...what is your avatar from? or made of? its hilariously cute P:
Clannad/Clannad After Story, my favorite anime.
 

l3o2828

New member
Mar 24, 2011
955
0
0
kidd25 said:
l3o2828 said:
kidd25 said:
l3o2828 said:
God no.
Just no,I hate incest.
Even if it isn't really incest.
Just...No. People who are part of your family one way or another... just no.
but then you could have a family within a family.
That's even worse. XD
But to provide with an acutal, meaningful reply, i would say that my values, incorporated by society and my family lead me to that choice, perhaps i would think differently in other circumstances, but these values related discussion will always find a way to be a discussion since values are as valid as people.
So yeah, continue discussing a matter that will never conclude in a clear answer.
ok lets do this crappy 2 star movie style, you got drunk or high and she raped you guess what she now has your child. so as the nice guy you are and don't want the family to know its your child. you say you will help her until she can find a man, but she keeps on trying to hit on you at every turn.
That's another kind of discussion, since there was rape , alcohol, unwanted pregnancy...besides i'm gay. lol joking.

But on topic: I would say No to her, yeah she can have my child, and if she wants to abort it, i would say go ahead, and i would help her with all i can, but i could never say yes to her.
 

Thundero13

New member
Mar 19, 2009
2,392
0
0
Frozen Donkey Wheel2 said:
Thundero13 said:
OmniscientOstrich said:
Thundero13 said:
You would see no problem in sleeping with your brother?
Well personally I don't want to sleep with my actual brother, i'm just saying that if some other siblings wanted to sleep with eachother i'd have no problem with that, or if I did want to sleep with my brother then i'd see no problem with that either
Um.....

.>

......
...
..Why not?
Well, it's just the only problem I can see with it is the dangers of children coming from an incestuous relationship, because of this I do think that incestuous couples shouldn't have children, at least not 'make their own' children
 

gigastrike

New member
Jul 13, 2008
3,112
0
0
It would be awkward as fuck, but I don't see anything morally wrong with it. Your "family relationship" is imaginary at best. You aren't related by blood so, as far as the universe is concerned, none of the physical problems with having a relation with a direct reletive apply.

Edit: Would I accept her offer? That depends on a lot of other things, but I'm definitly less likely to accept.
 

OmniscientOstrich

New member
Jan 6, 2011
2,879
0
0
MrHilter said:
OmniscientOstrich said:
MrHilter said:
And I don't consider somebody really being a relative through the technicalities of the bullshit institution of marriage. It's not like you gre up with this girl you only just met her. Situation A: If you're dad was seeing this girls mother and they weren't married you would not even be the step sister of this girl. You would not be by your definition related to her. Situation B: Exactly the same except your dad stood in a church for a day and that somehow makes her family. Bullshit.
Still family in both cases and still fucked in the head in both cases. If you want to fuck your sister by all means go ahead but I sure as hell wont.
Let me clarify, I WOULD NOT want to have relations with my Step brother/sister not because I think it's wrong but because I don't want to be in a relationship with someone I would have to live with. Also, there's no way in hell I'd be calling anyone I knew for about a couple of months or whatever brother or sister just because his/her mother happened to marry my dad. Face it, nobody immediately thinks of someone as their sibling just because this sort of thing happens. They're just some stranger in your house and while you might grow to warm to them and become their friend, the fact remains they are not your sibling and you are not related. Period.
 

OmniscientOstrich

New member
Jan 6, 2011
2,879
0
0
Philip Petrunak said:
Look dude, if you and your step sister want to fuck you don't need to come here for permission. Just use a condom, or agree to have an abortion in the event you manufacture some genetic monstrosity.
-_- I'm pretty sure his question is hypothetical and that he in fact has no step sister. Unless your comment was facetious in which case that was quite good.