Moral discussion: would you?

[Dr. Danger]

I would not but I don't find it strange that others would.

The reason I would not is just the possibility that I would always have them in my life. It's not just a fling. If it turns out bad then there's no escape from an awkward memory.

 

[Linsenman]

but then you could have a family within a family.

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

OT: Ummmmm maybe. No one really knows until they're in the situation themselves.

 

[thecoreyhlltt]

when my mom re-married my now stepdad, he had two daughters both older than me and both very attractive. i'm not gonna lie, i thought about it. but considering how awkward it was around them having had those thoughts, i couldn't imagine "THE EPIC OF AWKWARD" it would be had i fooled around with one of them.

so no

 

[Xhuliano Pula]

This can end in four ways.

1. (happy ending for you) She is your "friend with benifits".

2.Nothing happens

3. Mom walks in on you two just as you have put whip cream on her and have started to lick it off (if your into that kind of stuff ).


4. You both fall in love, get your parents to break up, run away together, get married in Vegas and live the rest of your happy live together in a small Italian village next to the sea, where you make a modest income as a professonal baker while she raises your twin boy and girl who later grow up to be partners in a oil and natural gas company in Russia where they will make millions. (Because thats what always happens) -_-

 

[Jedoro]

Yes. If there's no blood relation, it's fair game.

 

[dcdude171]

Haha , this actually happend in my family , well kinda , a guy , and like my 3rd aunt fell in love , so they got married , but then , there parents were both widowed and liked each other so they go married as well ..... so technaically even tho it was there relationsip first they are married to there step brother and sister . Im not realted to them tho , as my mom was adopted........ yah my familys weird

 

[Richardplex]

Hmm....
Alright, I'm not sure, but how about a reverse question?
You and your brother/sister are adopted from different families, and at some point in your lives (when you are both of age), he/she suggests "relations", how do you react?
Personally, even if he/she isn't related by blood, they were raised as brother and sister, so therefore it's still kind of wrong (that's my opinion of my situation, I'm still stumped on the original).

Unlikely to happen because of the Oedipus complex, but for aforementioned reasons, still cool with.

Now if you don't mind, I'm going to cause some form of bodily harm for mentioning the work of Freud in a serious manner.

Yes, but you're forgetting that Oedipus complex only theoretically applies in a situation where pheromones are produced by someone of a similar genetic composition. In this case that still wouldn't be true.

I'm referring to not feeling attraction to those you've known since your 4 or younger, distinctly possible I've mentioned the wrong freudian idea here.

I have no problem with actual incest (so long as no procreation involved) so yes, I'd hit that. No one is harmed, no one is inconvenienced, no-one has the right to call it wrong.

in this scenario procreation wouldn't matter since the two aren't related.

I was justifying my okayness with incest and nothing being wrong with it before someone launched at me with that particular problem. Since I have nothing wrong with them doing whatever they want even if they are related, I certainly have no problem with them if they aren't.

 

[Torrasque]

I would never put myself in such a sticky situation. I value the stability of my family too much to complicate it like that.

Pretty much this.
Emotions would get involved, guaranteed, and that would fuck up the family.
If it was some distant cousin that you are not related to by blood, that you don't see that often, possibly, but thats another story altogether.

 

[Android2137]

No. You may not be blood related, but for all intents and purposes, you are brother and sister. Besides, if you guys go out and then have a messy break-up, it's not just your relationship that will suffer, but your parents'. Moreover, how would they feel about this to begin with?

 

[imperialwar]

This can end in four ways.

1. (happy ending for you) She is your "friend with benifits".

2.Nothing happens

3. Mom walks in on you two just as you have put whip cream on her and have started to lick it off (if your into that kind of stuff ).


4. You both fall in love, get your parents to break up, run away together, get married in Vegas and live the rest of your happy live together in a small Italian village next to the sea, where you make a modest income as a professonal baker while she raises your twin boy and girl who later grow up to be partners in a oil and natural gas company in Russia where they will make millions. (Because thats what always happens) -_-

Point 3B. Mom walks in on you two just after you put whipped cream on your step sister and you've started licking it off and says "my that looks fun, can i join in."

OT: This kind of thing can be lots of fun, and good practice, look forward to her making lots of girlfriends and them having sleep overs: orgy FTW
Serious note though, use protection, last thing you want is a baby buldge blowing your little secret

 

[kypsilon]

If I liked her enough, sure I would. But I'd better really like her, because we'd be house-mates even if things went sour, at least until one of us moved out.

 

[Mr. Gency]

In such situations, I find that it's best to ask the Medic.

 

[Kenny3k]

Oo, how hot is she? Actually scrap that. Probably. It would make for some awkward dinner times if parents found out though.

mom:*looks at you across the dinner table "so how was the Other meal"

your sister coughs violently and begins to choke, eventually she dislodges the food in her throat.

mom: *looks at your sister "or was it your sister that stole all the cookies"?

i can just see it, would laugh so hard.

 

[Eggsnham]

"Hey, mom, I just finished having sex with susey, what's for dinner?"

No. No I would not.

 

[ChickenZombie]

Not okay. Its not a matter of biological issues, thats just gross. Legally they are family, if you make an advance you are a pervert. If you are that desperate, you need your genitals put into a straitjacket.

 

[likalaruku]

Consider this situation:
Your parents have divorced, and after a while one of your parents remarries. You get a new sister or brother, a few months younger then you. (in this situation its assumed youre around 17). You think your step-sibling is atrractive but you dont really want to do anything.
However, one day, they approach you while your parents are out and suggests, though some hidden meanings, that you and them could try getting physical. The question is, would you? And why or why not?

3 words; Watch "Marmalade Boy."

 

[Fugitive Panda]

Considering that I have no real objections to actual incest, faux-incest isn't even a thing to me.

So the answer is yes.

 

[Slick Samurai]

This is an interesting thread here. From what I've gathered, what most people have a problem with isn't incest, but marriage. It would seem to me that the line is drawn when adults come together in marriage, the children of the adults before the marriage cannot be together. This is especially strange, since I have gathered that a societal stigmata is in place against step-parents. Maybe the children are coping with the loss of the replaced parent, deceased or not, and the step-parent isn't and never will be the real parent to them.

However, when I come to this thread I read a lot of remarks that claim that the step-sibling is a real sibling. I see the word "incest" used frequently which I have always assumed to refer to the procreation between two genetically similar beings. I wonder, if the two children were in a relationship before the parents were married, would it be incest?

No, I do not think so, to society at least they would be and average couple. But with parental marriage added to the mix, it becomes a shunned incest.

Interesting.

 

[NoeL]

If we're still all living under the same roof, probably not (I'd get my ass kicked if the parents caught us, and it could potentially cause them to separate). If both of us had moved out, absolutely.

Captcha = hugger-mugger... good advice.


EDIT: Has anyone seen the awesome Dutch film Flodder? The mother has five kids to four or five different fathers (can't remember if the youngest two share a father). Anyway, in one scene the mum walks in to see her number two, Kees (pronounced "Case", like "Casey". Played by Tatjana Simic. Google her - you won't regret it) getting plowed by her number three, also named Kees (because by the time you get to the third kid it's ok to recycle names). She beats him and says "Get off your sister!", and he runs back to his own room. It's never mentioned again, so it must be a pretty frequent event in that household. Hell, if my half sister looked like Tatjana Simic and opened her legs to everyone I might do the same (just kidding. That'd be gross). Funny movie though - worth checking out if you've never seen it.

 

[blazinwings]

you're asking if it's morally wrong. no, it's not. however, it's also not morally wrong to put your dick into a beehive. i think you know that it's not morally wrong, but that it'll have consequences. the answer is no.