RustlessPotato said:
Just finished the third season and I can't believe how hilarious it is. You really have to stick with it to get all the jokes, though.
And that is exactly why it failed. Everything was a running joke. It's kind of shocking how many people do NOT watch every episode of a TV series, but rather watch an episode here or there. That's why bland, repetitive, "seen one episode you've seen them all" shows like House or CSI get huge numbers, but complex story driven shows like The Wire that force you to keep track of dozens and dozens of characters and elaborate plot lines struggle along with small audiences. Someone tuning in halfway through a season of Arrested Development MIGHT understand 25% of the jokes. If they're lucky.
As for underrated shows...I honestly don't know. Most of the shows I like were at least critically acclaimed, if not also popular.
Hmm. You know, VEEP is a pretty funny show that I don't hear much about. Let's go with VEEP.
Captcha: spoilers
No, not really captcha. Calm down.