Most unintentionally creepy game you've ever played.

[YamadaJisho]

For me, it was Metroid Prime. Playing it through wasn't bad, and it's still a really fun game. But one day, I decided "Hey, Samus wouldn't be hearing all this background music, so I'll go for a more realistic experience by turning the music off." Yeah, more realism in a metroid game is like making a chihuaha less annoying by tying a bow to it's head. But I digress.

Anyway, there are all kinds of sounds in that game that go on in the background that are completely obscured by the music. I highly suggest trying it out sometime.

So, what's the most unintentionally creepy game you've ever played?

 

[the spud]

The legend of zelda Majoras Mask

I was gonna say it before anyone else would.

That damn freak in the clocktower scared me to hell

I'll have to try that out in metroid prime.

 

[kypsilon]

Barbie on the NES. Anyone whose played that game knows.

...and they can't unknow...

 

[boag]

The Clock Tower Games, being a little girl with no means of defending yourself inside a giant puzzle with crazy shit trying to kill you was super freaky.

 

[Dirty Hipsters]

The Clock Tower Games, being a little girl with no means of defending yourself inside a giant puzzle with crazy shit trying to kill you was super freaky.

Someone forgot the meaning of the word "unintentional."

 

[OptimisticPessimist]

Kingdom Hearts. When you stop to think about it, you're controlling a deformed child who's only allies are two mentally unstable furries in a bid to save the fucking universe. He encounters several adults along the way, and they seem perfectly at ease with this. Yeah, nothing odd about that at all.

 

[Grey_Gore]

Any of the recent Elder Scrolls games. Every single NPC looks like they're either soulless or robots.

[sub]The stares.... THE STARES![/sub]

 

[-Drifter-]

Strange things started to happen to me when I reached West Elizabeth in Red Dead Redemption. My horse dropped dead for no reason, I was attacked by an invisible creature, and a sharp shooter bet me $0 that I couldn't shoot more birds than him (there were no birds in the sky.) All of this was going on at night no less.

 

[sketch_zeppelin]

Ecco the Dolphine: Defender of the future for the PS2 (originally dreamcast). I've always been kinda creeped out when it comes to exploring dark underwather areas...and thats where about 2/3 of the game takes place

 

[Kevo32A]

I don't know why but even though I love the series, something about timesplitters 2 always freaked me out. Same with Halo 2. I can't pin it down but these games always freaked me out a bit.

 

[YamadaJisho]

That it? That all anyone has?

 

[Anarchemitis]

Ace Combat 5, the mission "Sea of Chaos". 'The Journey Begins' playing back on a record player is the song of death when it reminds me that I took the lives of thousands of sailors.

 

[Javarock]

Daggerfall... WHY IS THAT NOISE FOLLOWING ME D:

 

[Fieldy409_v1legacy]

i admit ive gotten a little creeped out exploring caves in oblivion sometimes.