Movie Review: valkyrie

Recommended Videos

Dabamash

New member
Sep 10, 2008
27
0
0
Valkyrie is a historical thriller/drama based on the plot to take over the Nazi controlled government called "operation: Valkyrie". The main aim of the operation was to remove Nazi control and make a truce with the Allies, to prevent the destruction of Europe. To do this, the (German) resistance went about trying to convince the army/goverment that the SS (German Secret Service, controlled by Hitler) were trying to stage a coup, thus giving permission to the resistance to lock down the goverment in Berlin using a reserve army, and by doing that, liberating Nazi controlled Germany. The main issue was that Valkyrie could only be implemented if Hitler was dead. The irony was that they got Hitler to sign the amended version of Valkyrie, in effect, signing his own death warrant. It was up to the main character, Colonel Claus von Stauffenberg (Tom Cruise) to actually kill Hitler, which he chose to do by bombing a conference. Unfortunately the attempt failed.

It's interesting to think about how the war, and following wars such as the Cold War could have been so very different if this operation had succeeded. It's also nice to see a film that takes into account that not all Germans had the Nazi mentality at the time, and some were actually actively fighting back.

-----------------------------------------------------​


I went to see Valkyrie without really knowing what to expect, I knew it had Tom Cruise in it and lots of guns and stuff, so it fitted into my catagory of "movies that will probably be vaguely good". It turns out that it didn't have as much violence as I originally thought, but I wasn't dissapointed as it makes up for it with an excellent plot, well thought out actors, effects and good directing.

I was quite surprised at the amount of A-list actors that were in it, I knew that it had Tom Cruise, but I was pleasently surprised by the appearences of Bill Nighy, Eddie Izzard, kenneth Branagh, Tom Wilkinson and Terence Stamp, who all played convincing roles considering they were playing Germans. I think Tom Cruise did especially well, as it is always hard to make the viewer relate with the character when the actor is so well known.
Some of the main cast

Although no attempt was made at speaking German or even speaking with a German accent, all of the actors played their given roles convincingly and passionately, which really drew me into the movie, and actually made me feel for the characters. The guy who played Hitler was probably the least convincing, but he didn't show up much, so it didn't really matter.

Nice Ass

There was a good mix of action and plot. The story was quite deep and involved, and kept me gripped all the way through to the end.

This movie is very crisp and good-looking. All of the props seem very authentic, the effects are not over-done and none of the acting is sloppy or poor. It all works together to immerse you in the plot. At no point did I think "hmm, that was a bit surreal". Except maybe how Tom Cruise's glass eye magically moved in the same direction as his fully functioning one. Oh, and the fact that a bomb going off directly under Hitler's feet didn't so much as break his fingernail.

the actual aftermath of the bomb

To wrap this up, I think that you shouldn't go out of your way to see this movie, as it isn't really doing anything that we haven't seen before, but if you are near a cinema and have a few hours to kill, I think you could do much worse than watching this. I mean, you could go and see Twilight :|

-----------------------------------------------------​

Interesting fact: The display of Swastikas is illegal in Germany and some of the filming locations were charged by the authorities. Bet they were gutted.


(I welcome any comments on where I can improve this, don't feel guilty about calling it crap :D )
 

bermyduck

New member
Feb 20, 2008
136
0
0
Valkyrie was not the name of the plot to assassinate Hitler, but the name of the operation used as part of the plot to overtake government.
Also, is there anyone who can convincingly play Hitler?
Loved the movie though!
 

Calax

New member
Jan 16, 2009
429
0
0
bermyduck said:
Valkyrie was not the name of the plot to assassinate Hitler, but the name of the operation used as part of the plot to overtake government.
Also, is there anyone who can convincingly play Hitler?
Loved the movie though!
Ever seen Downfall?
 

ultimatechance

New member
Dec 24, 2008
583
0
0
Calax said:
bermyduck said:
Valkyrie was not the name of the plot to assassinate Hitler, but the name of the operation used as part of the plot to overtake government.
Also, is there anyone who can convincingly play Hitler?
Loved the movie though!
Ever seen Downfall?
ahhhh, beat me to the punch. If you dont know what movie hes talking about, its the one movie where everyone takes that one clip and puts fake subtitles on, and then titles it something like "Hitler Gets Banned From Xbox Live", or "Loses his Car Insurance", or whatever. But yeah, a really good hitler, and is much better than the one in valkyrie.
 

Dabamash

New member
Sep 10, 2008
27
0
0
bermyduck said:
Valkyrie was not the name of the plot to assassinate Hitler, but the name of the operation used as part of the plot to overtake government.
Also, is there anyone who can convincingly play Hitler?
Loved the movie though!
Ah yeah, good point. I'll amend that.

EDIT: Also added some images.
 

Dabamash

New member
Sep 10, 2008
27
0
0
Is it possible to resize images with bbcode? I've tried
Code:
[color=blue] img=200x100  Image  /img [/color]
EDIT: Never mind, used HTML instead.
 

Trace2010

New member
Aug 10, 2008
1,019
0
0
I liked Valkyrie...it was a story that many uneducated Americans needed to hear at least.
 

Silvertongue

New member
Jul 2, 2008
280
0
0
I adored the movie. I immediately decided I wanted it on DVD as son as I left the theater. I loved every second of it, and it made me do things I normally laugh at others for doing, like sitting on the edge of my seat and whispering frantically to characters who can't hear me. xD
 

PedroSteckecilo

Mexican Fugitive
Feb 7, 2008
6,732
0
0
I wasn't fond of this film, it centered far more around the "assasination" of Hitler than it should have and seems to wish that audiences weren't aware that Hitler survived and killed himself 9 months later.
 

mark_n_b

New member
Mar 24, 2008
729
0
0
You found the ending a bit depressing though?

*eyes roll* lines like that can be wholly omitted.

And connecting a generally accepted good point like: "deep and involved story" to something you generally find boring makes you look kind of stupid. You should phrase it in a manner that suggests while the story was of key importance it did not come at the expense of the overall energy and action of the film (or something to that effect) here you have just said that the film has an intense story and was not boring without making yourself look like a Michael Bay fanboy.
 

bermyduck

New member
Feb 20, 2008
136
0
0
PedroSteckecilo said:
I wasn't fond of this film, it centered far more around the "assasination" of Hitler than it should have and seems to wish that audiences weren't aware that Hitler survived and killed himself 9 months later.
I thought maybe the fact that you never actually saw Hitler after the bomb went off was perhaps hinting at a cover-up. Perhaps Hitler was killed but replaced by a double, perhaps why he committed suicide and ended up in a ditch, on fire, so the remains couldn't be accurately identified and proven that it was a double. I thought it peculiar that he was not shown at all after the bomb.