Comocat said:
Also the movie "Up". Who the hell gets teary 5 minutes into an animated feature? Great movie though.
Seconded. I don't think I even came close to crying the first time I saw it. The second time, a year later in my eleventh-grade English class, was a different story. The teacher showed us three clips in order for us to gauge our emotional responses to it (the first two being the death of Bambi's mom and a succession of sports injuries), and though I remembered the first five minutes being sad, I was nothing short of shocked when I found myself crying for the first time in almost ten years.
On the subject of not thinking I'd cry because I'd seen the movie already, there's
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2. I did cry the first time, during the Pensieve flashback scene, which I suppose was already a surprise since I didn't do so when I read that scene in the book. But I figured I'd be fine when I saw the movie again less than a week later. For whatever reason, I cried even harder the second time, and it wasn't until the third time (considerably longer afterwards) that I made it through that scene okay. Naturally, Viewing #4 somehow managed to drive me to tears again.