So I just bought Prototype, it cost 39.99 USD new, while it cost 5 dollars less used. Although I could have saved like 5 dollars, I didn't think it was much of a difference. Seriously, if I don't have the original case and booklet it feels less satisfying than owning a new copy. Also, it may seem insignificant, but I hate buying used games from Gamestop and then having to try and rip off the used stickers, they stick too well to the plastic and leave marks. Lastly, I hate the fact that although I paid for a new game, it was already fucking opened, the case was slightly worn and the goddamn disk itself had small light scratches.
Do you think it is worth buying the new or used games if they are only around 5 dollars (US prices) cheaper or more expensive? Which do you prefer if the difference in price is that small?