Next Xbox Practically Confirmed "Always-Online"

Recommended Videos

Souplex

Souplex Killsplosion Awesomegasm
Jul 29, 2008
10,312
0
0
Azaraxzealot said:
Johnny Novgorod said:
I don't take "practically confirmed" news very seriously but yes, an always-online console would put the suck in sucky.
I figure with the huge amount of rumors surrounding the always-online functionality it's almost 100% confirmed at this point. That's why I say "practically".

After all about the same level of rumors surrounded the PS4 and its hardware and most of those turned out to be true.
Clearly you don't understand how rumors work.
Someone says one stupid thing, and it snowballs out of control when enough people take the stupid thing seriously.
 

likalaruku

New member
Nov 29, 2008
4,290
0
0
If it is, I can already see not the backlash from angry users who will still buy the console & the games legally until they just get used to it, but the huge boost in piracy it will make in the console's first year. It always starts with some hackers who like to "stick it to the man" & look upon DRM of any kind as a challenge. They will find a workaround, create an emulator, & start releasing hacked ROMs. Then people who want the games who avidly appose the Always Online will download the ROMS out of spite. I will freaking bet money on this.

Personally, as a PC gamer who plays a lot of MMOs, I don't really see the problem. It's server stability that you have to worry about. I guess also the lack of ability to play the game 10 years latter because the servers are down. But would it really kill online multiplayer games to convert into purchasable offline single player games when that time comes?
 

faefrost

New member
Jun 2, 2010
1,280
0
0
TheCommanders said:
Treeinthewoods said:
Always online means nothing to me, I am blessed with with stable internet and I don't think I've been "offline" for over ten years now.
See, I originally thought, like you, that this wouldn't effect me, even if I did acknolewge that many people don't have stable internet. But there are two huge problems that have nothing to do with your personal internet and are out of your control.

1. Downtime. All game servers have downtime, most of it unscheduled. It's mostly unnoticeable for new games, but for games that are even only a few years old it can be a real problem if the game or console is forced to be always online. For example, the other day I was playing Dragon Age 2, and was notified while playing that I was disconnected from the server. I had my laptop online right next to me, so I know it wasn't my Internet, and I was still logged into xbox live, so it wasn't my console. This was no problem right now, but with an always online console, you would be kicked immediately from the game if like Sim City, the game itself was always online, or in between 0 and 3 minutes if it wasn't. Considering this happens pretty much every time I play a game that requires me to log in to play it, this could become a real problem really fast.

2. This is the much bigger issue. Your games, the ones you purchased with your own money and have sitting on your shelf, will now have an expiration date. In 10, maybe 20, or if we're really lucky 30+ years, microsoft will shut down their nextbox servers for good, and all your games are now small shiny Frisbees. Most developers will have shut down servers for their individual games long before this to make room for new titles (servers are expensive). You might say, "Ah, but by that time they'll probably have built in the ability to play offline and allow that after they shut down their service." They will not. Why? They have no incentive to. In fact, they have incentive not to. If you can't play your old games, that means you'll have to buy their new games. Why do you think consoles avoid backward comparability like the plague (besides an excuse for HD re-releases)? They want you to keep buying their stuff, and if you are content with your current stuff, omg, you might not buy their new stuff!

For these reasons, even though my Internet is pretty much on 24/7 anyway, I am firmly against alway online, and you might not be as unaffected as you think.
10, 20 or 30 years? Wow! You are being overly optomistic. MS shut the servers supporting the original X-Box less than 2 years after the 360 released. Which right there shows the heart of the problem. I have a 1st Gen PS2 that I can still play every game I ever bought for it, no problems. I have a Dreamcast that I adore. 15+ years going strong. I have a Sega Genesis that still works and has enjoyable content. I think I bought it around 1990. I fully own them. They will only stop working when the hardware dies and I can no longer scrounge a replacement. I do not need Sega in order for my console to work. I have 2 consoles that have outlasted them by a human generation. But this new XBox? Even after a $500 purchase, Microsoft will still own it. The day THEY turn off the lights is the day it becomes a brick permanently and forever. No replacement hardware to be bought, no ancient Somic the Hedgehog cartridge to play. The day that their accounting department says it is no longer worthwhile is the day my property dies. I do not like that. None of us should.
 

Tim Chuma

New member
Jul 9, 2010
236
0
0
It sucks enough that it has a delay when I turn the Xbox360 at the moment and I am having connection issues. What is it for? Just to show me ads? I could watch TV for that! I do not play online enough to justify having a subscription to Xbox Live, why should I pay twice for my internet connection? Pah!
 

WouldYouKindly

New member
Apr 17, 2011
1,431
0
0
I've never needed another reason to join the PC gaming master race.

That being said, nothing against Sony, but they've already won. They don't have the bullshit hardware they need to design for like the Wii U or the always online connection that'll piss people off. So yeah, PCs for me because they're actually no more expensive and do a hell of a lot more than just play games(though I will limit what I put on it for the sake of security). So yes, my next major purchase will be a 6 core gaming PC with a minimum of 8gb ram and preferably a 7700 series amd card or a 640+ series nvidia card. I can find this on Newegg for about 550-600 bucks. It'll even probably have an HDMI connection so I'd just need a HDMI cable to play it on my TV.
 

Andy of Comix Inc

New member
Apr 2, 2010
2,234
0
0
Berithil said:
Meh...

Quite honestly, as a Playstation gamer, the upcoming news about the next Xbox doesn't really have me on the edge of my seat, I'll be interested to see how severe the whole "Always online DRM" thing will be, but I'll remain unaffected.
As an Xbox gamer, the upcoming news about the next Xbox doesn't have me on the edge of my seat. I'm pretty happy I play games on PC and Wii U - as for console exclusives, I'll probably be picking up a PS4. Maybe. No backwards compatibility on it makes me more inclined to pick up a cheap PS3 instead so I can play all the PS games I missed over the past decade or so.
 

Elementary - Dear Watson

RIP Eleuthera, I will miss you
Nov 9, 2010
2,980
0
0
The problem is that the people who develop things like this are obviously people who live in worlds with a decent, always active internet connection... it ignore people like myself who get shifted from base to base in the forces, often forward deployed to units for courses and things where I CAN'T get the internet. And if I go spending a lot of money getting the internet installed for a few months before being posted again, it is really crap internet, because bases tend to be connected to the wider world through 1 hub for the entire base, and most of that is being used for our military systems!

Currently I have access to internet which maxes at 1MB/Sec... and that is really good for the forces! I can't even watch youtube in low res... without waiting the length of the video again in buffer...

I'll be sticking to the 360 and PS from now on if this comes into fruition.
 

Bertylicious

New member
Apr 10, 2012
1,400
0
0
I be PC fo' life blud, but some of my peeps just got a XBox for PES and Cricket. I don' think they even own a network cable. They is just in their living room with Mac books for playing fantasy football leauge.

They is not gonna want an always online XBox, innit.
 

veloper

New member
Jan 20, 2009
4,597
0
0
Too much wishful thinking going on here.
M$ will probably succeed, because outside some small savvy audiences here and there, not nearly enough gamers care about consumer rights. The rise of DRM on the PC is enough indication.

Now if you quit to become a PC gamer, you'll likely buy more PC hardware and run windows on it. The upgrade cycle in PC land is what allows M$ to keep selling new versions of their core product, so M$ wins.

Consoles are sold at a loss and the markup on games have to make up for it, so when the people who only(or mostly) buy used, ignore the xbox and go to a competitor, M$ still wins.

You know you won't migrate to the WiiU, if you weren't interested on it already, so that only leaves Sony and they aren't too keen on used sales either, so don't get your hopes up.
Expect massive corporate dick to penetrate your hobby, so that way atleast you won't be disappointed in the next gen.
 

Spygon

New member
May 16, 2009
1,105
0
0
Azaraxzealot said:
http://www.ign.com/articles/2013/04/25/next-xbox-functionality-pricing-reportedly-outed

Welp, guess I was right to jump the console ship when I did. This is just infuriating, because they're alienating the majority of the current xbox fanbase which probably doesn't have fiber optic or comcast internet. I myself have to work on an internet with a 128 kb/s bandwith cap, and can't afford to have ANYTHING taking up bandwith if the rest of the household wants to even use the internet (especially my mother, who works from home a lot).

Yet they also say it's up to the publisher... so I wonder if the only games requiring always-online are going to be Activision games and EA games...

Anyways, I REALLY wish that the gaming press, upon Microsoft OFFICIALLY declaring it is always-online, would just boo the speaker off the stage, but I know that will never happen :(
Really IGN picking up a story from a tech blogger that has nothing to do with microsoft or then gaming industry is practially confirmation for you?.The guy must be loving the traffic to his blog because of these rumors it is like he saw something that would do that for him and just wrote that oh wait.

I am fed up with everybody jumping on the rumor express at the moment and wont even humour any information until it comes out of microsoft mouth now.As i heard so many things ranging from always online,no disk drive and wont play used games that it is getting stupid.
 

Gunner 51

New member
Jun 21, 2009
1,218
0
0
I'm still going to wait until the big unveiling of the new console before passing judgement. But if the rumours are true, I do not truly know whether I shall return to my PC gaming roots or stay with consoles. Either way, you get short-changed by publishers whose greed knows no bounds. Hell, they're both as bad as each other sometimes - and that's not including the vocal gamers within those two cames.

But as an interesting footnote, an exodus of former 10 year old racist, sexist idiotic gamers from X-box Live headed toward the crowds of PC gamers, should if nothing else - make things a little more interesting. The question which begs to be asked is "Who is stuck with who?"
 

Cowabungaa

New member
Feb 10, 2008
10,806
0
0
Meatspinner said:
What's so bad about Win8? Other then the "I'm old and It's different" rhetoric?
On that subject you might find this enlightening:
Whether it's actually literally unuseable is to be disputed seeing as how plenty of my classmates use it, but he raises plenty of valid points especially when you talk about usability.

Hence why I don't really trust Microsoft if they really decide to go through with an always-online Xbox. Windows 7 was good enough but they're so on-and-off that I doubt their infrastructure is good enough to not have more than enough problems with an always-online system.
 

Colt47

New member
Oct 31, 2012
1,065
0
0
McFazzer said:
My console of choice will be the Wii with the iPad peripheral if things continue as they are.
I've already blown my console budget on a radeon 7970 graphics card since they were offering three free games with it. Not even going to try to get into the next console gen until I see what the libraries look like 1 year post release.
 

Something Amyss

Aswyng and Amyss
Dec 3, 2008
24,759
0
0
Spygon said:
Really IGN picking up a story from a tech blogger that has nothing to do with microsoft or then gaming industry is practially confirmation for you?
Thank you thank you thank you thank you thank you!

Paul Thurrot is not just a blogger posting unofficial stuff, he's a blogger posting unofficial stuff that undercuts his previous unofficial stuff and appears to be the sole origin about many of these rumours. People are treating this as fact when it looks like it's a complete asspull.

Elementary - Dear Watson said:
The problem is that the people who develop things like this are obviously people who live in worlds with a decent, always active internet connection...
Regardless of whether or not the rumour is true, this is a fairly decent point in general. How does patching things go on your console? It's an oft-slow thing on my broadband, which is much better than what you've got (Not that you can help it or anything, just saying).

And Sony's slow as shiiiiiiit. I'm glad I have PS+, because it downloads the updates in the middle of the night.

Anyway, the problem of the executives being out of touch is a real one. The problem of an always-online console? Not so certain.
 

Elementary - Dear Watson

RIP Eleuthera, I will miss you
Nov 9, 2010
2,980
0
0
Zachary Amaranth said:
Elementary - Dear Watson said:
The problem is that the people who develop things like this are obviously people who live in worlds with a decent, always active internet connection...
Regardless of whether or not the rumour is true, this is a fairly decent point in general. How does patching things go on your console? It's an oft-slow thing on my broadband, which is much better than what you've got (Not that you can help it or anything, just saying).

And Sony's slow as shiiiiiiit. I'm glad I have PS+, because it downloads the updates in the middle of the night.

Anyway, the problem of the executives being out of touch is a real one. The problem of an always-online console? Not so certain.
Oh god... What I tend to do is take it with me to my parents if I visit on the weekend and use their 50mb/s speed broadband instead...

To get the internet on my xbox in the forces I have to route it through my laptop... which makes things unbearable! :/