Congrats guys. You've taken a show that was borderline not worth watching and managed to make it funny. I'll definitely be back for next week's episode.
Extra points in your favor (and there were several this time):
1) the argument was actually interesting. I may not play either Kingdom Hearts or Half-Life 2 (got bored halfway through 1 and I hate not getting through series from the beginning), but I could definitely see real arguments for both sides as to which was the biggest broken promise. (Also, it was Oni 2).
2) NO JONES SODA! Yay, you guys seemed slightly less like shills! I have no problem with the idea of the soda itself, but it simply does not fit in with the concept of the show. How about milk or juice next time? It's a little harder to drink but it will look awesomely gross whenever either of the guys coughs it up.
3) Funny! The jokes actually worked this time. And yes, you have magically made Italian and Japanese the same accent. Weirdest plausibly racist combination I have ever seen.
Keep it up and I'll keep watchin'.