I'm not that weird I guess, but I felt like posting something for once, and this topic was interesting enough.
I'm a fairly small, somewhat effeminate guy and I'm more creative than athletic. I tend to prefer women with some masculine features. I can't stand fragile midgets who hang onto their burly tough guyfriends for dear life. I like women who are tough and strong, with muscular builds (but not mutated professional bodybuilder), and aren't afraid of getting their hands dirty. Messy hair and tattoos are a plus. I can't stand fake tans, though; light tans are perfect.
So basically, my tastes are the inverse of most 'nerdy' guys. I think the best example of the type of women I like, both in appearance and personality, is the character Noi from the manga Dorohedoro. (Oddly enough I resemble Shin somewhat, although with long hair and dark eyes.)