ok...this just trips me out..

[WorldCritic]

I think of Darth Vader... it got it right.
Shit then I'll try again. I'm thinking of Fuma Monou, it answers Touya from Card Captor Sakura. Ha! I got you! It actually got somewhat close though. Shit, never mind.

EDIT: I finally beat it. Take that stupid genie thing.

 

[IronDefender410]

It guessed itself... and was right. This thing is Skynet or something.

 

[Death God]

Wow. It guessed Solid Snake, Master Chief, Shrek, Frosty the Snowman, and Genie. That thing is creepy!
Edit: I BEAT IT! I guessed James from Silent Hill and it was wrong. But then it beat me at least 10 more times after that. That thing is good.

 

[[.redacted]]

Fuck me... It knew Nymeria!

But it didn't know Deneve ^^

 

[Falko]

This thing got:
Michael Jackson (Some funny questions)
Pikachu
Charmander
Godzilla
James Bond
It even got Mike from BitterSweet Candy Bowl!
WHAT IS THIS THING!?

 

[Superbeast]

Couldn't guess Rand al'Thor from Wheel of Time

I guess Shea Ohmsford is close? Or Skeeve?

It Didn't get it until the third attempt (where I had 7 questions asking me if the character was from popular Fantasy Series X, which isn't really "mysterious" by that point but rather an elaborate game of "Guess Who").

++EDIT++

Rather amusingly, do it thinking about one of your friends.

Question: Is this character a friend of yours? (Yes)
Answer: A Friend of Yours!

So there is some iffy guessing there

 

[ethan22122]

Holy shit, it guessed slender man :0

 

[DirgeNovak]

It's mostly amazing, but it sometimes does some truly stupid things. When I tried to make it guess Sten from Dragon Age, it asked me "Does your character have white hair?" (Yes) and then tried Zevran (who is blonde). And it frequently asks the same question twice.

Other than that, it's incredible.

 

[enriel]

At first, it offended my honor. I was thinking of Christina Aguilera and it guessed Ke$ha. Awful.

But then round two, he figured it out.

 

[Wharrgarble]

I was so sure it was gonna get mine wrong... The questions felt like they had nothing to do with it.

SUDDENLY BAM! I GOT PUNKED!

Skynet man! It's gonna get us!

 

[enriel]

HA! Beat it with Cillian Murphy!

 

[Aur0ra145]

It got:

Darth Maul
Big Daddy (after 1 incorrect guess)
Dr. Strangelove

Never got:

Big Jake (John Wayne character)

 

[MercurySteam]

As of now The Atkinator knows almost everyone from all currently released games. Gotta try games that have yet to be released.

 

[Phlakes]

It got fucking Brian from Quest 64. QUEST 64. NOBODY'S EVER PLAYED IT. But it knows...

EDIT: I just tried Lily from Star Trek: First Contact and beat it.

 

[someotherguy]

It didn't get dan rather, but HOLY HELL IT GOT HANK HILL.

Made my day.

 

[infohippie]

Okay, I'm impressed that it guessed the Normandy from Mass Effect in only ten questions.

Edit: ...but the Mako stumped it. As did the Destiny Ascension.