Plot devices that ruin any movie

Recommended Videos

bificommander

New member
Apr 19, 2010
434
0
0
May I second the time travel 'twist' which boils down to 'the reason you had to/were able to travel in time was that you changed something when you travel in time'. Besides a dumb paradox, it's also so utterly predictable by now (I think I saw 4 seperate Voyager episode that did this), so it neatly ties in to the fake-twist gripe before.
 

1blackone

New member
Dec 14, 2007
91
0
0
An easy answer the OP would be to throw a dart at anything on tvtropes.org

However, the one trope that reeaaaaly gets me is the "it was too late all along". Its when the protagonists are chasing a mcguffin or trying to get somewhere only to find out that 1. it never existed or 2. it was already "'SPLODED!" long before they got there.

EDIT:[removed some spoilers i put as examples here]

Its the ultimate dick move by script writers to try to make their work seems super intellectual and introspective. In their heads they must be like, " dam i can't resolve this story cleanly...lets just say it was kerblowed up and pretend that i really wanted to convey that the journey the hero takes is what matters! yea, that'll work!"
 
May 28, 2009
3,698
0
0
BuchalBainne said:
My biggest gripe has to be Green Rocks (ie some magical substance that does stuff to advance the plot). I understand that it has to be used sometimes but at least try to explain why it does what it does.
Unless it's the force, then don't try to explain it at all.

Fuck midichlorians.
 

octafish

New member
Apr 23, 2010
5,137
0
0
Heavy handed setups. As Robert Downey Jr's character Harry says in Kiss Kiss Bang Bang "Okay, I apologize. That is a terrible scene. It's like, why was that in the movie? Gee do you think maybe it'll come back later? Maybe? I hate that. It's like the TV's on, talking about the new power plant, hmm, wonder where the climax will happen? Or that shot of the cook in Hunt For Red October? So anyway, sorry." Hmmm why are slum kids in Mumbai learning about Alexander Dumas' "The Three Musketeers"? I wonder if that will come up again, maybe at the film's climax? Spare me.

BTW I saw the twist in The Village a mile out, same with Unbreakable but I didn't mind that one as it fit into the story neatly. I didn't see the one in The Sixth Sense coming but I didn't know there would be one. I think you would pick it if someone said "You've got to see this movie, it has the best twist..."
 

Lono Shrugged

New member
May 7, 2009
1,467
0
0
Any plot device where you actually notice it as a PLOT DEVICE or McGuffin. Some films hide it very well, like the Tiger shark they catch in Jaws that moves the plot along or the photos in Blade Runner.

I usually hate Deus Ex Machina plot devices such as the Vibranium upgrade in Iron Man 2 that comes out of nowhere and is a re hash from the first movie. Or the Cube of mysterious power in Transformers that kills bad guys when you jam in in them.

The greatest Plot Device in almost any movie and I am sure many will agree is the dudes rug. It really tied the room together
 

Joshdemon

New member
Oct 23, 2009
102
0
0
Where the film has a really ridiculously contrived ending, in order to make the good guys win unrealistically (looking at you, Predators!). Seriously, 5 humans for 3 predators? You wouldn't be too impressed if you got that K/D in COD, let alone if you were an alien with superior technology and physical prowess.
Also, the supersoldier "But you signed up of your own free will!" thing, present in the bourne series and then later hilariously stolen by the film Push.
 
Apr 19, 2010
1,544
0
0
The pointless love interest
or the 'loser guy' who for some untold reason is unable to find a girlfriend except for in the apparently hottest girl in the school (who of course is dating the biggest douche of the school.)
 

Unia

New member
Jan 15, 2010
349
0
0
Kurokami said:
Unia said:
Making a thriller about serial killings etc. and dropping so many hints the viewer guesses who the culprit is about 5 minutes in. (I'm looking at you, Saw. I think. I was too annoyed to finish that one tbh.)
Uhh...

If you're talking about Saw 1 I call bullshit.
Damn, plot summaries weren't too helpful and I'm not about to try watching it a second time so just tell me

Was the frustrated male nurse (or whatever) early on Jigsaw? Nobody seems to think it's relevant but I was more interested about Jigsaw's motivation thn the two guys in the bathroom...
 

Kermi

Elite Member
Nov 7, 2007
2,538
0
41
Unia said:
Kurokami said:
Unia said:
Making a thriller about serial killings etc. and dropping so many hints the viewer guesses who the culprit is about 5 minutes in. (I'm looking at you, Saw. I think. I was too annoyed to finish that one tbh.)
Uhh...

If you're talking about Saw 1 I call bullshit.
Damn, plot summaries weren't too helpful and I'm not about to try watching it a second time so just tell me

Was the frustrated male nurse (or whatever) early on Jigsaw? Nobody seems to think it's relevant but I was more interested about Jigsaw's motivation thn the two guys in the bathroom...
Jigsaw was the guy pretending to be dead on the floor in the bathroom, the weaselly male nurse was another of Jigsaw's victims... and now I don't remember why he was tapped as a victim apart from to drive the plot by kidnapping the doctor's family as motivation for him to co-operate.
 

tharglet

New member
Jul 21, 2010
998
0
0
When it comes down to using "technology" in some rather unrealistic manner. Think CSI and their infinite magnifier (which also crops up in films of which their names elude me).

Once someone starts to use a computer in a film, it's usually a sign I'm about to cringe or facepalm. Really does break the immersion for me.
 
May 28, 2009
3,698
0
0
tharglet said:
Once someone starts to use a computer in a film, it's usually a sign I'm about to cringe or facepalm. Really does break the immersion for me.
You mean the fast-paced, "the computer is running at super-efficiency you'd never see in reality" thing? They get what they need far too quickly? Or they just keep typing continuously and from what you can see technically the cursor is being used rather than anything remotely needing a keyboard?
 

Kurokami

New member
Feb 23, 2009
2,352
0
0
Unia said:
Kurokami said:
Unia said:
Making a thriller about serial killings etc. and dropping so many hints the viewer guesses who the culprit is about 5 minutes in. (I'm looking at you, Saw. I think. I was too annoyed to finish that one tbh.)
Uhh...

If you're talking about Saw 1 I call bullshit.
Damn, plot summaries weren't too helpful and I'm not about to try watching it a second time so just tell me

Was the frustrated male nurse (or whatever) early on Jigsaw? Nobody seems to think it's relevant but I was more interested about Jigsaw's motivation thn the two guys in the bathroom...
Nope.

I would suggest watching the first one if the morals don't bother you, I quite enjoyed it personally. Though obviously that's just a matter of tastes.
 

scottgoblue314

New member
Nov 18, 2009
1
0
0
Kermi said:
Your green rocks comment has me thinking about Unobtanium, which was the actual name of the element in Avatar...
Unobtanium is an Engineering joke. When someone designs a particular component whose ideal specs are impossible for any known material (or just too expensive), the ideal construction material is referred to as "Unobtanium." The idea in the movie is that they found this ore that has some very desirable properties and is extremely rare and expensive.

Anyway, OT: Aliens. If a movie is not advertised as a sci-fi and suddenly Things from Outer Space are driving the plot, then I walk away.
 

Tajomaru

New member
Jul 27, 2010
32
0
0
Good guy goes bad, than at the nmovie's climax, and at the hero's plea has a change of heart and again switches sides(personal sacrifice optional for dramatic purposes) thus saving the day. Return of the Jedi was the only film which Vader's change of heart seemed realistic and purposeful.
 

Kermi

Elite Member
Nov 7, 2007
2,538
0
41
scottgoblue314 said:
Kermi said:
Your green rocks comment has me thinking about Unobtanium, which was the actual name of the element in Avatar...
Unobtanium is an Engineering joke. When someone designs a particular component whose ideal specs are impossible for any known material (or just too expensive), the ideal construction material is referred to as "Unobtanium." The idea in the movie is that they found this ore that has some very desirable properties and is extremely rare and expensive.

Anyway, OT: Aliens. If a movie is not advertised as a sci-fi and suddenly Things from Outer Space are driving the plot, then I walk away.
It's also a literary joke. The highly sought after wlement X in any given film/book is often referred to jokingly as Unobtanium.
 

Unia

New member
Jan 15, 2010
349
0
0
Speaking of CSI, don't you just love how a piece of lint in the victim's pocket turns out to be crucial to the murder investigation? Then again those series have little to do with reality anyway.
 

BiscuitTrouser

Elite Member
May 19, 2008
2,860
0
41
The good character is jesus and the bad character is hitler. Let me explain. Big hollywood movies today dont see the point in having real people as movie characters, we are too retarded to relate to a normal person. What we have instead is massively exhaggerated people so we focus on it and instantly can go "hur hur hur that guy is good".

these are movies where they make the bad guy a puppy stamping neo nazi just so we hate him. You shouldnt need to do that. We should dislike the bad guy because of his personality, theres no need to ramp him up to hitler evil. Sometimes they do this when it makes no sense plot wise (IM LOOKING AT YOU AVATAR!) Then they make the good guy an orphan saving charity owner. Have BALANCED PEOPLE. Movies where the bad guy does bad things for the right reasons are good, these are real people. No ones 100% good or 100% evil but these movies seem intent on maing people 5000000% good and 5000000% evil. EVERYONE IS IETHER GOOD OR BAD, ITS PUPPY STOMPER OR JESUS, no inbetween or balence what so ever.
 
May 28, 2009
3,698
0
0
Unia said:
Speaking of CSI, don't you just love how a piece of lint in the victim's pocket turns out to be crucial to the murder investigation? Then again those series have little to do with reality anyway.
Looks like our killer... lint, a hand.

YEAAAAAAAAAAAAH!