Poll: Another Bioshock question

[Chaos Bringer]

What did you guys do with the little sisters. Half the people I know harvested them and the other half saved them. What did you do? I saved them.

 

[Spaceman_Spiff]

I dont trust anyone who harvested them...

 

[Radeonx]

Please use the Search Bar. This thread has been done multiple times.
I harvested them. Because I enjoy causing pain and suffering throughout cities.

 

[magicmonkeybars]

saving them gets you more adam in the long run because you get plasmids for free.

 

[Jonny The Kay]

I saved them it's the best long-term choice.

 

[Internet Kraken]

Please use the Search Bar. This thread has been done multiple times.
I harvested them. Because I enjoy causing pain and suffering throughout cities.

Really? I couldn't find this thread with the search bar. Prove it.

Anyways, I saved and harvested them on my first play through. I thought it would give me the neutral path. Unfortunately the idea of being neutral does not exist in Bioshock so I got the evil ending in which I was a murderous bastard for no reason.

 

[Troublesome Lagomorph]

I can boast to never harvesting before.

 

[scott91575]

Please use the Search Bar. This thread has been done multiple times.
I harvested them. Because I enjoy causing pain and suffering throughout cities.

Really? I couldn't find this thread with the search bar. Prove it.

Anyways, I saved and harvested them on my first play through. I thought it would give me the neutral path. Unfortunately the idea of being neutral does not exist in Bioshock so I got the evil ending in which I was a murderous bastard for no reason.

So if you go through life and you only kill a few kids you are not evil, you are neutral? What is the limit on child killing before you become evil?

BTW...I did kill one just to see what it looked like and I did get the good ending. So I guess there is a specific limit to child killing that is allowed.

 

[Radeonx]

Please use the Search Bar. This thread has been done multiple times.
I harvested them. Because I enjoy causing pain and suffering throughout cities.

Really? I couldn't find this thread with the search bar. Prove it.

Anyways, I saved and harvested them on my first play through. I thought it would give me the neutral path. Unfortunately the idea of being neutral does not exist in Bioshock so I got the evil ending in which I was a murderous bastard for no reason.

http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/9.120455#2366132 That is the thread you are looking for, although, upon a search, it took me a while to find it, so, my apologies, OP.

 

[Internet Kraken]

Please use the Search Bar. This thread has been done multiple times.
I harvested them. Because I enjoy causing pain and suffering throughout cities.

Really? I couldn't find this thread with the search bar. Prove it.

Anyways, I saved and harvested them on my first play through. I thought it would give me the neutral path. Unfortunately the idea of being neutral does not exist in Bioshock so I got the evil ending in which I was a murderous bastard for no reason.

So if you go through life and you only kill a few kids you are not evil, you are neutral? What is the limit on child killing before you become evil?

Well they're not really kids. Plus you need the adam to survive. If you're just killing them to survive, then you're not really evil. You're just doing what you need to do. I don't see why that instantly turns you into Satan.

 

[ssgt splatter]

Harvested because I like being the egomanical bastard. How else can you defeat Atlas

 

[scott91575]

Please use the Search Bar. This thread has been done multiple times.
I harvested them. Because I enjoy causing pain and suffering throughout cities.

Really? I couldn't find this thread with the search bar. Prove it.

Anyways, I saved and harvested them on my first play through. I thought it would give me the neutral path. Unfortunately the idea of being neutral does not exist in Bioshock so I got the evil ending in which I was a murderous bastard for no reason.

So if you go through life and you only kill a few kids you are not evil, you are neutral? What is the limit on child killing before you become evil?

Well they're not really kids. Plus you need the adam to survive. If you're just killing them to survive, then you're not really evil. You're just doing what you need to do. I don't see why that instantly turns you into Satan.

Well, since you don't have to harvest them you are not doing what you have to do. As for not really kids, that could be debatable. I think most would say they are.

 

[teutonicman]

Just to get the achievement.

 

[Julianking93]

First time I played it, I harvested them. But, then I watched a guy play it who saved them, then I realized that you get a lot more rewards if you save them.

 

[Skeleon]

For some reason, I always play nice in games.
Even in games like Overlord, I still get the best possible karma.
Not because I'm nice, but because I'm pragmatic.
If everybody is dead, who is there to work for me?
Same thing in Bioshock, I always saved them.

 

[blood77]

First time I played it, I harvested them. But, then I watched a guy play it who saved them, then I realized that you get a lot more rewards if you save them.

ditto.

 

[Andy_Panthro]

I'm usually a nice guy in games, with Mass Effect I think the only one I've gone bad in recently.

So I saved them, thinking I would replay the game and harvest the second time around.

I never played it again though. Really didn't want to. Ditto for Mass Effect actually.

 

[Flour]

BTW...I did kill one just to see what it looked like and I did get the good ending. So I guess there is a specific limit to child killing that is allowed.

The limit is 1, any more than that will get you the 'evil' ending

 

[thatoneguyyouknow]

The first play through I saved them because child murder is wrong. The second play through I harvested them because child murder is just fine.