nikki191 said:
Target audience has nothing to do with it, I'm afraid. Look at shows like My Little Pony, Harry Potter and, hell, even Spongebob. What's THEIR target audiences? And how many adults watch and enjoy them? And for that matter, how many adults read/watch and enjoy Twilight? Who a story was written for doesn't mean that only that group is supposed to read/watch and enjoy it, criticism can therefor be leveled from anyone. You say "Well it's written for teenage girls so they're the only ones who are supposed to like it." That'd be a valid argument in this context if indeed only teenage girls read the books or watched the movies.
But I'd argue that the books weren't written specifically for teenage girls, they were written for teenage girls, older women, and anyone else who has fantasies about vampires. My argument is that you can't take away a vampire's aversion to sunlight and replace it with glittering pixie dust and expect people to still think of that creature as being a vampire. It's not a new spin on things, it's a bastardization. The only hook that Twilight has is "human girl in a love triangle with a vampire and a werewolf". Take away the "vampire and werewolf" and it'd just be another lame highschool romance about one girl being fought over by two guys...the only reason these books are popular is because it plays upon the desire to be so special that supernatural beings are fighting for your love.
And I'm not faulting the author for using that desire to sell her story. I'm just saying that if the entire purpose of your story lies with those supernatural beings, the least you can do is write them correctly. I understand putting a new creative touch on traditional characters, changing them in ways that make them different from the norm. But that only applies if you maintain the core of those characters. Is it unheard of for a vampire to fall in love with a human? No. Do we need all vampires to be smooth talking, cape-wearing masterminds? No. Do we need all vampires to have hearts of darkness with an irresistible hunger for human flesh? No. Vampires have seen many incarnations over many different stories...one thing has always held constant though: sun = death, not glittering pixie dust.
That's really all my argument boils down to. I really don't mind taking creative indulgences with vampires. They're fictional characters and as such they can be anything you want them to be. But with each change you implement the character becomes less of the thing you based it off of and more of a thing of your own creation. Would anyone like a story about a girl who falls in love with a guy who has super strength, super speed, and a glandular problem that makes him glitter in the sunlight? Perhaps...but it's much more appealing to just say "they're vampires" and get people intrigued...because vampires invoke a sense of mystery, sparkling pixie boys don't.