Poll: Anyone else notice this about fantasy games?

Recommended Videos

Hectix777

New member
Feb 26, 2011
1,500
0
0
As everyone here is an avid gamer that can most likely play Super Mario on a kazoo, recite the names of the recurring summons in Final Fantasy, and can discover every skull and glitch in Halo I'm going to assume Luce played at least one fantasy video game. My question is this: has anyone ever noticed how every other race in a game have American accents while the humans have British ones? I know this isn't for every character ever but it's pretty common, why is that? What exactly separates Dwarven and Elven dialect from a human's so much that humans are British. I'm not hating the British but why isn't it possible for one human to sound like he has a plain accent. They don't even have to be an important character, if a developer wanted to he could create a character with an American accent that talks to the PC(he has a British one) and the main guy could be all confused. It could be like some kind of joke.

Like," Good morrow travelers! Might I ask what brings you into my shoppe?"
(just imagine Alistair is speaking for this part)"I say tha's a rather peeculiar accent you hav' thair,"
"Really? It's quite common where I'm from,"
(Alistair again)"it's so hard to understand you"

You know the guy that has this accent doesn't even have to be important, he could be a farce. I know Americans weren't around during the 17th century so our accent wouldn't exist, but when it's spoken by dwarves and elves, the furthest thing from human, it just raises questions. Why can't a human sound like this? Why is it that such an accent that is derived from humans be spoken by other races and not the source? Has anyone else noticed this?

My problem isn't with the fact that humans speak in an English tongue so much that it is that non-human races speak an American dialect.
 

Bara_no_Hime

New member
Sep 15, 2010
3,646
0
0
Hectix777 said:
My question is this: has anyone ever noticed how every other race in a game have American accents while the humans have British ones? I know this isn't for every character ever but it's pretty common, why is that?
Actually, I have noticed that. Also, it also happens in Mass Effect - there are some American humans, but a weird number of them are British for no obvious reasons. No French or Russian characters, no not sure why they went that way with it.

And actually, it's mostly humans being British. In Dragon Age, some of the elves are randomly French. **shrug** So they weren't American, they were just odd. So the American thing varies.

Honestly, it's mostly because that's where most of the English speaking voice talent is - American and England.
 

Rylot

New member
May 14, 2010
1,819
0
0
Aren't dwarves usually Scottish? Not sure that I've come across one with a plain American accent.
 

Hectix777

New member
Feb 26, 2011
1,500
0
0
Bara_no_Hime said:
Hectix777 said:
My question is this: has anyone ever noticed how every other race in a game have American accents while the humans have British ones? I know this isn't for every character ever but it's pretty common, why is that?
Actually, I have noticed that. Also, it also happens in Mass Effect - there are some American humans, but a weird number of them are British for no obvious reasons. No French or Russian characters, no not sure why they went that way with it.

And actually, it's mostly humans being British. In Dragon Age, some of the elves are randomly French. **shrug** So they weren't American, they were just odd. So the American thing varies.

Honestly, it's mostly because that's where most of the English speaking voice talent is - American and England.
I always thought the guys from Antiva had Spanish accents, as in from Spain. At least thats the picture Zevran paints when he talks about, he's almost like Ezio in a way. It just feels kinda lazy, y'know? Like in S. Korea they made a game about the frontiers about the USA, and of course this is Korea and an MMO this was nowhere near reality, but some had american dialects I assume(I never played it). This is something they could put into Fable 4, the new ones going to be based around World War I (Fable I=dark ages, Fable II=Renaissance, Fable III=Industrial Revolution) so it should be right to assume new accents in there. I mean Lionhead has created like 5 countries that prescribe to a certain region why not elaborate?
 

Fbuh

New member
Feb 3, 2009
1,233
0
0
I've noticed the same thing with movies. Classical Greek/Romans seems to have English accents, which I always thought odd. I'm guessing that people seem to think English=Refined=Class. Wouldn't it make more sense to given them accents depending on where they're from, like actual Greek/Roman accents?
 

Midnight Crossroads

New member
Jul 17, 2010
1,912
0
0
I didn't until now. It might be pretty cool to hear Elves with German or Swedish accents. Or Centaurs with Eastern European or Turkish accents.
 

Stall

New member
Apr 16, 2011
950
0
0
Fbuh said:
Wouldn't it make more sense to given them accents depending on where they're from, like actual Greek/Roman accents?
Titan's Quest, a little D2 clone set in ancient Greece, did that.
 

Nieroshai

New member
Aug 20, 2009
2,940
0
0
Look at it this way. They probably aren't even speaking english at all. You just happen to have a translator chip in your console. Made in your native country.
 

SkyKitty

New member
Dec 15, 2009
40
0
0
More important question, why do we never have a Scottish playable character?

Their accents are like, the best D:<
 

Crimson_Dragoon

Biologist Supreme
Jul 29, 2009
795
0
0
I've never noticed that outside Dragon Age, which got rid of the "normal" Scottish accents dwarves tend to have. But that's one game, and one does not make a pattern.
 

gostlyfantom

New member
Jan 22, 2011
405
0
0
nope, maybe i am not good at noticing accents but i have never noticed this and i have played a LOT of fantasy games