Poll: Batman: Arkham Aslyum - Overrated?

Recommended Videos

Sparrow

New member
Feb 22, 2009
6,848
0
0
I got the new Batman game this Christmas, and I recently only just finished it. The main reason I wanted it was due to it's ridiculously rated reviews, most all about 90%, and because Batman is generally quite awesome.

However, like I said, I just recently finished it and thought: "Wait a tic, that wasn't all that good". Granted, it was good, just not as good as everyone else said. People that played it said stuff like, "It's the closest to perfection a video game is". Of course, I realise it's probally just a gap in opinion. I'm sure I'm just weird or something for not liking this "masterpiece".

One of things I absolutely cannot agree with is it's "perfection" rating though. Combat, although fun, gets boring after a while. All common enemies use the same character build, with only a few variants in their actual looks, mainly the colour of their skin. Many of the sneaking modes gets repetetive over a while, and these scenes only have about ten or so pieces of repeated common dialogue. Certain boss-type enemies are repeated several times, mainly Bane copies, of which there must be ten or so within one playthrough... I could go on. There are a few more things that tick me off about the game, such as the ending or the fact that having to tap the X button like a mad-man every time you want to open a hatch or pull down a wall gets really annoying after a while, but I'm sure I've gotten my point across.

So, am I just crazy or something? Are all these things meant to be fun? Is it definately deserving of it's high ratings? Or do you disagree with any of my points?
 

300lb. Samoan

New member
Mar 25, 2009
1,765
0
0
Yep, it kicks lots of ass. I've been playing through it and Assassin's Creed simultaneously and AC is what I would call video game perfection, BUT Batman is the type of game absolutely anyone can sit down and have fun with. Challenging while accessible, familiar and new at the same time.

So, uh, yea I liked it a lort.
 

Senor Smoke21

New member
May 23, 2008
288
0
0
I think it got such good reviews was because it wasn't overly hyped and the general populace wern't expecting it to be what it was.
Also because it's fucking amazing!
 

GodsAndFishes

New member
Mar 22, 2009
1,167
0
0
It was a fun game but I'm with the OP, it really didn't deserve the hyped up ratings. Its added to my list of overhyped games.
 

Sonicron

Do the buttwalk!
Mar 11, 2009
5,133
0
0
Anything that could potentially detract from the fun in that game has been mentioned in Yahtzee's review, and even he - being an organism that would most likely perish if it went a certain amount of time without spewing bile - was struggling to find negative stuff to say about it. In my opinion, almost everything in that game was perfect (for its genre, of course) and thus it deserves the praise it gets.
 

Sparrow

New member
Feb 22, 2009
6,848
0
0
HUBILUB said:
Sparrow said:
HUBILUB said:
It definitely deserves all its praise.
Daystar Clarion said:
HUBILUB said:
It definitely deserves all its praise.
Seconded...
Yeah, yeah... that's great and all, but I was sort of looking for reasons WHY.
Because it's fun.

That's it.
I thought it was fun too, but you're missing the point. I've played things that are alot more fun, yet even I don't think they deserve ratings of 90% and above.
 

Cherry Cola

Your daddy, your Rock'n'Rolla
Jun 26, 2009
11,940
0
0

Cherry Cola

Your daddy, your Rock'n'Rolla
Jun 26, 2009
11,940
0
0
Sparrow said:
HUBILUB said:
Sparrow said:
HUBILUB said:
It definitely deserves all its praise.
Daystar Clarion said:
HUBILUB said:
It definitely deserves all its praise.
Seconded...
Yeah, yeah... that's great and all, but I was sort of looking for reasons WHY.
Because it's fun.

That's it.
I thought it was fun too, but you're missing the point. I've played things that are alot more fun, yet even I don't think they deserve ratings of 90% and above.
But I think that Batman deserved 90%.

So we clearly have different standards.

Therefore this is all pointless!

May I suggest we start talking about cookies?
 

Eagle Est1986

That One Guy
Nov 21, 2007
1,976
0
0
It's over rated compared to your pre-conceptions of it, most games would be. However I had no such pre-conceptions, so for me it wasn't in the least bit over rated.
 

DeadlyYellow

New member
Jun 18, 2008
5,141
0
0
It's a solid game. Great production, working gameplay, and few bugs. It even has a nostalgia factor for us old fogies that remember Batman TAS.
 

A.I. Sigma

New member
Sep 17, 2008
240
0
0
I absolutely loved it. Boss battles could have been more inventitive instead of the hulking dudes being overused, but o emm eff gee, the stealth! It was epic! The best combination of action and stealth in a game that I've ever seen~ :)
 

Sparrow

New member
Feb 22, 2009
6,848
0
0
Eagle Est1986 said:
It's over rated compared to your pre-conceptions of it, most games would be. However I had no such pre-conceptions, so for me it wasn't in the least bit over rated.
Going into it thinking it was meant to be some kind of masterpiece probally swayed me a bit, admittedly. But I don't think I put it down. There wasn't any point throughout playing it I thought "That isn't worth a high rating". It was only afterwards that it came to mind.