Poll: Brotherhood Of Steel VS Enclave

[AceDiamond]

Aren't these names getting a bit generic? I swear there were stupidly similar opposing faction names in Deus Ex: Invisible war.

Except Invisible War was unplayable and I doubt anyone remembers anyway. But yeah, it's generic, but not half as generic as blizzard names...

Personally, I think they both suck balls. Enclave do have a point but they're really fascist, and Brotherhood of Steel have a noble goal, but they protect technology over human beings...

Also in Invisible War it was the World Trade Organization, The Order, The Illuminati, the Omar, and the Knights Templar. So no, didn't sound at all like any of those. (yes, I played IW after the original and still liked it. I'm crazy. I know)

Anyway, my vote goes the BoS. They actually are willing to hire "unclean" humans on a long-term basis rather than just using them up. Granted they tend to be a bit up their own ass with traits that seem to combine the best and worst aspects of the WH40K Space Marines and the Adeptus Mechanus, but it's still better than the Shadow-government Enclave who are willing to erase what's left of humanity and start over with...what...a couple thousand people? You also have to keep in mind that The Enclave knew nuclear war was approaching and rather than try and avoid it, encouraged it to happen.

Also the BoS is shown to be open to idealistic divides at times, given the Capital Wasteland BoS changing their goal to protect the citizens (which causes the Outcasts to break off, but still).

 

[Madshaw]

the enclave won't stand a chance against me, the fact that the BoS are involved should be little more than a footnote

 

[Roamin11]

What about the outcast of fallout3? OUTCASTS FTW

 

[AceDiamond]

I'd still give the vote to the BoS overall though since that's incorporating just about every single offshoot of them (even the semi-canon-but-maybe-not Midwest BoS from Tactics)

 

[BakaSmurf]

What about the outcast of fallout3? OUTCASTS FTW

I agree entirely with this post. Outcasts F'ing rule. Also, their badass power armour paint job only adds to their awesomeness.

Add the Outcasts to the poll or I will punt a small harmless kitten through a plate glass window and sacrifice it's siblings to the Great Dark One.

 

[Shycte]

What about the outcast of fallout3? OUTCASTS FTW

I agree entirely with this post. Outcasts F'ing rule. Also, their badass power armour paint job only adds to their awesomeness.

Add the Outcasts to the poll or I will punt a small harmless kitten through a plate glass window and sacrifice it's siblings to the Great Dark One.

Is that a threat?

 

[BakaSmurf]

What about the outcast of fallout3? OUTCASTS FTW

I agree entirely with this post. Outcasts F'ing rule. Also, their badass power armour paint job only adds to their awesomeness.

Add the Outcasts to the poll or I will punt a small harmless kitten through a plate glass window and sacrifice it's siblings to the Great Dark One.

Is that a threat?

...Will you put the Outcasts in the poll if it is?

 

[Shycte]

What about the outcast of fallout3? OUTCASTS FTW

I agree entirely with this post. Outcasts F'ing rule. Also, their badass power armour paint job only adds to their awesomeness.

Add the Outcasts to the poll or I will punt a small harmless kitten through a plate glass window and sacrifice it's siblings to the Great Dark One.

Is that a threat?

...Will you put the Outcasts in the poll if it is?

Maybe...

 

[Hookman]

I see a 300 scenario if its the Fallout 3 versions were talking about. The Enclave outman the Brotherhood that are in Washington and wipe them out but then the Brotherhood reinforcements arrive from the west coat and decimate the Enclave!
EDIT: I dont agree with adding Outcasts to the fray. They have much smaller numbers than both the Enclave and the Brotherhood and while they might have better technology they would still be severely outnumbered and in most cases outclassed.

 

[ZonerZ]

Brotherhood of Steel. They never tried to kill me.

P.S. Mods don't like versus threads.

they've both tried to kill me. Multiple times. So I'm just gonna go with the faction that gave my Unarmed character frikkin power armor training.
BoS FtW. That is all.

 

[BakaSmurf]

What about the outcast of fallout3? OUTCASTS FTW

I agree entirely with this post. Outcasts F'ing rule. Also, their badass power armour paint job only adds to their awesomeness.

Add the Outcasts to the poll or I will punt a small harmless kitten through a plate glass window and sacrifice it's siblings to the Great Dark One.

Is that a threat?

...Will you put the Outcasts in the poll if it is?

Maybe...

Hmm... Well then, Yes, it is a threat! Also, I shall create a super virus and wipe cute, harmless kittens off the face of the Earth if you don't add the Outcasts! >=D

 

[SultanP]

I'll say BoS, but i don't see why people keep going on about the outcasts, as they are more BoS than the "BoS" from Fallout 3 who have abandoned the original agenda and replaced it with a new one, which means that if the original Brotherhood of Steel could be bothered they could whipe out the Capital Wasteland departement, reinstate the outcasts and massacre The Enclave aswell.

 

[jboking]

The BoS would win, they have more backup. Also, the lone wanderer destroyed Jon Henry Eden. The BoS also has Liberty Prime. I kinda wish they would destroy each other though. They both hate other people so damn much.

 

[Rezin SR]

I voted BoS. The enclave are a bunch of panzies.

 

[Shycte]

What about the outcast of fallout3? OUTCASTS FTW

I agree entirely with this post. Outcasts F'ing rule. Also, their badass power armour paint job only adds to their awesomeness.

Add the Outcasts to the poll or I will punt a small harmless kitten through a plate glass window and sacrifice it's siblings to the Great Dark One.

Is that a threat?

...Will you put the Outcasts in the poll if it is?

Maybe...

Hmm... Well then, Yes, it is a threat! Also, I shall create a super virus and wipe cute, harmless kittens off the face of the Earth if you don't add the Outcasts! >=D

DO NOT HURT MAH LOLCATS!! xD

I added it

 

[BakaSmurf]

What about the outcast of fallout3? OUTCASTS FTW

I agree entirely with this post. Outcasts F'ing rule. Also, their badass power armour paint job only adds to their awesomeness.

Add the Outcasts to the poll or I will punt a small harmless kitten through a plate glass window and sacrifice it's siblings to the Great Dark One.

Is that a threat?

...Will you put the Outcasts in the poll if it is?

Maybe...

Hmm... Well then, Yes, it is a threat! Also, I shall create a super virus and wipe cute, harmless kittens off the face of the Earth if you don't add the Outcasts! >=D

DO NOT HURT MAH LOLCATS!! xD

I added it

The kitties shall live another day... >:]

 

[Avatar Roku]

Let's just examine their "super" units. The Enclave have mind-controlled Deathclaws. Nice, very nice. The BoS have Liberty Prime. Sorry, this has to go to the Brotherhood.

 

[ZonerZ]

personally i'd rather have the deathclaws.