I usually like oogling my madeup men, but if the male model is poor, womenfolk don't ruin the game for me.
It's mostly just meh.
My friend recently asked me what I would have thought of Halo if you played Cortana, a Spartan, who did all the talking, who had a strong-silent male computer assistant in her head.
While I don't think that would have worked as a whole, for some reason, I have always liked playing space games with female characters. No idea why. It's like, women belong in space or something?