The shooting was bad, the driving was bad, the graphics were bad, the voice acting was bad, the plot and characters were crazy at best and dumb at their worst, and the music was often ill fitting. As a piece of game design, it manages to do just about everything wrong.
Anyway, I'm about to start my third playthrough to do all the sidequests. While they got just about everything wrong, it's refreshing to see something with such love and ambition put into it by the design team. one of my favourite games of last year, and the best £13 I've spent in a long time.