Poll: Do you agree with the Black Ops Swastika Ban?

Recommended Videos

LetalisK

New member
May 5, 2010
2,769
0
0
I think banning the swastika was pretty stupid. But so is blowing it up into such a huge ordeal. To both sides of this, it's a fucking obsolete symbol. Get over it.
 

Echron

New member
Nov 10, 2010
1
0
0
look I believe that your both a bunch of idiots with to much time on your hands mankind has done some reaalllly stupid things but to argue about who was bad and who was worse is not something we should argue about they are both symbols that both have a negative meaning involved with them, aswell as a positive I just dont think that a freaking symbol in a game will influence an intellectual person and if it will change your though processes you have bigger problems
 

Katherine Kerensky

Why, or Why Not?
Mar 27, 2009
7,744
0
0
spartan231490 said:
-All Hail Britannia Snip-
Define vile?
vile
1. Loathsome; disgusting: vile language.
2. Unpleasant or objectionable: vile weather. See Synonyms at offensive.
3. a. Contemptibly low in worth or account; second-rate.
b. Of mean or low condition.
4. Miserably poor and degrading; wretched: a vile existence.
5. Morally depraved; ignoble or wicked: a vile conspiracy.

I think that covers having a phallus as an emblem on Black Ops.
I don't know why you wanted me to define vile, though :|
Sure, it could also cover the Swastika, and a host of other images, but as long as the sexually explicite emblems are gone along with them, I don't care.
 

John the Gamer

New member
May 2, 2010
1,021
0
0
It's just a symbol. Wich has, just like the touthbrush mustash, become a taboo because of the actions of one imbicile, over 60 years ago. But I'm with the ban. It's still a touchy subject, people from ww2 are still alive after all.
 

SenseOfTumour

New member
Jul 11, 2008
4,514
0
0
John the Gamer said:
It's just a symbol. Wich has, just like the touthbrush mustash, become a taboo because of the actions of one imbicile, over 60 years ago. But I'm with the ban. It's still a touchy subject, people from ww2 are still alive after all.
He has a point, Charlie Chaplin's moustache is now seen not as his, but as the facial hair of a very silly little man with a funny walk. (hang on...)

My ideal fix for it would be that all players who disagree with the swastika, just make sure that they shoot anyone wearing one first whenever the choice arises. Same goes for any dumb penis or sexual emblems.

After a few months (I doubt these people are swift learners somehow), they may realise that it's their idiotic choice of badge that is making them a bullet magnet.

After all, in WOW, if I get someone being rude, arrogant, or otherwise irritating, but not enough to be worth kicking, they'll just get less priority healing, and if they so much as say 'gogogo' once, I can generally persuade the group to stand still for 10 seconds, purely to irritate him. I for one think, in group play, tactics, planning, and letting the healer get full mana is more important than finishing a dungeon 30 seconds faster.
 

skeliton112

New member
Aug 12, 2009
519
0
0
Well if you ban the swastika you must ban all political and religious signs. LKet us not forget that the swastika is a symbol from eastern religions. No censoring. Unless the image is illegal in the first place let us have whatever we want as our emblem.
 

skeliton112

New member
Aug 12, 2009
519
0
0
Nile McMorrow said:
No I don't agree with the ban. People are saying if you show the image people are never going to know your meaning for doing so. However there are major differences between the Nazi and Religious symbol. For starters they have different colour schemes (e.g. Nazi Swastika: Black with a white circle and red background. Religious Swastika: Gold/red cross.) Also they are drawn in different directions. If people are not made aware of these sort of things then they will never accept them and know the difference. I have to say its also unfair and prejudice towards people who are trying to show they are proud of their religion and its kind of hypocritical if they allow people to play COD:WaW's campaign, MP and Zombie modes online, they have Nazi Swastikas all over the blooming place.

However, if they are going to be banning people for using the Swastika either for religious or insulting perposes then they should ban other offensive imagery as well and also the use of other religious symbols to be fair to the people being banned for using the Swastika religiously.

I also have to raise the question, if they can see the difference between the Nazi and Religious Swastikas used in people's logos then why not just ban the people using the Nazi one?
Some religious ones aren't drawn in different directions. they can be drawn facing clockwise or anti-clockwise. The Nazi one is always facing clockwise though.

EDIT: Oh and my above post was ninja'd
 

gagalloogie

New member
Jul 29, 2009
148
0
0
OMFG, seriously people what the fuck....I literally cannot believe the majority of people actually disagree with the decision to ban a symbol, which btw NONE- NONE of you would even consider using if it wasn't for the use by the Nazi's, thus empowering it for "shock value" or some shit like that, If it wasn't for the Nazi connotations the swastika wouldn't even be known to any of you, so don't even try to say "oooh its been around for years". The fact is its neither a particularly attractive symbol, or has any other meaning than those of great trauma for people all around the world, maybe xbox live are limiting free speech, but unless you are actually a Nazi, i think its one you can live without. Using the Swastika on your emblem is no better than all those people who choose to use other inappropriate images, in fact its worse as it has FUCKING GENOCIDAL CONNOTATIONS.

YuriHellsing said:
no the swastika should not be ban its a unfair bias against some religion. and don't give me the (but the Nazis used it) so what. if they going to ban it they should ban every thing relate to religion. i mean come the cross and the symbol of Jesus (yes its a symbol not a person) has cause much more death then the swastika and Nazi ever could of.
Yeah perhaps it does have something to do with some religions, but even so its inappropriate, i think many Christians would be offended if they saw that someone had made an emblem of Jesus on the cross, no doubt many Jews would be offended if they saw someone using the Star of David, in a game where alot of graphic killing happens perhaps religious symbols are inappropriate
FFs all i mean to say is people should just use common sense, its alright to say your all for freedom of speech and against censorship, but that doesn't mean you have to abuse it just for kicks, because whatever anyone claims the only reason they would want to use a swastika is to "shock" people, and to be honest its not even that shocking its just offensive and uneccessary
 

AshuraSpeaks

New member
Jun 12, 2008
93
0
0
RatRace123 said:
Yes, I agree. The people who are making swastika's for use as their emblems, aren't doing it to make a statement, or to be historically relevant.
They're doing it because they think it's funny, and they know it pisses people off.
These people are a sort of cancer on the gaming community, and they deserve every ounce of punishment they get.
Especially considering how often I've been called a Jew. What's up with that?
 

MattRooney06

New member
Apr 15, 2009
737
0
0
Im indifferent

I can see why people may be offeneded but i dont really care

especialy when the german level of zombies (cant remember the name) is full of swastika's and nazi's
 

Iamnotawitch

New member
Nov 23, 2010
4
0
0
Bottom line is that 'Conditions of Use' override any moral agree/disagree arguments; Activision determines what they let you do in the game once you clicked that 'I Agree' button before installing the game. As such arguments about freedom of speech are meaningless in this context. The only meaningful discussion point is personal feeling towards motivations for Activision decision.
 

Mechanix

New member
Dec 12, 2009
587
0
0
Displaying a swastika in Germany is illegal, therefore if this ban was not put in, Black Ops risks being banned in Germany.
 

Polaris19

New member
Aug 12, 2010
995
0
0
Yes. a good 80% of the people doing it are pretty much going "Haha look I made a Swastika."

Same thing goes for the penises and all the other garbage people are using in the emblem system. Honestly would have been a much better idea to just have preloaded ones that you had to pick from. Would have saved everyone a lot of headaches...
 

Eclectic Dreck

New member
Sep 3, 2008
6,662
0
0
Iwata said:
If you ban the swastika, then you also have to ban the hammer and sickle, no if's, ands or buts. Double standards much?
I would save the effort. Lamenting a double standard will get you nowhere slowly. If you want to throw the hypocrite stone, you might as well throw in the symbols associated with the US, the UK, France, Spain, Italy, China, Japan. . . more or less any nation that has existed for a few hundred years. Nations have a way of acquiring a lot of blood on the hands in the course of history.
 

Maerarde

New member
Oct 27, 2010
11
0
0
OK before this thread goes on - The Swastika = A Hindu symbol of peace backwards

Because Hitler was a bad man (lol nice words) he used this to symbolize war and that is it.
 

ryuuki

New member
Nov 19, 2009
5
0
0
The problem with banning certain signs and pictures is that you then have to carry it on and be consistent which is going to be difficult due to the amount of manpower it would require. The other difficulty is the fact that certain symbols aren't legally allowed to be used. If i recall correctly this is true for the swastika in Germany, hence why if you play a german version of a ww2 game all the logos are removed, it's an offence to display the logo. I only believe that bans should be carried out for items of legal dispute.
 

Vryyk

New member
Sep 27, 2010
393
0
0
It'd be wrong to say that they can't do what they like with their personal property. If they don't like it, their call. Stop pretending freedom of speech extends to the private sector, it doesn't.
 

ServebotFrank

New member
Jul 1, 2010
627
0
0
People love controversy so of course they will use the swastika as a joke. It's not right though and they love to point out the first amendment arguement too. This is not covered by that at all. The swastika is offensive and they know it.