Poll: Do You Think British Accents Are More..."Sophisticated"?

Recommended Videos

MetalMagpie

New member
Jun 13, 2011
1,523
0
0
It depends on the precise British/American accent. There are accents in both countries that drive me up the wall.

I guess in a "best of each" contest, I'd say I find an RP British accent more sophisticated than a well-spoken New York accent, but that's probably just because I don't really know many Americans. Pretty much everyone I have ever really respected has had a British accent.
 

Iron Criterion

New member
Feb 4, 2009
1,271
0
0
There is no such thing as a British accent, the dialects vary from region to region; and that's just in England alone, Scottish accents are far from 'posh'.

However I assume you are referring to Received Pronunciation aka The Queen's English. In that case I agree that it is more sophisticated and quaint.
 

OmniscientOstrich

New member
Jan 6, 2011
2,879
0
0
There's no such thing as a 'British' accent, that would imply some kind of weird amalgam of generic English, Scottish, Welsh and Northern Irish accents. Okay, I think I know what you're alluding to, it seems when most people from the other side of the atlantic talk about 'British' accents they refer to the stereotypical elocutionary accents of the upper/middle class found in central London, that are oft portrayed for giggles in the mainstream American media. Perhaps to a lesser extent they also refer to generic English accents that are harder to pin down to any particular region, but basically you'll never see somebody listen to a Scottish or Welsh accent and opine that it's 'British'. If they would simply refer to the accent which they envision as an 'English' accent then I wouldn't really have a problem with it, but as it stands calling it 'British' seems rather disingenuous. And as others have mentioned nations encompass a wide variety of dialects; Jeremy Irons would likely seem to have an accent which as a great deal more sophisticated than say Wayne Rooney, whereas on the other side of the pond Kelsey Grammer's voice would sound (I'm not saying the guy himself is all that classy, as he isn't >.>) more refined than Bill Hicks. Personally, I come from a place where the stereotypical accent would sound something like this:


Though I myself (and many others I've met) haven't picked it up, leaving me with a rather generic English accent, that's rather difficult to trace, unless you can pick up on the slight Somerset inflection that my voice places on certain words but I wouldn't consider it particularly posh or anything. Ultimately I find this prospect to be rather pretentious, the sound of one's voice does not denote any particular qualities or characterstics about the individual themselves, it's only an indication of where they grew up and even then the strength of one's accent tends to vary from person to person. And I honestly have much less respect for someone trying to obfuscate their natural speaking voice for something more accessible in an effort to be taken more seriously than someone who is comfortable enough in who they are and their ability to articulate themselves in spite of whatever mypoic preconceptions that others may have about their voice. In short, what may constitute as sophisticated is entirely down to the individual in question and even then just because someone sounds sophisticated doesn't mean they actually are.
 

Tipsy Giant

New member
May 10, 2010
1,133
0
0
Rastien said:
Intresting fact the "pirate" accent of yarrrr etc etc is actually VERY close to the south west somerset/dorset accent but even more close to the cornish accent where they had alot of pirates and smugglers.

If you listen to the wurzels then listen to some pirate accent its pretty similar.

Somerset boy ere scrumping them apples oooh arr
My tutor at college is the bassist from Wurzles!

I'm from the west country and we do not have a sophisticated accent, but i've meet americans who can't tell the difference, even when I say ark at e
 

Thaluikhain

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 16, 2010
19,538
4,128
118
Iron Criterion said:
There is no such thing as a British accent, the dialects vary from region to region; and that's just in England alone, Scottish accents are far from 'posh'.
I dunno, you can have posh Scottish accents IMHO.
 

Iron Criterion

New member
Feb 4, 2009
1,271
0
0
thaluikhain said:
Iron Criterion said:
There is no such thing as a British accent, the dialects vary from region to region; and that's just in England alone, Scottish accents are far from 'posh'.
I dunno, you can have posh Scottish accents IMHO.
I didn't mean to seem insulting but I've never heard a Scottish accent that could be described as sophisticated. But then I have never been to Scotland.
 

razer17

New member
Feb 3, 2009
2,518
0
0
There is no such thing as a British accent. Not only do the Welsh, Irish, Scottish and English all sound different, but within each country there's many different accents, especially in England.

A Geordie accent is very different to Liverpudlian, both of which are definitely not more intelligent sounding.
 

Zack Alklazaris

New member
Oct 6, 2011
1,938
0
0
Its hard to say, anyone can sound more sophisticated by actually using words that are more complex that "got" and "cuz". I'm sure a British accent can sound sophisticated to some people, but for me I seem to start smiling whenever I get into a verbal argument with someone whose British.

Something about how they swear just makes me laugh.
 

Layzor

New member
Feb 18, 2009
731
0
0
Almost nobody actually speaks like that, we're mostly just an assortment of horrible, horrible regional accents.
 

wintercoat

New member
Nov 26, 2011
1,691
0
0
Some do, yes. Others...not so much. Take cockney for example. Cockney makes you want to insert a tiny, sharp clawed, highly agitated creature into your ear canal.
 

Nightmonger

New member
Jul 1, 2010
147
0
0
Well i'm from Yorkshire (or Up north) and i don't really consider my accent to be posh at all. Also i do tend to do the stereotyped yorkshire thing of Converting The into T' but thats comes with the accent its like instinct :p
 

OmniscientOstrich

New member
Jan 6, 2011
2,879
0
0
Tipsy Giant said:
Are you from Bristol?
I live in Bristol which is why i'm asking
Close, I actually come from around Bath, more speficially in a village just outside it, though I'm currently living in Dorset during term times at Uni, though I go back home to ol' Somerset in between terms. Kinda surprised to see at least two other people on this thread from the South West. :3
 

Tipsy Giant

New member
May 10, 2010
1,133
0
0
OmniscientOstrich said:
Tipsy Giant said:
Are you from Bristol?
I live in Bristol which is why i'm asking
Close, I actually come from around Bath, more speficially in a village just outside it, though I'm currently living in Dorset during term times at Uni, though I go back home to ol' Somerset in between terms. Kinda surprised to see at least two other people on this thread from the South West. :3
I love Bristol, Best music in the country which has the best music in the world.
I love the underground Hip Hop scene here.
What ya studying at uni, I finished my course last year and realised the only jobs going were temp jobs, it sucks, I miss uni
 

DrgoFx

New member
Aug 30, 2011
768
0
0
Two things:

There are a lot of "dumb brits" and they sound just as bad as Americans, accent or not. There are also a lot of dialects, like in the states.

However, point two is that the British education is far greater and more complex than the US form of Education, from my experiences anyway. To those who aren't aware of what it is, simply Google IB, that's the acronym for the system. Most of my schooling has been from IB schools, like the one I'm nearly finished with.
 

For.I.Am.Mad

New member
May 8, 2010
664
0
0
You know, I was watching the newest Harry Potter when I realized I could barely hear their accents.
 

scorptatious

The Resident Team ICO Fanboy
May 14, 2009
7,405
0
0
I've never really been around many people like that so I can't say for sure. But from the few English sounding people I listen to on TV they sound somewhat more sophisticated than I do.
 

OmniscientOstrich

New member
Jan 6, 2011
2,879
0
0
Tipsy Giant said:
I love Bristol, Best music in the country which has the best music in the world. I love the underground Hip Hop scene here. What ya studying at uni, I finished my course last year and realised the only jobs going were temp jobs, it sucks, I miss uni
Interesting, can't say I'm all that fond of hip hop, but different strokes I guess. Yeah, I like the idea of living near a big city without actually living in it y'know? I'm a more reserved kind of guy, so I liked having a bit of greenery, not being in the hustle and bustle all the time, but being able to get into that kind of thing within a short bus ride if I wanted to. I'm studying Scriptwriting for Film and Television in the hopes of becoming a screenwriter though I realise chances are slim of being able to get in that line of work especially in the way things are panning out for me at the moment in the course. But yeah, I can understand things being rough in the job market given we're in the fallout of a recession, my dad in particular had a tough time finding work over the past few years. So anyway, what did you get your degree in?
 

Tipsy Giant

New member
May 10, 2010
1,133
0
0
OmniscientOstrich said:
Tipsy Giant said:
I love Bristol, Best music in the country which has the best music in the world. I love the underground Hip Hop scene here. What ya studying at uni, I finished my course last year and realised the only jobs going were temp jobs, it sucks, I miss uni
Interesting, can't say I'm all that fond of hip hop, but different strokes I guess. Yeah, I like the idea of living near a big city without actually living in it y'know? I'm a more reserved kind of guy, so I liked having a bit of greenery, not being in the hustle and bustle all the time, but being able to get into that kind of thing within a short bus ride if I wanted to. I'm studying Scriptwriting for Film and Television in the hopes of becoming a screenwriter though I realise chances are slim of being able to get in that line of work especially in the way things are panning out for me at the moment in the course. But yeah, I can understand things being rough in the job market given we're in the fallout of a recession, my dad in particular had a tough time finding work over the past few years. So anyway, what did you get your degree in?
Yeah I live on the outskirts too and love the countryside round here.

I studied Creative Sound & Music and learnt that most experimental music is pretentious and boring and most pop music is the equivalent of a placebo when it comes to human expression.

Something i'm sure will be mirrored in your course!

But got some good mates from the experience and an album which i'm glad is almost finished