immortalfrieza said:
That's the problem, it DOES affect everyone. Due to COD's success, every video game developer out there is trying to emulate COD's formula in an attempt to grab it's audience, and as a result otherwise great games are being turned into bland brown shooters. The reason why COD dying out would be good for the industry is that developers would STOP DOING THAT! COD is ruining the quality of countless games throughout the industry just by existing, Mario, Madden, Fifa, Street Fighter, and other games that have been the same over and over with every release haven't done this, and that's why they get a pass. It doesn't hurt that each of them actually deviate from their formulas once in a while either.
And if you remove the patch of skin with the rash, your problem is solved.
What's that? A new rash popped up? But how?
You're talking about treating the symptoms to cure the underlying cause. While they're following CoD, the problem is they're following something, and that's been an issue since the beginning of gaming. Pong Clones, Donkey Kong Clones, Super Mario Clones, Twin Hitler Clones, etc. etc etc etc. The industry is always looking for something to follow. If CoD dies, it will look for something else. This is not a good thing, nor is it healthy. It means that there is an endemic problem underlying the brown shooter patches on the surface.
I don't know if you weren't around in the 80s and 90s, or maybe you just lack perspective, but in the 80s and into the 90s platformers took over. Everything was trying to copy Mario and Sonic. In a smaller market, this was kind of a big deal.
Then, in the late 90s there was a glut of RPGs. Final Fantasy clones, a lot of them. There was some good stuff, but it strangled the market.
Madden and even Street Fighter don't compare. They are their own niches. Yes, Madden is in a niche. It's just a particularly large one. Even when fighting games were at their biggest, they weren't a threat like Mario or FF clones. They really shouldn't get a pass. Especially since Squeenix has become such a horrible offender in the "me too" mindset, trying to make its games appeal to everybody and their mama by stripping out things like gameplay and setting expectations at more than 5 million units. That's not even a Call of Duty move; gaming has tried to make itself significantly more cinematic since the 90s.
I mean, hey. I can't stop anyone from hating CoD, but at least be realistic in your expectations. CoD is a symptom, not a cause.