Poll: Do you think people would get mad if Gordon Freeman spoke in a Half Life movie?

Recommended Videos

stiborge

New member
Sep 23, 2009
278
0
0
Hypothetically speaking, let's say that someone made a Half Life movie. Also, lets say that by some miracle of nature the movie was actually really good. Maybe they got a good director on it, or whatever. Do you think that you could forgive the movie if in that movie Gordon Freeman spoke for whatever reason?
 

legion431

New member
Mar 14, 2010
729
0
0
The games have been based around him not speaking, so I don't think he should.

EDIT: They are making a Half-Life movie, but it's based on Adrian Shepherd.
 

Chogg Van Helsing

New member
May 27, 2010
673
0
0
Hmm... I'm not sure, I accidentytally clicked the blasphemy option, that was unintentionaly lol.

It would have to be a really good movie, and he couldn't speak all that much.
 

Kapol

Watch the spinning tails...
May 2, 2010
1,431
0
0
Unless they're REALLY good at their jobs, having a movie where the main character doesn't speak would NEVER work well. Moreso when you have characters talking to him.
 

Unrulyhandbag

New member
Oct 21, 2009
462
0
0
I just assumed the mans a mute, wouldn't stop him being a top scientist he can still publish papers and work on stuff.

The games makes direct references to his silence so for a film to have a talking freeman would be pretty out of character.
 

Cherry Cola

Your daddy, your Rock'n'Rolla
Jun 26, 2009
11,940
0
0
I'd be disappointed if he did. People have made movies where the protagonist doesn't speak before, so Half Life can't come with excuses!
 

Kurokami

New member
Feb 23, 2009
2,352
0
0
stiborge said:
Hypothetically speaking, let's say that someone made a Half Life movie. Also, lets say that by some miracle of nature the movie was actually really good. Maybe they got a good director on it, or whatever. Do you think that you could forgive the movie if in that movie Gordon Freeman spoke for whatever reason?
I think he should always be interrupted, and occasionally make a humorous reference to it, but how would that work in a movie? I can't see a movie being made following Half Life well, so they'll probably change a whole lot and leave a trail of hatred following them.
 

Lem0nade Inlay

New member
Apr 3, 2010
1,166
0
0
legion431 said:
The games have been based around him not speaking, so I don't think he should.

EDIT: They are making a Half-Life movie, but it's based on Adrian Shepherd.
Really? Can I have a source? (Not being sarcastic I'm genuinely interested!)

OT: Yes, I would be annoyed. But if it was as good as you said, then maybe I could forgive it...as long as he wasn't made out to be some macho jackass.

Also, I don't know if I'd be happy or sad if it made HL2 more appealing. Because I mean I've been telling all my friends who play Halo 3 for years that Half Life 2 is a genuinely good game, but they all say it's not. I'd be pretty damn pissed off if they saw the movie then suddenly said that "OMGGG Hl2 is AWESOME!"
 

brodie21

New member
Apr 6, 2009
1,598
0
0
well if you have a protagonist that doesnt speak it works great for a video game but not for a movie. so he would have to speak
 

ENKC

New member
May 3, 2010
620
0
0
I just find myself wondering what kind of conversation he'd have with Link if they ever had the chance. Perhaps they all attend Mutes Anonymous or somesuch.
 

Lucane

New member
Mar 24, 2008
1,491
0
0
I didn't mind when Link talked in his and Captin N's Cartoons,or when Sonic did it,Mario and Co. Cloud and etc.

They would just need a good actor for it but it's hard making a good movie that is generally accepted by fans, non fans and non gamers.
 

JediMB

New member
Oct 25, 2008
3,094
0
0
I'm going to have to say that making a Half-Life movie would be an act of madness. It's just a really bad idea.
 

stiborge

New member
Sep 23, 2009
278
0
0
legion431 said:
The games have been based around him not speaking, so I don't think he should.

EDIT: They are making a Half-Life movie, but it's based on Adrian Shepherd.
Really? I didn't know. Can I find news of this anywhere?
 

sephiroth1991

New member
Dec 3, 2009
2,319
0
0
legion431 said:
The games have been based around him not speaking, so I don't think he should.

EDIT: They are making a Half-Life movie, but it's based on Adrian Shepherd.
I wondered where he got up to.

OT:I kinda don't mind eather way, if hes silent then he's silent but if he speaks i wonder what he sounds like.
 

P.Tsunami

New member
Feb 21, 2010
431
0
0
I picked "Yes, but not too much" as it was the closest option. Frankly, though, I don't think a Half Life movie is a good idea as it is. Much like a Halo or Doom movie, the very concept of translating it to screen has little point as is. FPS games, for good reason, usually has a thin, stretched-out storyline, flat characters, and not much to work with. If they didn't, the talkie stuff would just get in the way of why we play FPS games in the first place; blow stuff up. And with games that thin in areas that are crucial to most any movie, an adaptation is a bad idea unless your sole ambition is to milk a well known series for cash. If the tide of awful-to-mediocre movie adaptations of games is to be turned, Half Life certainly is not the one to do it.

On a related note, the Prince of Persia movie is pretty good for its kind. Of course, Prince of Persia isn't -much- thicker in terms of storyline, writing and character depth, but there's at least enough there to extrapolate from. Personally, I think the ideal picks for games to adapt would be RPGs. Bioware comes to mind. Of course, whether there'd be any point in doing so (I know a Mass Effect movie is planned) is another question. Might make an okay film, but I doubt it'd hold much interest aside from novelty for fans of the games.

Let's say they do make this Half-Life film, though. I couldn't really care less whether Freeman speaks or not. It's kind of a Damned If You Do, Damned If You Don't situation. Either they are disloyal to the chronically mute character, or they decide to keep a character trait that works well in an FPS game, but would be very odd for a movie. I suppose that I would enjoy Freeman talking more than the alternative, but it would probably cause a fan outcry.
 

Mr. Bojangles

New member
Nov 13, 2009
230
0
0
Lem0nade Inlay said:
Really? Can I have a source?
Is that a pun?

OT: It might work but II think they could pull of being mute.

The problem is I'd love a movie of Half-life but when I think about it it wouldn't really work as a movie, mute or not.
 

Estocavio

New member
Aug 5, 2009
1,372
0
0
I think he should do what he did in HL2: Refuse to speak at THE WORST POSSIBLE TIMES, and every other time... "A man of few words, i see..."
 

WolfThomas

Man must have a code.
Dec 21, 2007
5,292
0
0
I think he'd definitely have to speak in a movie, but they'd have to have a good script and actor though. I think if it was a combination of dry cynicism, self deprecating humour and the ocaisonal technobabble that would work.