Poll: Escapist: Waffles vs. Pancakes

Recommended Videos

PlayingOpossum

New member
May 5, 2010
50
0
0
Pancakes. Blueberries don't fare well in a waffle iron.

I do think Crepes and Blintzes want in on this deathmatch, too.
 

Feralcentaur

New member
Mar 6, 2010
742
0
0
Neither, because remember,"French toast won't turn you into a ghost!"(I'm trying to make a catchy saying for French toast lovers)Although out of the two I would choose Waffles for they, as you said, hold Maple syrup and Margarine/Butter far better than those silly pancakes.
 

Sakurazaki1023

New member
Feb 15, 2010
681
0
0
Wereduck said:
Interesting - I'd go with pancakes for their tactical flexibility.
Certainly the waffle can withstand the addition of post-preparation toppings with little-to-no effect on the waffle itself. However, one finds pancakes with an extraordinary variety of additions during preparation. All kinds of things can be chopped into pancake batter and be awesome whereas they're only distractions when added cold on top (as with waffle-toppings).

Admittedly, I'm not aware of any reason why one couldn't put the same variety of ingredients into waffle batter too but I've rarely seen it done. To me that suggests that getting creative with the batter creates technical problems (e.g. too much chance of waffles sticking to the iron or disintegrating during release or somesuch). Any waffle cookers out there who can speak on this from experience?
That is actually the exact reason that trying to add things to waffle batter doesn't work. Unlike a pancake that's cooked quickly on each side, the extra surface area of a waffle makes it hard to maintain a smooth product with a chunky batter. It also complicated matters if the add-in can melt (like chocolate) because this will almost guarantee sticking. The only type of pre-cooking addition that will work with waffles is a liquid or semi-liquid addition like peanut butter (Peanut butter waffles topped with preserves are f-ing awesome BTW).

Pancakes are far more conducive to pre-cooking additives while waffles offer more structural stability after cooking. In light of this, I'm just going to call it a tie...

Actually, make that a 3-way tie because crepes are also awesome.

(Normally I'd make a sarcastic comment about the absurdity of us breaking down breakfast items into a precision science, but as an engineering student and cooking enthusiast it's my duty to take this to the logical extreme. On an unrelated note, I've attempted to make bacon pancakes in the past. They worked illogically well.)
 

randomsix

New member
Apr 20, 2009
773
0
0
The true elites allow the members of this debate yell all they will: they know French toast is indeed superior.
 

Furbyz

New member
Oct 12, 2009
502
0
0
Sakurazaki1023 said:
Wereduck said:
Interesting - I'd go with pancakes for their tactical flexibility.
Certainly the waffle can withstand the addition of post-preparation toppings with little-to-no effect on the waffle itself. However, one finds pancakes with an extraordinary variety of additions during preparation. All kinds of things can be chopped into pancake batter and be awesome whereas they're only distractions when added cold on top (as with waffle-toppings).

Admittedly, I'm not aware of any reason why one couldn't put the same variety of ingredients into waffle batter too but I've rarely seen it done. To me that suggests that getting creative with the batter creates technical problems (e.g. too much chance of waffles sticking to the iron or disintegrating during release or somesuch). Any waffle cookers out there who can speak on this from experience?
That is actually the exact reason that trying to add things to waffle batter doesn't work. Unlike a pancake that's cooked quickly on each side, the extra surface area of a waffle makes it hard to maintain a smooth product with a chunky batter. It also complicated matters if the add-in can melt (like chocolate) because this will almost guarantee sticking. The only type of pre-cooking addition that will work with waffles is a liquid or semi-liquid addition like peanut butter (Peanut butter waffles topped with preserves are f-ing awesome BTW).

Pancakes are far more conducive to pre-cooking additives while waffles offer more structural stability after cooking. In light of this, I'm just going to call it a tie...

Actually, make that a 3-way tie because crepes are also awesome.

(Normally I'd make a sarcastic comment about the absurdity of us breaking down breakfast items into a precision science, but as an engineering student and cooking enthusiast it's my duty to take this to the logical extreme. On an unrelated note, I've attempted to make bacon pancakes in the past. They worked illogically well.)
You sir are a mad fucking genius.
 

Sakurazaki1023

New member
Feb 15, 2010
681
0
0
Furbyz said:
Sakurazaki1023 said:
Wereduck said:
Interesting - I'd go with pancakes for their tactical flexibility.
Certainly the waffle can withstand the addition of post-preparation toppings with little-to-no effect on the waffle itself. However, one finds pancakes with an extraordinary variety of additions during preparation. All kinds of things can be chopped into pancake batter and be awesome whereas they're only distractions when added cold on top (as with waffle-toppings).

Admittedly, I'm not aware of any reason why one couldn't put the same variety of ingredients into waffle batter too but I've rarely seen it done. To me that suggests that getting creative with the batter creates technical problems (e.g. too much chance of waffles sticking to the iron or disintegrating during release or somesuch). Any waffle cookers out there who can speak on this from experience?
That is actually the exact reason that trying to add things to waffle batter doesn't work. Unlike a pancake that's cooked quickly on each side, the extra surface area of a waffle makes it hard to maintain a smooth product with a chunky batter. It also complicated matters if the add-in can melt (like chocolate) because this will almost guarantee sticking. The only type of pre-cooking addition that will work with waffles is a liquid or semi-liquid addition like peanut butter (Peanut butter waffles topped with preserves are f-ing awesome BTW).

Pancakes are far more conducive to pre-cooking additives while waffles offer more structural stability after cooking. In light of this, I'm just going to call it a tie...

Actually, make that a 3-way tie because crepes are also awesome.

(Normally I'd make a sarcastic comment about the absurdity of us breaking down breakfast items into a precision science, but as an engineering student and cooking enthusiast it's my duty to take this to the logical extreme. On an unrelated note, I've attempted to make bacon pancakes in the past. They worked illogically well.)
You sir are a mad fucking genius.
Thank you.

It might just be the combination of engineering and cooking, but I have the insane tendency to combine food that were never meant to be combined (but they still come out delicious).

Now, anyone up for some lime-kiwi-vanilla ice cream?

(I'm not joking, I've made it, and it was awesome.)
 

Lilani

Sometimes known as CaitieLou
May 27, 2009
6,581
0
0
Choppaduel said:
Sanvich...
pancakes...
gravy...
soup...
pie...
jello...
bacon...
corn...
cupcake...
You, sir, just won this thread.

Anyhow, I like both equally. It just depends on the mood I'm in, I guess. But I must say, this morning I had some pancakes made from repurposed crepe mix, and they were a whole new kind of delicious.
 

Luftwaffles

New member
Apr 24, 2010
776
0
0
Well......can pancakes fly??????

But i do agree, while waffles are better at holding toppings, the pancake takes the cake(HAH!) for versatility and ease of production.
 

SovietX

New member
Sep 8, 2009
438
0
0
Waffles are awesome because the grooves hold the maple syrup.

Pancakes are awesome because they are easy to make and they taste good with anything.

ITS A TIE!
 

Dr Snakeman

New member
Apr 2, 2010
1,611
0
0
That's a good question. I loves me some IHOP, and all their options for stuff to put on a stack of pancakes. However, my mom makes some kick-ass Belgian waffles.

So, I'm going to Take A Third Option and say French toast. I've actually been eating more of that lately than waffles or pancakes.

French toast... surrendering to my hunger is what it does best. ;)
 

One of Many

New member
Feb 3, 2010
331
0
0
randomsix said:
The true elites allow the members of this debate yell all they will: they know French toast is indeed superior.
BURN THE HERETIC!!!!

All know that waffles are the better breakfast food.