Guilty Gear and its successor BlazBlue: :3 apart from the characters, being both interesting and diverse, and the sound track, which i have select cuts of in my MP3 play when i go for walks ( mostly Guilty Gear XX and Overture, look of Overtures Diva and The Man for some Epic win) but the story, BlazBlue is better about this then GG, as the ARCADE MODE gave me just enough to make me want to play the story mode, well more, was gonna anyway, ( also, i like how that even thought BlazBlue is the successor of GG, NO ONE PLAYS LIKE ANYONE FROM GUILTY GEAR, there all fresh feeling game play wise, even if the designs lean more toward one character being anothers counter part, EI Ragna = Sol in effect
next is Killer Instinct: this game was and still is, AWSOME, and before the F'ed it all up in 2/gold had the BEST combo system in a game EVER, side name me another fighter where you can have a ninja, fight a were wolf, dinosaur, an ice alien, living fire, a skeleton, robot, an indian and a demon ( or what ever Eyedol is )in the same line up, if you haven't played it, you need to.
and for the guilty pleasure fighter, Bloody Roar 3, a 3D fighter, and button masher basicly, where you can turn into a were-beast mid fight for more damage an some health regen, not the best fighter out there, in game play or story, but since i can rip out throuts mid mate in were form, it gets my vote, sides, its got a killer were-bunny named Alice, i defire you to come up with something as awsome as that XD
as for the options on the poll ... tekken is a button masher to me

and is as over hyped as Street Fighter, and i could never get into Mortal Kobmat, tryed a few times, but never got me, Soul Calibur *sighs* yeah, thats fun an all, but the sound effect an the narrator being all ' its the most epic thing ever' for every fight, got on my nerves after awhile,