Hard to say. I'm a big fan of polearms, in general. However, having a main protagonist with fist weapons (cesti, katar, brass knuckles, catclaws, etc.) is something I haven't seen before (not counting Dante's Beowulf weapon), so that would be pretty cool. Especially if the main character is a magic user, in which case small personal weapons of the sort indicate well-roundedness as well as awesomeness.
Then again, maybe I'm still just pissed off that mages in WoW can't use fist weapons. I'll go with polearms/staves.