Poll: Gears of War 2 Review (Go to igetpwned.blogspot.com for more semi-hilarious reviews)

Recommended Videos

sneak_copter

New member
Nov 3, 2008
1,204
0
0
D_987 said:
sneak_copter said:
mentor07825 said:
I find your lack of review disturbing....NOW DIE!!!

[http://photobucket.com/images/darth%20sidius]
Constructive Criticism FTW!
Neither of you are helping matters - why don't you at least comment instead of spamming to get up your post count...?
Darn you for spoiling my fun.

OK, it wasn't a bad review. But it was far too short and went into nearly no detail.
 

D_987

New member
Jun 15, 2008
4,839
0
0
sneak_copter said:
Well you didn't comment either.
I suggest you look above...

But even if I had produced spam - thats one of the most juvenile responses I've ever witnessed - "Its ok for me to spam because you did!". What sort of mind-set is that?
 

Hey Joe

New member
Dec 23, 2007
2,025
0
0
Where to begin?

Paragraphs and depth have apparently gone AWOL in an attempt to be like Yahtzee. You're not Yahtzee, and don't promote your blog if it's going to contain more of the same.
 

scotth266

Wait when did I get a sub
Jan 10, 2009
5,202
0
0
BLARG ADVERTISEMENTS IN THE TITLE!

...I haven't even read this, but I can already tell one major problem: a lack of understanding as to what a paragraph is.

...And now I've read it. Dear gods above.

Look, humor in a review is appreciated. Making a bunch of jokes and having that constitute your entire review is not. You've also got your facts wrong: there are certainly more than four weapons. There are four weapon slots specific to certain kinds of weapons, but you made it sound as if there's only four guns in the whole game!

The rest of your review isn't much more factual than that either. All I can say is: ugh. Please, try harder next time, if there will be a next time. And don't advertise your blog on top of that.
 

Cartman2nd

New member
May 19, 2009
213
0
0
Zero Punctuation rip-off. And what up with saying its semi-hilarious. You have to let other people say that.
 

NoNameMcgee

New member
Feb 24, 2009
2,104
0
0
Sorry mate, I know you were trying to be funny but I hardly smiled while reading it; and it did seem like you were ripping off Yahtzee a little with some of your comments.

I've found that the review section is a place for real reviews, and if people mess about too much in this section of the site then others get annoyed. Serious biznez and all that. =]

But yeah, if you do another review try reviewing the game more instead of just making fun of it. Taking the piss out of a game you dislike is perfectly allowed (believe me, i've done it many times) but you need to make valid points inbetween all that or it's just not really a review.
 

PurpleRain

New member
Dec 2, 2007
5,001
0
0
Aside from the mentioned, I only feel that I should post to stop the inhuman treatment of words (I say that in a jovial manner and not offensive). When using the word 'literally' you should actually back it up with actual things that happen.

soaringbiscuit said:
...Marcus and Dom, literally mow down hundreds of Locusts with their spit...
Unless you talk about the spit from the barrel of a gun, I don't think there was a button to spit on people. Here's me wishing there was though. (Sad face)

soaringbiscuit said:
(If you're a girl, the above could be counted as a bad)
Also, that's a bit of sexism.
 

soaringbiscuit

New member
Apr 25, 2009
246
0
0
PurpleRain said:
Aside from the mentioned, I only feel that I should post to stop the inhuman treatment of words (I say that in a jovial manner and not offensive). When using the word 'literally' you should actually back it up with actual things that happen.

soaringbiscuit said:
...Marcus and Dom, literally mow down hundreds of Locusts with their spit...
Unless you talk about the spit from the barrel of a gun, I don't think there was a button to spit on people. Here's me wishing there was though. (Sad face)

soaringbiscuit said:
(If you're a girl, the above could be counted as a bad)
Also, that's a bit of sexism.
Not exactly. I don't know many girls that would like to be changed into a rabid wolverine, or, indeed, many boys either.
 

WrongSprite

Resident Morrowind Fanboy
Aug 10, 2008
4,503
0
0
Basically, you need to review something to put it in the user reviews section. This is not a review, this goes in game discussion.
 

soaringbiscuit

New member
Apr 25, 2009
246
0
0
Cartman2nd said:
Zero Punctuation rip-off. And what up with saying its semi-hilarious. You have to let other people say that.
scotth266 said:
BLARG ADVERTISEMENTS IN THE TITLE!

...I haven't even read this, but I can already tell one major problem: a lack of understanding as to what a paragraph is.

...And now I've read it. Dear gods above.

Look, humor in a review is appreciated. Making a bunch of jokes and having that constitute your entire review is not. You've also got your facts wrong: there are certainly more than four weapons. There are four weapon slots specific to certain kinds of weapons, but you made it sound as if there's only four guns in the whole game!

The rest of your review isn't much more factual than that either. All I can say is: ugh. Please, try harder next time, if there will be a next time. And don't advertise your blog on top of that.
Yeah, it was terrible. We've established that.
 

PurpleRain

New member
Dec 2, 2007
5,001
0
0
soaringbiscuit said:
PurpleRain said:
soaringbiscuit said:
(If you're a girl, the above could be counted as a bad)
Also, that's a bit of sexism.
Not exactly. I don't know many girls that would like to be changed into a rabid wolverine, or, indeed, many boys either.
Just because the main character is a guy who so happens to be overly manly, doesn't effect the joy nor the gameplay for either sex.
 

soaringbiscuit

New member
Apr 25, 2009
246
0
0
PurpleRain said:
soaringbiscuit said:
PurpleRain said:
soaringbiscuit said:
(If you're a girl, the above could be counted as a bad)
Also, that's a bit of sexism.
Not exactly. I don't know many girls that would like to be changed into a rabid wolverine, or, indeed, many boys either.
Just because the main character is a guy who so happens to be overly manly, doesn't effect the joy nor the gameplay for either sex.
We're forgetting this was a terrible review for a terrible purpose: cheap humor. But no, it wasn't intended as a slur or the whole men-are-better thing.
 

Tech Team FTW!

New member
Apr 1, 2009
1,049
0
0
Is there something wrong with paragraphs?
Are you allergic to them?

Intending it to be cheap humour does not excuse you for making a poor review.

Also, please don't advertise in your title again.
 

scotth266

Wait when did I get a sub
Jan 10, 2009
5,202
0
0
Pi_Fighter said:
Is there something wrong with paragraphs?
Are you allergic to them?

Intending it to be cheap humour does not excuse you for making a poor review.

Also, please don't advertise in your title again.
Dude, he made a better one and learned from his mistakes. No need to slap him when he fixed himself....
 

soaringbiscuit

New member
Apr 25, 2009
246
0
0
Pi_Fighter said:
Is there something wrong with paragraphs?
Are you allergic to them?

Intending it to be cheap humour does not excuse you for making a poor review.

Also, please don't advertise in your title again.
I made a better one, you can look it up.
 

Thyunda

New member
May 4, 2009
2,955
0
0
D_987 said:
soaringbiscuit said:
I'm new here. Is there a humor-type thread?
Theres a difference between a humorous review and a pure joke thread. Joke threads are looked down upon because they arn't funny and just take up space for the genuine reviews that people spend a lot of time writing.

You can always create a "funny" review, but try and make it a good review at the same time.
Oh! Oh! Like mine?