Poll: Halo 3: ODST or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Real Halo 2

Recommended Videos

DeadWaker718

New member
Mar 5, 2009
48
0
0
Let me get something out of the way at the very start of this review. I am a fan of Halo... That's it. Halo:Combat Evolved. Not 2, not three. I understand that may make some people angry, so that's why I included the poll. I felt that Halo 2 and 3 were just trying to hard, had horrendous cliffhangers and the gameplay felt less...solid. I will post my retrospective review of the HALO series as a whole so you can flame to your hearts content D:. Anyways, onto ODST.

I have to say, as soon as I heard of the concept of Halo 3: ODST(hence referred to as ODST, even though the original name "Recon" sounded better) I was pretty hooked. Instead of being the one-man army killing tank that is Master Chief, playing a more vulnerable character, one of the grunts. I always felt these boys in black got a little shafted in the games so it's good to see them get some comeuppance. So the game starts with your drop-pod malfunctioning and most of your team scattered or dead...Yaaaaay comeuppance? Okay, kidding aside, the story's delivery was very satisfying and the additions of Firefly Alumni Nathan Fillion and Adam Baldwin really helped sell the characters to me and made me sympathyze with them. To the point that I actually cared when they teased us with the idea of some of the characters dying. Of course in True Bungie Cocktease fashion they never definitively die. The only story thing that disappoints is that the Elites aren't the enemies in this game, just the Brutes eve though this game takes place before the rebellion. In the words of Aristotle "WTF guys?"

But now onto the true defining factor: Gameplay. This game is, as my deliciously beautiful title suggests is what I call the "Real Halo 2". What makes this real? The simplee fact that it's a continuation of the design principles of HALO 1. Halo to me was never about confidently striding through a tide of flood, only pausing to one-liner and reload. It's a game about vulnerability. Most of the time in Halo 1, you were outnumbered by tons of well trained, lethal soldiers or things that just...won't...die! And ODST captures that beautifully, the energy shield (or stamina, so I like to call it "Energy Refractive Biceps") is more of a fail safe for when you do screw up rather than an excuse to plunge into the fray single-handedly and I love the return to the single-weapon-at-a-time system which makes you really consider your weapon choice and tactical options. I'm also glad that Bungie decided to let the Flood take the day off and didn't try to shoehorn them in there. The Brutes make for an interesting challenge and the return of the scoped pistol is a godsend. My only complaint is that its $60 for all that when even Bungie said that $40 was the most they'd charge for what is at best an expansion pack, remember Aristotle guys...

I don't have XBOX Live so I can't comment on the quality of the Multiplayer but I've played enough firefight to know that its as cool as it was when Gears of War 2 did the same thing and that Halo 3's multiplayer is a wheel that is quite safe from reinvention.

Overall, I think ODST is a marvellous return to form for Bungie, it's pacing, story, delivery and acting is on a much higher level than their previous Halo-sequels, but my parting shot(aside from the very out of whack Price-Amount ratio) is why was it Halo 3: OSDT, the 3 isn't really necessary. It's more about HALO 2. I guess they were just cashing in on the best selling video game of all time.

I give HALO 3: ODST an 8.75 out of 10, just shy of videogame nirvana and, like every videogame, can only be brought to a 10 by the inclusion of Jesus fighting The God-Emperor of Mankind and God-Emperor of Dune...or adding Liam Neeson
 

Vrex360

Badass Alien
Mar 2, 2009
8,379
0
0
Good review, I liked reading it. I also agree with your comment about the Elites as in they should have been in the game in all fairness. But yeah a decent review and somewhat well constructed, I approve.
 

Vrex360

Badass Alien
Mar 2, 2009
8,379
0
0
DeadWaker718 said:
Thanks for your comment, but doesn't this mean you technically just reviewed my review?
Indeed, a review after all is a complex expression of opinion, hence my post was exactly that just smaller.
Arguably you could call all posts comments on a youtube video 'mini reviews'
 

WrongSprite

Resident Morrowind Fanboy
Aug 10, 2008
4,503
0
0
DeadWaker718 said:
Thanks for your comment, but doesn't this mean you technically just reviewed my review?
It's called feedback, it's why most people post reviews here, to get feedback so they can improve their reviewing.
 

Iron Mal

New member
Jun 4, 2008
2,749
0
0
Vrex360 said:
Indeed, a review after all is a complex expression of opinion, hence my post was exactly that just smaller.
Arguably you could call all posts comments on a youtube video 'mini reviews'
While you have a very good point I beg to differ when you say 'all' the comments on Youtube are mini reviews (look around there for a while and you will no doubt find people who do one of the following: get into fights and flamewars with others, simply say something like 'this rocks' or'funny at 1:47 LOL!', adverts and links for porn sites and, sometimes, statements that are completely irrelevent to the video and what anyone else has written).

Onto the review itself however, well written and some good points were made (it does get a bit strange when the Flood appear yet again despite having been allegedly nuked in the last game).

Keep up the good work.
 

DeadWaker718

New member
Mar 5, 2009
48
0
0
WrongSprite said:
DeadWaker718 said:
Thanks for your comment, but doesn't this mean you technically just reviewed my review?
It's called feedback, it's why most people post reviews here, to get feedback so they can improve their reviewing.
Well, yes I'm aware of this feedback contraption, I just meant his delivery seemed like a review as well. I must remember that delivery of what one says is difficult to translate over the internet
 

Vrex360

Badass Alien
Mar 2, 2009
8,379
0
0
Iron Mal said:
Vrex360 said:
Indeed, a review after all is a complex expression of opinion, hence my post was exactly that just smaller.
Arguably you could call all posts comments on a youtube video 'mini reviews'
While you have a very good point I beg to differ when you say 'all' the comments on Youtube are mini reviews (look around there for a while and you will no doubt find people who do one of the following: get into fights and flamewars with others, simply say something like 'this rocks' or'funny at 1:47 LOL!', adverts and links for porn sites and, sometimes, statements that are completely irrelevent to the video and what anyone else has written).
Yeah, this is true.
I suppose I shouldn't really have put youtube in this context, but still I hold true to my basic idea.
 

Iron Mal

New member
Jun 4, 2008
2,749
0
0
Vrex360 said:
Yeah, this is true.
I suppose I shouldn't really have put youtube in this context, but still I hold true to my basic idea.
Fair enough, I still agree with you and believe you have a good point.
 

Sonicron

Do the buttwalk!
Mar 11, 2009
5,133
0
0
Hmm. You know, this is actually the first review I've read of this game that makes me want to give it a try. I know the damn thing has been out for months, I just couldn't be bothered to even rent it. The first Halo game I ever played was Halo 3, then I played Halo 1 and 2... and aside from the fact that I don't understand all the rabid hate Halo 2 received (and continues to do so) I have to agree with you, the first game was best regarding gameplay. If what you say in your review holds true then I guess I know what I'll be playing and enjoying next weekend.
Keep it up!
 

Dyp100

New member
Jul 14, 2009
898
0
0
-Makes Aquila- Emperor be with you.

And yeah, it is the most similar to Halo 1, but a lot smoother and easier to play IMO. It's nice and interesting and definitely better then Halo 3, even though Halo 2 is probably my favourite Halo, I mean, even the pistol isn't that bad in my hands. (In multi player anyway, I'm sorry but spamming it dual wield is so fun. xD)
 

sneeky033

dAT cAPSLOCK
Dec 1, 2009
119
0
0
my only complaint is the lack of firefight matchmaking. Left 2 Dead 2's "Survival" mode has it and it's one of my favorite features in the game. c'mon Bungie, what were you thinking?
 

DeadWaker718

New member
Mar 5, 2009
48
0
0
Thanks for all of the positive feedback guys!

@IdealistCommi- How do you add pictures btw? Escapist Forums weren't behaving.

@Sonicron and Dyp 100- Halo 1 is really good, No argument there, and I picked up ODST a week after it came out for $40 bucks from a friend. It also seems my Avatar outranks yours.
FOR THE ME!
 

MasterMongoose0

New member
Nov 3, 2009
195
0
0
I really enjoy all the parts of the Halo series, personally.

I loved Halo: CE for being a fun co-op console shooter that actually implemented vehicles significantly better than most modern games.

I loved Halo 2 for being the first true console online shooter, and still having an above average campaign with high production values.

I loved Halo 3 for having some truly stellar levels ("The Covenant" and "The Ark" most notably) as well as a more streamlined approach to multiplayer and the inclusion of Forge.

And ODST rounds it out by making the narrative more focused, creating some cool characters, and giving me the best multiplayer mode in any game this side of Left 4 Dead 2.

Nice review!
 

FlyAwayAutumn

Rating: Negative Awesome
May 19, 2009
747
0
0
To be fair the elites were in ODST there was a dead body of one lying around. Anyway I enjoy halo 3 because it's multiplayer at it's best for halo it offers a lot of replay value for me.
 

Punisher A.J.

New member
Nov 18, 2009
445
0
0
Nothing is better than the original..... well except.

NFSU:2
KHII
assassin's creed 2
DEF Jam:NY
DW 6
Smackdown: shut you mouth
and a few others

But the main point is the original is usually the best.