well when it comes to movies i have yet to get scared at anything since i was 9, but video games are a whole different story
i can play through them, will jump when they get a jump scare out of you, which is fine, thats what scares me the most
creepiness kind of does, as usually i will be running low on health or the such and i freaking hate knowing there is something coming up, just dont know exactly when.
i have this weird thing though, where anytime i play any kind of survival game or horror game, i immediately have dreams about it, (try having a dream after play 4 hours of l4d2, its one of the most exhilirating and craziest things i have woken up from, that bastard AI in the dream was just as difficult as usual) so i tend to stay away from them now a days, as i wake up sweating like a pig during 100 degree weather, and end up panting like i just ran a 5 mile sprint
so probably a 2.5