Poll: hypothetical battle saturday: wolverine vs darth vader

Recommended Videos

Something Amyss

Aswyng and Amyss
Dec 3, 2008
24,759
0
0
MHR said:
Right, but can Wolverine regenerate instantly from such damage? My guess is that with the cauterizing and the broad strokes from the saber, definitely not. Vader can, by other means, destroy or remove wolverine while he is sufficiently disabled.
Well, here's the thing: comic books operate as the story dictates at the time. They make Star Wars look like it has a solid and consistent power set (considering they have had Force users destroy planets and Super Star Destroyers, that's something). Wolverine's healed pretty fast in the past. He's actually regenerated near-total destruction from Cyclops' optic blasts (which at the exact same time were described as capable of pulverising adamantium to dust) in the course of a panel or two. But he doesn't do that all the time.

Not a Wolverine deal, but we've had Bruce Wayne shrug off explosions, and The Punisher fell like 400 stories without so much as a broken bone. If even "normal" people in comics can suddenly develop immunities to things like falling and explosives,Wolverine suddenly regrowing his head doesn't see m all that weird. Hell, the above example of Wolverine putting his legs back on wouldn't have happened in the 90s, because Deadpool was the only one of the Weapon X guys who could do that OR truly regenerate.

Most media has inconsistencies, especially if you're talking a large franchise. But comics? There's so much dissonance in one continuity alone, you can literally justify almost anything. Especially when humour exists in the same continuity.

In fact, the ultimate answer to "who would win between (two comic characters) is "whose comic is it?" Spider-Man's gone toe-to-toe with Thanos, Punisher's beat the Hulk, and even the Juggernaut has been punked outside of the X-Men books.

So yeah, in a medium with less consistency than Calvinball, how do we even measure this sort of thing?
 

shootthebandit

New member
May 20, 2009
3,867
0
0
Zachary Amaranth said:
MHR said:
Right, but can Wolverine regenerate instantly from such damage? My guess is that with the cauterizing and the broad strokes from the saber, definitely not. Vader can, by other means, destroy or remove wolverine while he is sufficiently disabled.
Well, here's the thing: comic books operate as the story dictates at the time. They make Star Wars look like it has a solid and consistent power set (considering they have had Force users destroy planets and Super Star Destroyers, that's something). Wolverine's healed pretty fast in the past. He's actually regenerated near-total destruction from Cyclops' optic blasts (which at the exact same time were described as capable of pulverising adamantium to dust) in the course of a panel or two. But he doesn't do that all the time.

Not a Wolverine deal, but we've had Bruce Wayne shrug off explosions, and The Punisher fell like 400 stories without so much as a broken bone. If even "normal" people in comics can suddenly develop immunities to things like falling and explosives,Wolverine suddenly regrowing his head doesn't see m all that weird. Hell, the above example of Wolverine putting his legs back on wouldn't have happened in the 90s, because Deadpool was the only one of the Weapon X guys who could do that OR truly regenerate.

Most media has inconsistencies, especially if you're talking a large franchise. But comics? There's so much dissonance in one continuity alone, you can literally justify almost anything. Especially when humour exists in the same continuity.

In fact, the ultimate answer to "who would win between (two comic characters) is "whose comic is it?" Spider-Man's gone toe-to-toe with Thanos, Punisher's beat the Hulk, and even the Juggernaut has been punked outside of the X-Men books.

So yeah, in a medium with less consistency than Calvinball, how do we even measure this sort of thing?
Ive edited the OP recently it states that logan cant regrow limbs and decapitation is lethal (assuming the adamantium can be destroyed)

As i said before if you dont think any limitations i make are fair them feel free to let me know
 

Morsomk_v1legacy

RUMBA RUMBA RUMBA RUMBA RUMBA
Jan 30, 2013
2,940
0
0
Hmm....I would say Vader for the sheer fact that after he manages to stop Logan for brief moments, that he could either throw into the carbonite machine, space or both at the same time. That is saying if he manages to stop him before Logan destroys the life support system Vader is hooked to.