Poll: Imagine Yahtzee, The Angry Nerd, Nostagia Critic and Linkara joining up to review a movie!

[YoUnG205]

NO

 

[BENZOOKA]

That just wouldn't work at all.

 

[mrtenk]

No, because it would become cluttered full of people trying to "outfunny" each other.

 

[The Random One]

Most of those guys have a style that works better when they're alone. So, no.

 

[Bob the Average]

to many people doing the same thing in really different ways it just wouldn't mesh.

 

[Chris^^]

just stupid, theyre all pretty much solo operators..

 

[hailmagus]

Dear god,the awesomeness would make the universe implode!

So, would it work?

I don't know who Linkara is, but for some reason I don't think it would work anyway. Yahtzee and the Nerd would constantly be trying to out do the others anger... yeah it wouldn't be pretty. Yahtzee seems like the type of person that hates Americans too. And the Nerd would probably poop on Yahtzee's face like he did with Bugs Bunny... and then Yahtzee would cry. JK (or am I!?)

But in all fairness, Yahtzee's cameo on Unskippable was fantastic. Now to take back my "in all fairness"... no, it still wouldn't work. + idk who Nostalgia Critic is either.

 

[jboking]

I feel like they would clash too much. There styles wouldn't mesh terribly well and there would be a constant power struggle.

It's just better if they don't do this.

 

[Syphonz]

the feeling i got with Yahtzee on Unskippable is that he doesn't work well with others. He just seems out of place, its like Yahtzee is that guy that walks into a room filled with people and insults everyone for the fun of it, and then tries to fit in despite everyone feeling off-put by their first impression.

 

[Carlston]

Seperate styles, Seperate games, Y likes to review games out in the last 15 years, Nerd is funny in a Nostalgia way but to pad out games that are short, repetative all he can do is string profanities together like a bored 9 year old.

 

[Queen Michael]

Yes it would work. Here's why: Because they are all competent reviewers who do good jobsa nd whose reviews are entertaining.

 

[BenzSmoke]

No, they'd get in eachothers way.

 

[Kurokami]

Dear god,the awesomeness would make the universe implode!

So, would it work?

wouldn't they be talking over each other the whole time? They'll gradually get louder and louder until finally all we hear is "THAT'S IT MOF***ER, I'M TAKIN YOU DOWN!"

 

[hazabaza1]

No. AVGN is more of a swear bucket, Linkara and NC had their best when it was just those two, and I'd think that Yahtzee would pretty much hate them all.

 

[imp_spittle]

I'm reminded of the end of a Zero Punctuation wherein Yahtzee states that two great things mixed together don't always work, using the example of a syringe-removal of the creme from a Cadbury Egg and replacing that creme with Branston Pickle. So, no, absolutely not. They all work best flying solo, which is typically the best way to go about criticism.

 

[Lord Beautiful]

Replace Linkara and the AVGN with Spoony and Benzaie, and then you got something. As it is, no. I'm not a fan of AVGN and Linkara just isn't funny.

 

[smargh1015]

first of all i dont know who linkara is and i dont care second of all the 3 i do know have such a contrast of reviewing stylethat it would just be wierd. plus the Avgn an NC sorta teamed up before. also totally check out the Avgn for some hilaiously profantic shitty game reviews.

 

[Misterian]

we're dealing with several different critics with different point of views.

I can see quite a few ways why that wouldn't work.

I say let only Yahtzee review the movie.

 

[Thaius]

Probably would turn into a mess. But if they could pull it off, it would be interesting.

Oh, and The Spoony One has to be in there. I mean he was an inspiration to Yahtzee: he has to be there.