Poll: Is Anything Possible?

Recommended Videos

crudus

New member
Oct 20, 2008
4,415
0
0
Aylaine said:
Shankity Stick said:
I dare anyone to disprove ANYTHING, if you factor in magic, other planets, and alternate dimensions. My logic is that we can't prove that something definitely doesn't exist/ happen somewhere out there. That is the one thing that is impossible. But by all means, try to disprove something to me.
P.S. anyone trying to disprove something visual I?m sick of repeating my self so here goes, maybe x is happening, you just don't realize it.
We can't have world peace, because of free will.

Try to disprove that.
I'll give it a shot.

Before I begin, what constitutes a breaking of world peace? Petty crime? murder? isolation of each individual person not even to mate? Before I begin an argument we are going to have to agree on terms.
 

Jaranja

New member
Jul 16, 2009
3,275
0
0
crudus said:
Shankity Stick said:
But by all means, try to disprove something to me.
A square with 3 sides can't exist. Not even magic can do this because if you do you either make a triangle or an object that is not a polygon. I am of course assuming you don't take the easy way out and start changing definitions at which point I will change your "anything" to mean "almost anything" at which point I will agree.

Susano said:
Breaking the laws of physics.
go to the center of a black hole or you know, look around you(physics was broken at least once to get you to exist).
I have decided to take the easy way out! If someone was brought up to believe a square had 3 sides. they're not strictly wrong. Badow!

I suck.
 

crudus

New member
Oct 20, 2008
4,415
0
0
Aylaine said:
Basically that.
Ok. Well I can go with two things then. Either you take the one with the nations not fight at which point I say "aliens attack, go earth!". Basically the only real war between humans is to have a third party they can attack. If you mean there is no crime then I say eradicate the planet or do the isolation thing I said.
 

Mcface

New member
Aug 30, 2009
2,266
0
0
crudus said:
Aylaine said:
Shankity Stick said:
I dare anyone to disprove ANYTHING, if you factor in magic, other planets, and alternate dimensions. My logic is that we can't prove that something definitely doesn't exist/ happen somewhere out there. That is the one thing that is impossible. But by all means, try to disprove something to me.
P.S. anyone trying to disprove something visual I?m sick of repeating my self so here goes, maybe x is happening, you just don't realize it.
We can't have world peace, because of free will.

Try to disprove that.
I'll give it a shot.

Before I begin, what constitutes a breaking of world peace? Petty crime? murder? isolation of each individual person not even to mate? Before I begin an argument we are going to have to agree on terms.
There has never been world peace as long as humans have been around. To hope otherwise is just that, hope. Nothing more, because It won't happen. There will always be war to some degree or another. The Middle East has been in a constant war for thousands of years. As long as there is religion, there will be war. As long as there is currency, there will be war.

Many people point to ancient China as proof it is possible, only on a larger scale. The whole "one ruler, through battle, unites the world under one flag." This is impossible. Even if one were actually able to literally conquer the known world, there are so many different religions, rebels, political groups, etc, that they would constantly be fighting, even if their country was taken. It's damn hard to have total control over a land that is thousands and thousands miles away from it's capital, across a ocean, and then some.
 

righthead

New member
Sep 3, 2009
175
0
0
World peace is not a good example of something that's not possible. The world will have peace when everything's dead. Like Mars. I like something like, it is impossible to get me to type "I think Celine Dion is the best musician ever" Into a public forum... crap.
 

Shynobee

New member
Apr 16, 2009
541
0
0
Ok, in exactly 5 seconds after me finishing this post, I want 5 million dollars to pop out of my computer screen and onto my lap. Ready.... go!
 

F-I-D-O

I miss my avatar
Feb 18, 2010
1,095
0
0
crudus said:
Shankity Stick said:
crudus said:
Shankity Stick said:
Susano said:
Breaking the laws of physics.
Different dimensions man.
Even different dimensions have laws of physics that can't be broken. They are different laws but laws nonetheless.
But if our laws can be broken there, then who's to say theirs can't be broken some where else, plus there is (possibly) an infinite number of dimensions, therefore, an infinite number of dimensions to break each others rules.
Ok, say I, a good looking 20-something, go to live in Illinois where the age of consent is 17. I just can't wait to do the horizontal monster mash with my sexy 16-year-old girlfriend. So we go to Indiana(age of consent there is 16). We rent a nice hotel room and do the deed there. We didn't break any laws by Indiana's standards nor Illinois' because their laws do not pertain to what happens in Indiana. The same thing goes when cross dimensions. You still stay within the confines of the laws of physics; the laws of physics are just different.
Very...disturbing...comparison.

OT: Some things are impossible such as circles with four corners, my computer running Crysis, and DRM working out.
(you references OP from now on)
Even in other dimensions there are laws which CANNOT be broken, hence there are impossible things. And since there is more than likely one such law that binds the dimensions together that all of them follow. This law likely cannot be broken, and since you cannot prove such a law does NOT exist (another impossibility-proving something doesn't exist) you cannot make a rebuttal.
 

Shynobee

New member
Apr 16, 2009
541
0
0
1...2...3...4...5... TIMES UP!

Nope, no money.

So, I believe money flying out of my computer with in an alotted time falls under the category of "anything."

Thus, anything is not possible.
 

F-I-D-O

I miss my avatar
Feb 18, 2010
1,095
0
0
Shynobee said:
1...2...3...4...5... TIMES UP!

Nope, no money.

So, I believe money flying out of my computer with in an alotted time falls under the category of "anything."

Thus, anything is not possible.
Money popped out of mine, does that count?
EDIT: Damn, forgot to take off those 3D glasses.
EDIT2: Hey, its real! I'm going to go buy a computer than can run Crysis!
(a trip to best buy later)
Now to see it work!
(One install later)
Never mind, running Crysis is impossible.
 

Shynobee

New member
Apr 16, 2009
541
0
0
F-I-D-O said:
Shynobee said:
1...2...3...4...5... TIMES UP!

Nope, no money.

So, I believe money flying out of my computer with in an alotted time falls under the category of "anything."

Thus, anything is not possible.
Money popped out of mine, does that count?
No, i specified my computer.

On a side note, YOU LUCKY BASTARD!
 

righthead

New member
Sep 3, 2009
175
0
0
Lewis Carroll presented a similar argument in the other direction in through the looking glass (I think, I never read the book, just saw the quote.) by the mock turtle.

It is actually quite easy to disprove something, as long as that something is everything. Say, everything is made of pineapples. With everything taken into account as is originally presented, there is bound to be a situation where this is not the case.

Alternatively, the opposite could be presented. That everything is made of not pineapple. if the other is proven to be true then this must be false.

However if you take the position that neither position denies the other then you're basically taking the mock turtle's position: That the verification of a premise does not necessarily indicate any conclusion no matter how directly it follows from said premise.
 

spinFX

New member
Aug 18, 2008
490
0
0
This thread was over as soon as someone mentioned that a 3 sided square cannot exist therefore not anything is possible.
 

righthead

New member
Sep 3, 2009
175
0
0
spinFX said:
This thread was over as soon as someone mentioned that a 3 sided square cannot exist therefore not anything is possible.
I reject your reality and substitute my own.
 

righthead

New member
Sep 3, 2009
175
0
0
righthead said:
spinFX said:
This thread was over as soon as someone mentioned that a 3 sided square cannot exist therefore not anything is possible.
I reject your reality and substitute my own.
whoa, I guess I disproved that this thread was over.
 

crudus

New member
Oct 20, 2008
4,415
0
0
Aylaine said:
Not sure if the latter is possible, because even if they had a third party, several different countries of the world are opposed/hostile to completely different ones, so it's like a bunch of red, aggressive strings on a small globe not all leading to the same place. Also, aliens haven't been proven just yet so I can't accept that they are logically viable for this sort of thing, though if Watchmen has taught us anything that approach "might" work.

Still, I don't feel convinced that world peace is attainable with free will.
Ok, attacking the "countries of the world are opposed/hostile to completely different ones", the same was true for black and whites back in the civil war. White people thought blacks lack courage to fight. This was proven wrong at the battle of Port Hudson, Louisiana on May 27, 1863. About a year later black soldiers were getting paid as well as white soldiers at least this is true for the union. However, by the end of the war the south was offering slaves their freedom for fighting and surviving. Now I am not saying people can forget 1000s of years of hatred long enough to shoot an alien but if the south is willing to free slaves then it could happen.

Also, remember that we have free rein of which universe we are in. So aliens attacking is possible.
 

spartan231490

New member
Jan 14, 2010
5,186
0
0
VGStrife said:
spartan231490 said:
VGStrife said:
spartan231490 said:
it is often said, even in scientific circles, that it is impossible to prove a negative. And that is exactly what it means, you can't prove that something doesnt ever happen somewhere, you can only prove that it is unlikely.
Prove it :p
Idiots, proving my point since 1995.
that was a joke, i dont think your an idiot.
Just for the record i agree with you. But i also believe it is impossible to prove everything is possible (other than trivial solutions).

I also think this thread is quite pointless.
I thought you prolly agreed with me because of the :p, lol. and you are correct, it is beyond our current abilities to prove that everything is possible, we would need to be able to cross dimensions, not to mention guarentee that we completely understood physics. and of course the thread is pointless, it's online discussion. :p all joking aside, its nothing more than an interesting philisophical question, not really useful for anything, other than killing some time.