Poll: Is the Doctor (Doctor Who) Gay?

Recommended Videos

Denamic

New member
Aug 19, 2009
3,804
0
0
Yes, no, definitely, possibly, uncertain and absolutely not.
He's the Doctor.
 

New York Patrick

New member
Jul 29, 2009
462
0
0
HerbertTheHamster said:
interspark said:
HerbertTheHamster said:
I really doubt the BBC would dare to air that, considering doctor who is a family/kids show.
what are you talking about?! Jack was incredibly gay!
Oh yeah, shit. What the fuck am I talking about.

Fairly certain the 11th is asexual, considering how weird his character is.

Jack was bi, btw :p
No, Captain Jack is OMNI... not just Bi. There is a reason for the phrase "anything that moves..."
 

masonfr8kr

New member
Aug 10, 2009
57
0
0
I know this wasn't the current Doctor (I think it was the 9th) but he was flirting with a tree. I really think that he could go for about anything but he's just too busy
 

Mauso88

A Simply Dignified Manly Man.
Feb 3, 2011
265
0
0
Harbinger_ said:
Also please note that he is an alien and therefore not human and also weird by their standards as well.
Agree.

Also, also are Timelords human or a different species like Jaffa from Stargate? Seeing as they look human but are not considered as such.
 

conflictofinterests

New member
Apr 6, 2010
1,098
0
0
Meh, the current Doctor is probably too "zany" to have any really defined sexuality. Please read this as "The 11th Doctor was written for 10 year olds with ADD who wouldn't recognize actual sexual tension if it was the only thing a show covered."

Off Topic:
I can respect the guy's acting, but the shift in character is a bit too much for me to swallow, personally. Like I said, they really dumbed it down (it wasn't particularly subtle to begin with, but still, I'm pretty sure the audience has already grasped that time travel is possible, the Doctor is a millennium or so old with knowledge/experience to match, and can figure out through methods other than "IT'S ALMOST AS IF..." what capabilities other characters have.)
 

conflictofinterests

New member
Apr 6, 2010
1,098
0
0
Mauso88 said:
Harbinger_ said:
Also please note that he is an alien and therefore not human and also weird by their standards as well.
Agree.

Also, also are Timelords human or a different species like Jaffa from Stargate? Seeing as they look human but are not considered as such.
Yeah, Timelords are from Gallifrey. They look like humans, but are not. 2 hearts, regenerative capabilities, incredible longevity, etc.
 

Sejs Cube

New member
Jun 16, 2008
432
0
0
He isn't gay, he isn't straight, he's the Doctor.

That's its own category. And hell, it's a category that changes from regeneration to regeneration. Trying to define it in human terms like homo- or hetero-sexual is to miss the point entirely.
 

darksakul

Old Man? I am not that old .....
Jun 14, 2008
629
0
0
Lets see, Rose Tyler, The very first Doctor has a Granddaughter who shares some of his DNA. TV movie Doctor had a romance with a woman. River song being pushed away by Doc 11 only means he is unsure of his relationship with her, specially since River is from the Doctor's Future.
 

Sarah Frazier

New member
Dec 7, 2010
386
0
0
When you've been alive for 900+ years, eventually you'll start to branch out with what you'll hit and how you'll hit it. The shows just don't focus on the times when he and his companions aren't plopped down just in time for some crisis involving aliens, robots, or some other disaster that threatens a planet.

Just how much time do they get between disasters? What do they do during that time, if they ever actually get any? These are things the audience never really gets to see because it's not as exciting, even if it may become relevant to the characters later on. It just isn't as interesting as, say, bluffing an entire space fleet made up of every one of the Doctor's foes with nothing but the sonic screwdriver.
 

Jaime_Wolf

New member
Jul 17, 2009
1,194
0
0
interspark said:
alright, so he flirted with River but he was waving his hands around like Bernard Black on a Saturday when she was kissing him and backed away from her afterwards
He barely knew her and wasn't expecting that. How many times do people just walk up and kiss him?

interspark said:
also he prances around the place all the time, frequently boasts of men who were attracted to him
He ALSO frequently boasts of women who were attracted to him. And how would other men being gay for him indicate that he was gay?

interspark said:
also, River frequently kissing the doctor could mostly refer to future regenerations
Potential problem: he dies before his next regeneration. And unless the creators are blatantly lying to us, that really was him dying - like dead and not coming back dying. In the Confidential after that episode he made this pretty clear. He was several centuries older, so there's still plenty of story left, but if he died looking as he does now, he isn't going to regenerate into another body.
 

Twilight_guy

Sight, Sound, and Mind
Nov 24, 2008
7,131
0
0
Haven't you ever heard of camp gay? It supposed to be funny since everything in the series indicates a big "no." Besides, he's not even human, he can do what he likes.
 

Sarah Frazier

New member
Dec 7, 2010
386
0
0
Jaime_Wolf said:
interspark said:
alright, so he flirted with River but he was waving his hands around like Bernard Black on a Saturday when she was kissing him and backed away from her afterwards
He barely knew her and wasn't expecting that. How many times do people just walk up and kiss him?

interspark said:
also he prances around the place all the time, frequently boasts of men who were attracted to him
He ALSO frequently boasts of women who were attracted to him. And how would other men being gay for him indicate that he was gay?

interspark said:
also, River frequently kissing the doctor could mostly refer to future regenerations
Potential problem: he dies before his next regeneration. And unless the creators are blatantly lying to us, that really was him dying - like dead and not coming back dying. In the Confidential after that episode he made this pretty clear. He was several centuries older, so there's still plenty of story left, but if he died looking as he does now, he isn't going to regenerate into another body.
I heard through my Dr Who fanatic husband that BBC will be getting around that with a little bit o "Handwavium", claiming that the time lords limited themselves to 12 regenerations because they all draw from a collective pool of energy. With the Doctor being the last Timelord (supposedly, though there is his cloned daughter and possibly future birth daughter), that pool isn't being drained as quickly as when there were however many millions. This means he can effectively immortal until he decides he's done, assuming BBC does go with this idea and the Doctor decides to break a rule that only he is there to enforce.

It is late and I get my rumors third hand at best, so don't count on it being accurate.
 

Jaime_Wolf

New member
Jul 17, 2009
1,194
0
0
Sarah Frazier said:
Jaime_Wolf said:
interspark said:
alright, so he flirted with River but he was waving his hands around like Bernard Black on a Saturday when she was kissing him and backed away from her afterwards
He barely knew her and wasn't expecting that. How many times do people just walk up and kiss him?

interspark said:
also he prances around the place all the time, frequently boasts of men who were attracted to him
He ALSO frequently boasts of women who were attracted to him. And how would other men being gay for him indicate that he was gay?

interspark said:
also, River frequently kissing the doctor could mostly refer to future regenerations
Potential problem: he dies before his next regeneration. And unless the creators are blatantly lying to us, that really was him dying - like dead and not coming back dying. In the Confidential after that episode he made this pretty clear. He was several centuries older, so there's still plenty of story left, but if he died looking as he does now, he isn't going to regenerate into another body.
I heard through my Dr Who fanatic husband that BBC will be getting around that with a little bit o "Handwavium", claiming that the time lords limited themselves to 12 regenerations because they all draw from a collective pool of energy. With the Doctor being the last Timelord (supposedly, though there is his cloned daughter and possibly future birth daughter), that pool isn't being drained as quickly as when there were however many millions. This means he can effectively immortal until he decides he's done, assuming BBC does go with this idea and the Doctor decides to break a rule that only he is there to enforce.

It is late and I get my rumors third hand at best, so don't count on it being accurate.
There have been a tremendous numbers of rumours about how they'd handwave that.

But they're all pointless now. We don't just know that he will die, we've seen his death. And it was in this body. And according to the producer, it really was him dying for good. The time-travely nature of the show (and the fact that the Doctor explicitly mentions being several centuries older when we see him just before his death) means there's still plenty for them to talk about, but when he died he had this body, which means he's not going to regenerate again.