Johnny Novgorod said:
I noticed a lot of people answered "My partner/spouse is my best friend". Which is very cute but I don't know how wise that is. I have a very rudimentary (?) don't-put-all-you-eggs-on-the-same-basket philosophy in life, as far as romance and friendship go. And there's some discussion value in that, I think. Is your significant other "also" your best friend? Is your best friend "also" your significant other? What do you think of that?
The grounds for either relationship are very different and I don't know if they mix very well together.
Penny for your thoughts?
I'm sorry you had a bad experience, but it has worked out great for me.
I met a friend my Freshman year of College. We were just regular friends for my Freshman and Sophomore year. Then, my Junior year, we bonded over an anime and ended up becoming really close - best friends. We hung out as best friends - dating other people throughout - all the way through graduation Senior year.
The summer after we both graduated, we went (as friends) to an Anime con... and things kinda sparked. After the con, we decided to go out on a date to see how that went. We had a nice dinner, ended up making out in a park (my best friend got to second base with me before we realized that a group of hikers could see us), and then went back to my best friend's place where we had sex for several hours, put our clothes back on to hang out with some mutual friends, and then had several more hours of sex that night. It was the best sex either of us had ever had.
We talked thereafter about doing a Friend with Benefits thing, but after some thought and a few more dates we pretty much decided to officially call it romantic.
That was in 2001. We've been married since 2005 (we got married on the four year anniversary of our first date). We have a kid now.
There is no one in the world I have more fun hanging out with. There is no one in the world I have more fun gaming with. There is no one in the world I would rather have hot multi-hour multi-orgasm sex with. That whole "sex is boring after marriage" thing is a myth too, by the way. At least it is for us.
So yeah... not only can it work, but it can work great.
And I absolutely disagree that "grounds" for the two relationships is different. One of the reasons our marriage is so awesome is that we share a lot of interests and hobbies. Rather than having our fun activities separate us, they draw us closer together.
Which is why we run lots of solo D&D (read Pathfinder) games for one another - because play is one of the most important aspects of any good friendship or romance.