Poll: Judicial Duel: Your Weapon of Choice

Recommended Videos

RedDeadFred

Illusions, Michael!
May 13, 2009
4,896
0
0
I'm assuming we have identical fighting prowess (or lack of). I'll take the spear simply because I don't want to be close up at all. Knowing myself, he'd be scared to get close to the spear so all I have to do is wait for an opening and strike. Me not having very good reaction times would lead to him not being able to dodge. My evil twin would probably go with the next long range weapon in the Naginata. Mines better for poking which would essentially be our fighting style so I would win pretty much by default.
 

CpT_x_Killsteal

Elite Member
Jun 21, 2012
1,519
0
41
Rapier most definitely. I'd prefer to be fast, and I have decent footwork form when I used to play soccer.
I was originally thinking the sabre, but it's curved too much.
Maybe a cutlass without the full handguard.

Can we get cutlasses?
 

Hero of Lime

Staaay Fresh!
Jun 3, 2013
3,114
0
41
Long sword for me, my grandpa taught me all about sword play, his and my favorite are the long sword, plus my Master Sword is already available and ready to fight! I hope I have some training time to get my feel of the sword again, it's been a while.
 
Oct 10, 2011
4,488
0
0
I've actually got training using a katana so I'll go with that, even if I always had trouble with the "hold the blade loosely" part. Second choice would be the axe and shield, because I have an obsession with Viking stuff.
 

Towels

New member
Feb 21, 2010
245
0
0
I prefer a non-lethal approach and I would use the spear as a staff. But in a duel to the death, I'd be a bit more serious with a katana because of its balanced defense/offense. If I was in a war I'd go with a sabre because chances are I'm going to hit and run a lot on a chaotic battlefield and I'm going to try my damnnest to find a horse or motorcycle and katanas are too heavy.

Edit: Eh screw all that. Sniper Duel with explosives.
 

freaper

snuggere mongool
Apr 3, 2010
1,198
0
0
The only sort of training I've had with a martial weapon that comes even remotely close is with the katana, so I'd have to go with that.

On second thought, my natural reach might give me more of an advantage with a spear.
 

Heronblade

New member
Apr 12, 2011
1,204
0
0
AA12 with the extended drum magazine. 32 slug rounds at point blank range ought to be plenty to deal with him. What? stick to the list? fine

my choice: handaxe & shield

A handaxe is the only item up there that I actually have some experience wielding (mostly against rogue branches I could not effectively take a saw blade to rather than any kind of combat training, but that is far better than nothing). That, and I do have the strength and stamina to use the shield properly as an offensive weapon in and of itself rather than just to block.

If training were less of an issue (ie, I had basic martial training with all of these weapons at some point prior to the match), I would go with the zweihander with the naginata being a tempting second choice. Even in perfect shape I would not have the agility to fully use the potential of many of the lighter weapons listed above, but I should be able to capitalize on those two quite well

wulf3n said:
Why is the axe the only one to get a shield?
Except for the longsword, and sometimes the spear, none of the rest are normally used with a shield. (and both of those can be more effective without the shield in some cases) Either due to balance/agility issues like with the rapier, or because they can only effectively be used with two hands. Actually, the inclusion of the sabre here doesn't make a great deal of sense. Its natural "environment" is mounted combat. While it can be used on foot it loses most of the advantages of its design there.
 

J Tyran

New member
Dec 15, 2011
2,407
0
0
No dildo bats option disappoints me, so I would go for a hand axe and shield. I can use hatchets quite well in a gardening/DIY environment so I could get the hang of swinging one fairly quickly, having a shield is a bonus and I am big enough to charge with it and drop the other person on their arse if the axe isn't working out to well.
 

BlackStar42

New member
Jan 23, 2010
1,226
0
0
Can I use a spear and shield? I can't decide between the axe and the spear. Leaning towards the axe, purely because of the shield.
 

Kaymish

The Morally Bankrupt Weasel
Sep 10, 2008
1,256
0
0
well i would go for the Zweihander just to club my enemy into submission with it
but i would much rather a shield and a falchion giving me the best of both worlds a shield to protect myself and a weapon that can chop halfway through a horse in a swing to again bludgeon my enemy into submission
my good twin would never stand a chance against the damage a axe/sword hybrid would bring to the party
 

Captain Slow

New member
Dec 9, 2012
7
0
0
I choose the rapier. I have fenced for two years and the rapier is a lighter, deadlier version of the Epee.