Poll: L.A noir or portal 2

[codisthebest]

i realise they are very different games but im just wondering which one you like more

 

[Javarock]

Haven't played either.

Genrally I heard portal 2 is alot shorter.

And both have the same replay value.... Whitch is not much.

However portal is spousedly the most fun of the two.

 

[Madshadow]

Portal 2 has a higher replay value not just because of the humor, also because of the multi player.

Problem with Noire is that's its to stiff a game, for story it should have been a good thing but the they way you solve crime case is very repetitive. Plus the character you play with just works on my nerves i don't like him at all.

What i do hope for La Noire that they besides future cases add like GTA IV another story with different characters. Especially that you get the chance to play a greaser Buy a beat up old rod fix it up. Drag race or chicken races and so forth for either money or pink slip. To slowly advance until you beat the fastest racer per region you get the most awesome car and of course the girl

Would be ideal in LA Noire and for those who liked and played a very old game called Streetrod

 

[Makon]

L.A. Noire and Portal 2 are both very good games, but I have to say that I loved Portal 2's playthrough a lot more than L.A. Noire. For one, I've never laughed that hard during a campaign. Ever. For two, Portal 2 has multi-player.

 

[infohippie]

Portal 2, definitely. I've never really liked Rockstar's productions all that much.

 

[RA92]

Didn't you just make another one like this?

http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/9.291026-L-A-noir-or-infamous-2

Why are you even comparing these games with LA Noire? They are completely different genres.

 

[Alfador_VII]

Didn't you just make another one like this?

http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/9.291026-L-A-noir-or-infamous-2

Why are you even comparing these games with LA Noire? They are completely different genres.

I notice you didn't spell Noire right in either thread.

Anyway, of those 3, Portal 2!

 

[Remleiz]

Portal 2, Because the character of Wheatley alone makes it worth the purchase [he's so funny ^_^]

 

[voetballeeuw]

LA Noire. It's a great game, and definitely my top game for this year. Granted the larger titles are on their way.

 

[iRevanchist]

Portal 2, for sure. Btw, you should put an actual clickable poll thing up here as to more easily see the results.