lordlee said:
THIS WINS!!
Yeah if the witch would be my vote if it was an option, for successfully scaring the living shit out of me the first time I played... It was in a dark area... Witch crying, music playing.. I knew what I was up against thanks to youtube... I turn my lights off.. Walking into this overly dark room, looking around for possible zombies, then turning back to where I was heading... All the sudden, I stopped moving forward, and the witch went from crying to growling (Youtube did not prepare me for THAT!) I was confused by this.. So I look around and then face forward again and turn my flashlight on, and too my dismay, all I see is a Witch RIGHT IN MY FACE!!! Eyes glowing ever so red from my flashlight... I get mauled.. I literally jump out of the chair and the chair goes flying back...
That emo chick has held a special place in my heart ever since...