Poll: Manga VS. Anime

[ChromeAlchemist]

-snippety snip-

No doubt in my mind that he was the cop out king from that chapter, I thought the Naruto storyline was going to change completely after that, because it had to, but it was just like 'oh, let's pretend it didn't happen, gold stars and toffee for everyone!'. It's a shame really, but I can see it going in a good direction again, I don't really doubt him. There's still a lot of things to cover, like Kabuto, and the 8 tails and whatnot.

Oh, by the way, I'd put your info in spoiler tags just for those who are watching but not reading, or reading but not up to date. that's {spoiler}info here{/spoiler} but replace { with [

i'm new. :[ didn't know how to do that! :[

but yeah, i'm interested to see what's going on with kabuto. last time we saw him he'd

Spoiler

absorbed orichimaru and had half his face??

Spoiler

I know!! You actually saw Anko and Yamato going to track him down, but Naruto was going nuts and they had to cancel it, it was such a teaser because we haven't seen him in so long, and he could be up to anything! And what about Hinata and Naruto??

Oh and by the way, I'd edit your other posts and copy what I did above, just so people don't quote you and go 'OMG YOU SUCK MY LIFE IS RUINED!'. ;¬)

 

[Caliostro]

Movies vs. Books....

 

[Legion]

Anime, because Manga tends to drag things on for too long.

Movies vs. Books....

Um...No. All Anime comes from a Manga comic book first, therefore the Anime is a TV/Movie adaptation of a comic series.

Completely incomparable to normal books and movies.

 

[la-le-lu-li-lo]

-snippety snip-

No doubt in my mind that he was the cop out king from that chapter, I thought the Naruto storyline was going to change completely after that, because it had to, but it was just like 'oh, let's pretend it didn't happen, gold stars and toffee for everyone!'. It's a shame really, but I can see it going in a good direction again, I don't really doubt him. There's still a lot of things to cover, like Kabuto, and the 8 tails and whatnot.

Oh, by the way, I'd put your info in spoiler tags just for those who are watching but not reading, or reading but not up to date. that's {spoiler}info here{/spoiler} but replace { with [

i'm new. :[ didn't know how to do that! :[

but yeah, i'm interested to see what's going on with kabuto. last time we saw him he'd

Spoiler

absorbed orichimaru and had half his face??

Spoiler

I know!! You actually saw Anko and Yamato going to track him down, but Naruto was going nuts and they had to cancel it, it was such a teaser because we haven't seen him in so long, and he could be up to anything! And what about Hinata and Naruto??

Oh and by the way, I'd edit your other posts and copy what I did above, just so people don't quote you and go 'OMG YOU SUCK MY LIFE IS RUINED!'. ;¬)

will do!
and i thought that other stuff was old news, so that's why i didn't bother. :sigh: can't win.

 

[BIGB0SS]

sometimes manga is better and sometimes anime is better

 

[NeutralDrow]

Anime, because Manga tends to drag things on for too long.

Movies vs. Books....

Um...No. All Anime comes from a Manga comic book first, therefore the Anime is a TV/Movie adaptation of a comic series.

Completely incomparable to normal books and movies.

Should I go through the litany of anime that have been adapted into comic format again?

 

[ChromeAlchemist]

and i enjoy naruto.
and after you get to shippuden, it matures a bit.

not to mention the writer decided to blow up the entire damn village.
still not really over it. :[ shocked the shit outta me.

i mean, who does that!?

Oooo you could've motherbeeping spoiler tagged that godsdamnit! Just....arg....I hate the internet sometimes. Thank you, another anime spoiled, the previous one being Death Note. *delets all his downloaded Naruto episodes*

*ahem*

Anyway, depends I guess, but most of the time I'll pick the anime over manga. Especially action scenes look so much better in an anime. I doubt that the EPIC drunken fist fight from Rock Lee (no one beats him in coolness, no one) in Naruto is even remotely as awesome as in the manga. I doubt I'll see a better fight in the anime itself though, I'm a sucker for hand-to-hand moves, screw that magic ninjitsu and genjitsu stuff.

I'll say this much, it was fairly major, but there's so much more to be seen, so much more. Soldier on.

 

[Tohru_Readman]

I enjoy both and a fair amount of the time characters, storylines and endings can be change for the anime.

 

[Neeko Masochist]

In terms of interest, I like both Anime and Manga as I have noticed in a variety of them that the same Manga about the same Anime take different routes in the story.

To take an example, in the Manga Love Hina (Vol1) when Keitaro is discovered in the Hot Spring by Naru he make a run for it. He ends up bumping into Kaolla Su and she drops a basketful of washing. Keitaro keeps running and eventually ends up standing on a balcony, I think, or a veranda, overlooking the city cut off by the horde of girls. And then the beating commences before Haruka shows up and saves him.

However in the Anime version, Su is actually playing with her remote controlled tanks and has formed a line of them in the lobby of the Hinata Inn calling it 'The last line of defence.' Keitaro steps on one and destroys it and Su opens fire, running out of the inn's front door before there's an explosion and Keitaro tumbles out. (Seriously, how does he always survive these damn explosions.) He's eventually surrounded by the residents, and there is a swift flurry of punches before Haruka shows up.

This difference in storyline is quite evident in many animes and mangas.

 

[Siegreich]

I generally find the manga to be better, also there are many great mangas that never make it to become an anime like Akumetsu, also the manga usually has alot of content that the anime just skips or changes.

 

[gagalloogie]

Both sure add something.....presumably...to culture, and can be quite good...but I don't think they are anywhere near different enough to post a poll over, and most of it is just japanese refuse anyway

 

[Danik93]

ok... i will probably be hated for this comment but... i HATE Anime and Manga!! i don't like teens with weirdo banana hair that takes seven tons of Helium every morning to talk that squeaky a whole episode.