I wonder how many people were torn between choosing Sports and Racing, and then remembered either Mario Kart, Wipeout, or Road Rash, and went with Sports. I know I did.
I don't like sports games, but I'm not really convinced by the argument of, "I could just play the sport". If I play a Total War game, I could also just join the SCA. I could take karate for a fighter, I could watch a movie for a Point and Click, I could play paintball for an FPS. And I could very easilly love the game version, and not like the real world counterpart. There's something else going on here, pushing sports to the top of the dislike list. Something that separates the mechanic/dynamic/aestetic framework of sports from the MDA framework of other kinds of games.