Poll: My Love Triangle Help!!!

Recommended Videos

UpSkirtDistress

New member
Mar 2, 2009
272
0
0
Ok so heres my problem. 2 years ago I was on and off with this amazing girl but nothing serious. At a house party I got together with a girl from school and now 2years later we are still together.

The problem is this other girl is still in my life, we stayed good friends the whole time and everytime i see her (which is rare because she lives an hour or so away by train) there is this big spark between us and she is so fun and exciting. My girlfrined is fun in her own way and i do love her but i still have all these annoying thoughts.

My girlfriend is great, cute ,friendly, exceptionally loyal and kind. We get on great ,we are like part of each others families. We have a huge history together and were each others first more or less everything .Our day to day stuff is fun and still isn't dull or boring even after all this time. The only problem really is she doesnt get on too well with my friends, its not that they don't like each other its just they don't really click you know, they all talk and joke with her but wouldn't really count her as a friend of their own. They think she is a little boring ,she doesn't really drink or go out clubbing etc. Also she can be quiye clingy at parties she follows me around and won't give me much space.

The other girl is full of good qualities really fun, funny, social gets on with everyone very very sexy. We talk on the phone alot and she tells me everything about her life ,we keep nothing from each other. She is great fun the whole time has lots and lots of friends and ...well is just great fun all round. I can't stop thinking about her its driving me mad but i still love my girlfriend

What would you do in my situation or have youu ever been in a similar situation and what have you done?

Edit: The other girl has made it clear she still has feelings for me.
Edit2: Just looking for outsider opinions not gonna base my decision on it. I don't actually expect to solve my problem on the internet just curious is all.
 

Internet Kraken

Animalia Mollusca Cephalopada
Mar 18, 2009
6,915
0
0
Why not have both? A hur hur hur

I would stick with your current girlfriend. You never really know how a relationship with the other one would end up until it's to late.
 

SargentToughie

New member
Jun 14, 2008
2,580
0
0
Stick with your current girlfriend, you've heard the old 'grass is greener on the other side' thing.

EDIT: ignore all the smartasses respected forum goers around here that say that you should date both, I have a few friends that tried that, it always ends in disaster.
 

jim_doki

New member
Mar 29, 2008
1,942
0
0
*sigh*
Ok, dude, it's really quite simple. Four options. Give up you're great girlfriend for the shot at something that might suck, Give up something that could be amazing for your boring and safe girlfriend, walk away from both until you figure out what it is you want, or a battle to the death between the two women involving Sai and a pit full of Jelly
 

dmase

New member
Mar 12, 2009
2,117
0
0
Do you even now if the other girl still has feelings for you, don't assume that she does because two are such good friends just ask her.
 

Armored Prayer

New member
Mar 10, 2009
5,319
0
0
Damn, your in a really tough spot.

I say go with your girlfriend, keep your good relationship going.
 

dmase

New member
Mar 12, 2009
2,117
0
0
jim_doki said:
*sigh*
Ok, dude, it's really quite simple. Four options. Give up you're great girlfriend for the shot at something that might suck, Give up something that could be amazing for your boring and safe girlfriend, walk away from both until you figure out what it is you want, or a battle to the death between the two women involving Sai and a pit full of Jelly
addition to fourth option: videotape and post on escapist.
 

dmase

New member
Mar 12, 2009
2,117
0
0
SargentToughie said:
Stick with your current girlfriend, you've heard the old 'grass is greener on the other side' thing.

EDIT: ignore all the smartasses respected forum goers around here that say that you should date both, I have a few friends that tried that, it always ends in disaster.
In his situation it seems almost impossible for him to date both anyways. Unless you tell one and not the other that she is the girl that is being used for a "special" friends relationship.
 

IxionIndustries

New member
Mar 18, 2009
2,237
0
0
I'd try and get both, but apparently people around here frown upon that, so on a serious note:

Stay with your current one. If she decides to dump you, or go all "crazy-psycho-*****" on you, then try and get with the other girl. That way, you'll always have a backup plan.
 

Kiutu

New member
Sep 27, 2008
1,787
0
0
The girlfriend. So what if she does not get along with your friends? Unless you are 100% of the time with friends. Do you hang out with hers?
Besides, friends are fickle. I did not get along with my boyfriend's friends either. They however all betrayed him, but I still very much love him and support him.
 

jboking

New member
Oct 10, 2008
2,694
0
0
jim_doki said:
*sigh*
Ok, dude, it's really quite simple. ONE option. A battle to the death between the two women involving Sai and a pit full of Jelly
Fixed that for you.

Seriously though, Do you know that this other girl is interested? If not then that would be a good place to start. If you feel like your relationship with your current girlfriend is getting stale then do something spontaneous and unexpected. If all else fails, just tell your current girlfriend how you feel and ask her if its alright to date other people for a while to see if you still feel the same way about each other afterwords. That is still a gamble.

Safest bet is to stick with the girl you have and be happy you have her.
 

Flap Jack452

New member
Jan 5, 2009
1,998
0
0
jim_doki said:
*sigh*
Ok, dude, it's really quite simple. Four options. Give up you're great girlfriend for the shot at something that might suck, Give up something that could be amazing for your boring and safe girlfriend, walk away from both until you figure out what it is you want, or a battle to the death between the two women involving Sai and a pit full of Jelly
Those options are really the only way you can solve your problem. The fourth one would be fun to watch though.
 

Matronadena

New member
Mar 11, 2009
879
0
0
sometimes I wish I could follow old Celtic rites, and be able to take my OWN wife...think Hubby worries that would give me yet more control and authority in the house, but meh...damn laws :mad:

UpSkirtDistress said:
anyway hun, in your spot I would lean more to toughing it out with the current... who, or how socially attached they are to others outside the relationship should not matter at all, the fact that she tries to be friendly, and social and enjoy time around " your" friends speaks volumes about her as a good woman, trying to enjoy her life, and try's to make her man's life enjoyable. If you really were to ask me love, at least from what you said so far...you already know the answer deep down.
 

Plauged1

New member
Mar 6, 2009
576
0
0
Stick with the one you have. Dumping her for someone who already had a chance is a very bullshit move.