Poll: Portal 1/2 end credit songs, wich was better?

[SangRahl]

I like Still Alive a lot... but the different feel of Want You Gone fits well, too. I guess I'll stick with Still Alive, for now. But I'll likely change my tune ::groan:: after I've gone through Portal2 a few more times.

As for JoCo songs, I like Stonecrusher Mountain the best. I just wish I still had the range to be able to carry all of it, instead of having to hum a couple times when I really want to sing it through.

 

[DementedSheep]

Well I think Want you Gone sounds better but the lyrics for Still Alive are more clever and funnier IMO. So Still Alive wins.

 

[iblis666]

both are good songs but still alive was much funnier so i have to choose it

 

[JET1971]

32 to 26... closer than it was.

 

[Fangv2]

The first :30 seconds of "I Only Want You Gone" don't mesh. Rest of it is fine but those first :30 seconds leave a bad opening taste that nags the back of my head.

So my vote is for "Still Alive".

 

[Pearwood]

Want You Gone seems to be the better performed song, Still Alive was the more quotable.

 

[Talydia]

Still Alive for comedic value.

Want You Gone is the better song.

I'd have to agree with this. Overall though I'd go with Still Alive, but only for the reason that it was the first one and that makes it better in some unsubstantiated way.

 

[joemegson94]

Still ALive is a classic, funny song, but I prefer Want You Gone, as it just sounds better.

 

[tharglet]

16 for "Still Alive" and 7 for "Want you Gone". 6 replies! tell me why you prefer the song lol

For most people the reason is likely to be "because I do", and Escapist frowns on short answers . Always the case more people vote than reply lol - at least you're getting their opinion in the poll .


For me, Want You Gone has grown on me, but I think Still Alive is still the better song to listen to.