Poll: RP ideas: Warcraft UPDATE! read bottom of OP

Recommended Videos

stormcaller

New member
Sep 6, 2008
2,314
0
0
Hi there, I've been wanting to give a Warcraft RP another go(With the last two kind of failing not entirely my fault though) for a while now but I am stuck between two choices of the exact kind of game I want to play.

The choices in short are as follows-

A creative liscense re-enactment of the end of the Second Azeroth War in which the broken Dark Horde raids Azeroth for artifacts which Ner'zhul uses to open portals to different worlds but ultimately fails and destroys Draenor.

or

A story extension of the Battle for Undercity quest chain in which King Varian Wrynn of the humans breaks the 'peace' which the Horde, effectively starting the fourth war, which makes it the perfect time for the Scourge and the Black Dragonflight to start strirring shit up as well. Read: World War Azeroth

Play style-

The overall idea is to get people from different teams competing against each other in both of the choices but with some differences.

The Dark Portal story is for the most part a standard RP, the major battles are pre-decided so it's easy to just write about your characters involvement.

While World War Azeroth is alot more complex meshing pieces of traditional RP/ Army management and territory control. It'll also require alot more contact with me and your fellow players to the extent I'll probably need your MSN addresses and if you don't have one then prepare to love the PM system.

Number of players

Both will have a split of 6/6 between the Alliance and (Old) Horde,I'm consdiering a playable scourge faction for WWA so possibly 4/4/4. I understand 12 is a large amount of players but both these story lines are epic and require the attention.

How it'll work

Like I said with the past story it'll be a straight up RP, characters defending attacking settlements, out in the wilds,etc.

With the other it'll be about managing a smaller army of your respective faction. You'll still have character development and characterisation don't worry about that. The idea is that you conquer your enemies through whatever means- total annihilation, territory control, resource choke, force into peace. the groups will have a leader and by that I mean just the bloke who relays your movements and actions to me.

Characters themselves-

The fun of an old setting would be engaging with historical figures in their prime, ever wanted to see how long you could go one on one with Uther or Grom for? Here's your chance. The races are as follows- Dark Horde: Orc, Ogre, Amani Troll Alliance: Human, Dwarf, High Elf, Gnome. I will also ask you to choose which clan/kingdom you follow. Classes are basically anything from lore at the time (Orc Blademasters, Ogre Maulers, Troll Axethrowers etc.)

For WWA I'd prefer you find a way to weasel yourself into a military position, or if you want to be a rank and file soldier that's fine, there's a way to make everything work :D.

Let's have a go at it!-

Yeah not quite, I still have a little bit of writing to do for both ideas so I've put this poll up to see if I can cut my work down a bit.

Final note-

I ask that for both you are a active player and have a decent-ish+ understanding of Warcraft lore. I will be in need of people who are able to co-ordinate well for both ideas so again it shows up.

If this thread flops I'll know there isn't a lot of interest.

So ideas,opinions, anything is welcomed please and thanks. (Sorry for making you read le wall du text aswell)

UPDATE: Ok new poll I'm starting within the text. How many people will be willing to actively play WWA? (It looks like it's going to win sorry to all those who were rooting for The Dark Portal story, maybe another time)

5
 

Zombie_Fish

Opiner of Mottos
Mar 20, 2009
4,584
0
0
stormcaller said:
On another note, where has the bookmark button gone!?
I've lost all those buttons as well. Don't know why.

Anyway, I think War Of Azeroth sounds better, but I don't know Warcraft that well so my opinion isn't that reliable.
 

stormcaller

New member
Sep 6, 2008
2,314
0
0
Zombie_Fish said:
stormcaller said:
On another note, where has the bookmark button gone!?
I've lost all those buttons as well. Don't know why.

Anyway, I think War Of Azeroth sounds better, but I don't know Warcraft that well so my opinion isn't that reliable.
They've just gone invisible I found out, dunno' why though.

Thanks, what does "that well" mean. For WWA all you really need is to know the places and about your armies and the enemies.
 

the Tadman

New member
Apr 15, 2009
1,047
0
0
stormcaller said:
ta2ce said:
The first one sounds slightly better, but both are awesome.
The first option on the poll you mean? I just realised I screwed the order up...
On the poll. Also if you do, do that save a spot for me. I <3 Warcraft
 

ae86gamer

New member
Mar 10, 2009
9,009
0
0
I like the second idea (The Last Stand of the Dark Horde). Seems like it would be more fun :)
 

stormcaller

New member
Sep 6, 2008
2,314
0
0
ae86gamer said:
I like the second idea (The Last Stand of the Dark Horde). Seems like it would be more fun :)
Yeah, it would be a fair bit easier to keep track of too, but even then the interest pool seems smallish... :(
 

ae86gamer

New member
Mar 10, 2009
9,009
0
0
stormcaller said:
ae86gamer said:
I like the second idea (The Last Stand of the Dark Horde). Seems like it would be more fun :)
Yeah, it would be a fair bit easier to keep track of too, but even then the interest pool seems smallish... :(
As long as you have a few dedicated people it doesn't matter. Just make sure that the people you do get are decent-ish at writing and make their post longer than two sentences.
[sup]I'd be more than willing to join. :)[/sup]
 

Mookie_Magnus

Clouded Leopard
Jan 24, 2009
4,011
0
0
Both look fun. I'd like a spot for either.

Personally, I like the Last Stand of the Dark Horde idea.
 

Zombie_Fish

Opiner of Mottos
Mar 20, 2009
4,584
0
0
stormcaller said:
Zombie_Fish said:
stormcaller said:
On another note, where has the bookmark button gone!?
I've lost all those buttons as well. Don't know why.

Anyway, I think War Of Azeroth sounds better, but I don't know Warcraft that well so my opinion isn't that reliable.
They've just gone invisible I found out, dunno' why though.

Thanks, what does "that well" mean. For WWA all you really need is to know the places and about your armies and the enemies.
Don't even know that. I've only even had one experience of Warcraft, in Germany. I'm actually only going on what you have written so I doubt I would be that good with it anyway.
 

Kaboose the Moose

New member
Feb 15, 2009
3,842
0
0
I am all for epic-ness but the RP should be manageable, from a GM point of view and players should be acive or else it could die
 

stormcaller

New member
Sep 6, 2008
2,314
0
0
Skarin said:
I am all for epic-ness but the RP should be manageable, from a GM point of view and players should be acive or else it could die
You're right, that's the challenge with a large player base. Hopefully I get some truly dedicated players though.
 

ravensshade

resident shadow
Mar 18, 2009
1,900
0
0
World War Azeroth how far after last stand of the darkhorde does that take place? i.e short enough for high elves because if you wait to long they become bloodelves
 

stormcaller

New member
Sep 6, 2008
2,314
0
0
ravensshade said:
World War Azeroth how far after last stand of the darkhorde does that take place? i.e short enough for high elves because if you wait to long they become bloodelves
? Last Stand of the Dark Horde occurs straight after the second war, so while Thrall was still very young.

WWA takes place in the current WoW timeline, there are still some High Elves though. They didn't choose to aqll become Blood Elves.
 

Bling Cat

New member
Jan 13, 2008
899
0
0
stormcaller said:
ae86gamer said:
I like the second idea (The Last Stand of the Dark Horde). Seems like it would be more fun :)
Yeah, it would be a fair bit easier to keep track of too, but even then the interest pool seems smallish... :(
Never sacrifice epic to make things easier to keep track of. If you put enough work into it, the World War Azeroth idea sounds like it could become genuinely awesome. And I mean, really, really good. Having players on different level of command in a war, as long as you put some limitations on just how stupid they can be, sounds like a very good idea.

Just avoid the WW3 effect (As I call it) Which, for those who don't know, is placing no limits limits on players, until it devolves into a brawl with no consequences or limits.
 

stormcaller

New member
Sep 6, 2008
2,314
0
0
Bling Cat said:
stormcaller said:
ae86gamer said:
I like the second idea (The Last Stand of the Dark Horde). Seems like it would be more fun :)
Yeah, it would be a fair bit easier to keep track of too, but even then the interest pool seems smallish... :(
Never sacrifice epic to make things easier to keep track of. If you put enough work into it, the World War Azeroth idea sounds like it could become genuinely awesome. And I mean, really, really good. Having players on different level of command in a war, as long as you put some limitations on just how stupid they can be, sounds like a very good idea.

Just avoid the WW3 effect (As I call it) Which, for those who don't know, is placing no limits limits on players, until it devolves into a brawl with no consequences or limits.
True I guess, the RP equivalent of "Never aim for second best"?

I thought I was on to something interesting when I thought of it, but it is a pretty fragile thing.

I plan to limit players quite heavily, their a piece in a world war not the only army. For example you'll only start out with a small platoon that will receive missions from the higher ups such as "Begin an attack on *so and so place* and create a diversion while the main host attacks from the back gate" or protecting a cavaran. That's not to say you wont be on the field of honour at some point though.