Poll: She's really into me... she just doesn't know who I am

[Abedeus]

Go for it man, it'll be an awesome story for your grandkids.

Lying to someone for the sake of an "awesome story" seems kind of immoral to me, but maybe I'm just old-fashioned like that.

Edit: Then again, if she's really that hot...

If she's dumb enough to not see a difference between 2 different people, she deserves a mental gloveslap.


At least it's more entertaining that listening to another 15-year old "tough guy" that has been dumped and is emoing out here.

Call her and come clean, calmly and maturely apologize and ask if you can make it up

MAKE IT UP?! FOR WHAT?! Don't listen to him, she'll use you for some stupid thing if you say that. It's her own fault.

 

[Queen Michael]

Ahoy, oh man... Ye had better not be makin' this up, shiver me timbers! Me say go for it. When ye die, ye will be wonderin' what it had been like otherwise. Yarr!

 

[vampirekid.13]

....


come up with a story about how your middle name is nick?

or your nickname is nick.

or something. i dont know, but way to fuck yourself over on that one. altho i dont think there were any real alternatives. -_-

 

[Olikunmissile]

Don't play with her feelings, come clean.

 

[BehattedWanderer]

Really reminds me of that Flight of the Concords song "Jenny"

Gonna go with come clean, but do it humorously. But hopefully she didn't get rid of Nick's number.

 

[XJ-0461]

Call her and come clean. That way you still have a shot with her after she knows who you are. If you carry on the lie things will blow up in your face very quickly.

And the Fight Club thing does make sense.

 

[twistedshadows]

First off, that's hilarious and I commend you for your efforts.
Secondly, I highly doubt this end well. Girls don't like being lied to (even if it's funny) and you're already too far in to fix it.

If you call her and come clean, there's a remote possibility that she'll take it well and remain interested in you. Very remote, though.

 

[Zac_Dai]

Ok, so a bit of backstory first. I am the most generic looking person of all time. Now that we have that out of the way, today I was walking from my class to my car and I hear this girl yell "Nick" really loud (This isn't my name BTW). So you know, natural reaction, you hear a loud noise, you react to it. So I look over and this smoking hot girl runs up and gives me a hug and a kiss on the cheek, and then starts telling me about how she hasn't seen me in over a year and things of that nature for about 2 minutes. Now, to avoid an extremely awkward situation and just because I have a sense of humor, I just sort of go along with it.

So I make some small talk with her for about, 10 minutes, (she's dropping major hints that she's into me) and then she asks "So how are you and (Natalie?)" and I just pulled out of my ass something along the lines of, "well she's going to SDU, I'm here at (my college) and with the whole long distance thing we both decided that it wasn't going to work out." So she tells me that she doesn't have a boyfriend right now and asks for my number. At this point I'm kind of committed to the lie that I'm this Nick guy so I tell her I dropped my phone and now it doesn't work so I'm switching to Cingulair and I probably won't have the same number. So she writes down her number for me and tells me to call her when I get a new phone, then hugs me again and runs off to her next class.

So now I have her number and I really have no idea what I should do. I could keep pretending to be Nick. Sure, that will blow up in my face probably very quickly, but I would have an interesting story to tell for the rest of my life. I could call her and come clean. I feel like kind of an asshole for getting her hopes up, and she did seem pretty into me anyways. Or I could just not call her, but then i might run into her again and that will be just as awkward. So what do you think I should do? And do you think if I come clean I still have a chance with her, or will she be too pissed off at me?

Oh, sidenote. just as a complete mindfuck to top it all off, I come home and the movie fightclub is on TV. If you've seen it you know what I'm talking about.

This is the start of a legendary story, a story that will you be drunkingly telling at parties to the delight of the gathered crowd for years to come! So for the sake of the legend you have to continue to be nick and see it through to its conclusion!

Don't listen to all the "be honest" crap, she will only feel a fool and go right off you so you will lose anyway.

There is no way you can rescue this so you might as well do the right thing and continue to be Nick!

 

[Shycte]

Wow, you should pst this story on /b/, jsut for teh lulz.

Then count how many "screw her and post tits" responses you get. It will be amusing.

Anyway, I would say Come Clean, But she fucking hates me Ultra hard refrence, super-cookie if you tell me the refrence

 

[SomethingUnrelated]

Keep being this "Nick" fella for a while. Then when she suspects, come clean. It'll be one hell of a laugh.

 

[justhereforthemoney]

You dont call her and tell her the truth, either go with it for the story or leave it alone. If she continues talking to you, you have to go with it. Try and figure out who she is, so you can figure out who the real Nick is. If you talk to her some, the hints about who Nick is will be obvious.

 

[Glass_House]

Well if I were you I would have come clean at the start and when she started being all embarrassed and such I would have joked around and made her feel better. At least then she knows your not a douche and you can work on it from there.

 

[Grampy_bone]

I think he should come clean... after he nails her.

Seriously, what's the harm? We are talking about college kids for christ's sake. He should go over to her place and put the moves on her, and if she goes with it, hooray for all involved. Then afterwards admit to not being Nick (during the cuddling!) At that point, she may be mad but oh well. Chances are good at that point she will stick with him anyway, and you never know, they may end up together and have a hilarious story to tell their grandkids.

It's not like he's the aggressor in the situation anyway, Nick or otherwise.

 

[Yorkshire_matt]

the worst that happens is you get slapped and have the storry to tell.

take one for the team and see what happens

 

[justhereforthemoney]

Well if I were you I would have come clean at the start and when she started being all embarrassed and such I would have joked around and made her feel better. At least then she knows your not a douche and you can work on it from there.

If you come clean from the start she will guaranteed say "o, sorry then" and leave you in the dust, unless she's some unbelievably exceptional girl.

 

[Triple G]

Ok, so a bit of backstory first. I am the most generic looking person of all time. Now that we have that out of the way, today I was walking from my class to my car and I hear this girl yell "Nick" really loud (This isn't my name BTW). So you know, natural reaction, you hear a loud noise, you react to it. So I look over and this smoking hot girl runs up and gives me a hug and a kiss on the cheek, and then starts telling me about how she hasn't seen me in over a year and things of that nature for about 2 minutes. Now, to avoid an extremely awkward situation and just because I have a sense of humor, I just sort of go along with it.

So I make some small talk with her for about, 10 minutes, (she's dropping major hints that she's into me) and then she asks "So how are you and (Natalie?)" and I just pulled out of my ass something along the lines of, "well she's going to SDU, I'm here at (my college) and with the whole long distance thing we both decided that it wasn't going to work out." So she tells me that she doesn't have a boyfriend right now and asks for my number. At this point I'm kind of committed to the lie that I'm this Nick guy so I tell her I dropped my phone and now it doesn't work so I'm switching to Cingulair and I probably won't have the same number. So she writes down her number for me and tells me to call her when I get a new phone, then hugs me again and runs off to her next class.

So now I have her number and I really have no idea what I should do. I could keep pretending to be Nick. Sure, that will blow up in my face probably very quickly, but I would have an interesting story to tell for the rest of my life. I could call her and come clean. I feel like kind of an asshole for getting her hopes up, and she did seem pretty into me anyways. Or I could just not call her, but then i might run into her again and that will be just as awkward. So what do you think I should do? And do you think if I come clean I still have a chance with her, or will she be too pissed off at me?

Oh, sidenote. just as a complete mindfuck to top it all off, I come home and the movie fightclub is on TV. If you've seen it you know what I'm talking about.

Call her, tell her to meet you, and come clean personally. That's better than coming clean on the phone.

 

[DND Judgement]

keep going with nick when it blows up in your face we can all have a good laugh about it on here....

 

[anti-hero_will]

cant say i would have done the same thing and go along with it but the only other me lookalike that i know of, is in america and thats a bit of a distance from england.

but come clean anyway its evil in a funny way. but will end bad or something. come clean will save a beating of you.

 

[ThreeWords]

I'd call her and come clean.
She might like you even if you're not Nick.

This.

I would, just for the lulz, but as he^^^ said, she might still like you