Poll: Should I accept my mother in this scenario?

Recommended Videos

Kryzantine

New member
Feb 18, 2010
827
0
0
Before I start describing the situation, I'll say that my family is very fucked up, as this will show. It's a very chaotic family, if you can call it that anymore. I don't need any comments consisting of only that, but I guess you can make them anyway. If you don't want to hear the backstory, skip 3 paragraphs.

My mother is a *****. I'm not even being the average teen who wants to get away from his mum, I mean she is crazy. She and my dad are separated (like most Russian couples) and have been for about 10 years now. As a result, my dad had to start paying for two apartments at once, which can get expensive in NYC. He had to live in mediocrity for a very long while, and only recently has gotten the financial push he's been looking for. I stayed with my mum, until around 2 years ago, when we start disagreeing with each other profusely, and she starts complaining about all sorts of things. She runs me out of the god damned house. I live with my dad for a few months until hell month kicked in (don't ask me about hell month, it was pretty much the worst month of my life, and I don't want to reiterate the details), and I got shipped back to her. She makes up with me, we live in relative peace for a while (although I rarely interacted with her, very little real conversation).

Fast forward to about 2 months ago, when my sis is ready to move onto college. Despite getting a perfect SAT score and having a 94 average in a pretty good NYC school, she gets rejected by all the colleges on her list. Soon, my mum and sis are talking about moving to LA. I bolted for my dad's place before she kicks me out. My dad works down in Baltimore, so he doesn't exactly have a problem with what I do in his apartment, and my mentality changed a lot after hell month for the better. My sis and mum go to LA, I stay in NYC to finish off my last year of HS, it's all a good plan.

Except they forgot to actually plan for once they were in LA, because my sis didn't technically get into any college there. Since she can't claim California residency, and since the schools there are overcrowded, she would have to wait for the spring term to enter a crummy community college, or wait a whole year to apply to Cal. She feels her only acceptable option is to go back to NYC and go to CUNY. So she calls this week and says she's coming back to NYC for a long, long while, and she's probably getting here Friday or Saturday.

Now, the problem. My dad and I agree that my mum cannot live in our apartment. For one, we don't have enough room. For two, we both can't tolerate her. She has not worked since 1990, has not gotten a job in NYC (and her resume is very largely and very crudely falsified), and she has a nasty habit of dragging people down with her. She's the woman that goes from middle class income to living off food stamps just to piss off the government. Her family gets in the way of that. However, knowing her, she's going to be touching down in NYC as well, back from a vacation in LA, and show up at my apartment door, and she's going to be expecting me to provide her a home. My dad and I do not want to accept her. When I tell my sister on the phone that my mum is not welcome, she says that my mum may "not necessarily" come to my door. I interpret this as total bullshit and fully expect my mother to appear at my apartment door charming her way into another free life.

Should I take her in because she is my mother anyway, or do I have a right to refuse her hospitality because of every other reason?

Meh, busted poll, I figured this will happen. I will read to responses.
 
Apr 28, 2008
14,634
0
0
Oof, thats heavy.

I would say if she does come, make her get a job. Refuse to let her live with you until she proves she got one. Yes she's your mother, but unless she's very old or very sick, you shouldn't have to put up with this. Plus, its your dad's apartment, so what he says goes.

Honestly thats all I can say. Not really sure what to do in this situation. But I hope it helps.
 

Steppin Razor

New member
Dec 15, 2009
6,868
0
0
So she's a ***** and she doesn't even have a frigging job? Normally I'd say to take her in, even with those two issues as she is family, but then we come to her kicking you out of the house before and the fact that you and your Dad don't get along with her.

Edit
Give her one last chance, but make it perfectly clear to her that it's only a temporary thing until she can get her own place to stay and that if she causes any trouble the cops will be called out to get her the hell away from you.

Call the cops if she turns up at the apartment.
 

pretentiousname01

New member
Sep 30, 2009
476
0
0
Coming from a bitter hate filled ass hole such as myself. Cut your mom off. The only reason these people can get away with living the way they do is because people let them. Don't be an enabler.

Your sister on the other hand, can probably get into school. They may not be her choice schools, but that's not a reason to not go at all. Add on those scores and it shouldn't cost much if anything. Apply for every scholarship you can.
 

Girl With One Eye

HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA
Jun 2, 2010
1,528
0
0
If you let her in she will be there for a long time and make your life hell in a very crowed space which could result in you either leaving or getting kicked out again. You could give her another chance, or help her find her own place and a job. I'm not good with these situations I'm afraid but her moving in doesn't seem to be a good idea.
 

twasdfzxcv

New member
Mar 30, 2010
310
0
0
Before you do anything you should consult with a lawyer and see if you have the responsibility to take care of your mom legally. If you're free in terms of legality (though I highly doubt that'd be the case), move and change your phone number.
 

The_Healer

New member
Jun 17, 2009
1,720
0
0
Given your history, I think you can reasonably forget that she is your mother in this case and treat her as you would any other freeloader who you don't have space for in your house.

That is, slam the door in her face.
 

StBishop

New member
Sep 22, 2009
3,251
0
0
You owe her nothing.

If you feel that she will have a negative impact on your life, don't let her have the opportunity.

Many people will judge you for it. It's worth it, the people who matter will accept it and move on.

You need to worry about yourself in life until you meet someone who worries about you, then worry about them too. (This sounds like it applies to your dad and sister).

Don't throw yourself under a bus for someone who won't appreciate it and hasn't done anything to deserve that from you.
 

SimuLord

Whom Gods Annoy
Aug 20, 2008
10,077
0
0
I stopped at the point where you said Russian couple and immediately wanted to say "is for shutting out of mother for make glorious life living of child! Is making many happy happy time for not having of parent!"
 

Steppin Razor

New member
Dec 15, 2009
6,868
0
0
twasdfzxcv said:
Before you do anything you should consult with a lawyer and see if you have the responsibility to take care of your mom legally. If you're free in terms of legality (though I highly doubt that'd be the case), move and change your phone number.
What? Why would he legally have to look after her?

On Topic: I changed my mind. Tell your sister that you're going to call the cops out to cart her away if she turns up at your Dad's apartment. Crazy ***** causing problems needs to be kept well away.
 

klaynexas3

My shoes hurt
Dec 30, 2009
1,525
0
0
make her get a job FIRST then if she loses it she's out. i don't know how much of a ***** she really is, because all the evidence of that you had to offer was that she kicked you out but she also knew you had a place to go so it wasn't like she was making you live on the streets or anything. you obviously weren't getting along with her and you might have seriously been pissing her off so she decided that she didn't have to put up with it and thought you'd be better off with your dad. look, let her in after she gets a job, you don't have to interact with her, and the moment you're through with her kick her out. if you make her start paying rent then you've got nothing to lose and some extra money in giving her one last chance.
 

Averant

New member
Jul 6, 2010
452
0
0
Don't let her in. If she's a ***** and you can't live with her, DON'T LIVE WITH HER. That can put you on a very fast track to a miserable life and quite literally on the highway to hell. Tell her to go live in a hotel and get a job. It's not your responsibility if she's freeloading.

twasdfzxcv said:
Before you do anything you should consult with a lawyer and see if you have the responsibility to take care of your mom legally. If you're free in terms of legality (though I highly doubt that'd be the case), move and change your phone number.
This. Definitely this.
 

Russian_Assassin

New member
Apr 24, 2008
1,849
0
0
SimuLord said:
I stopped at the point where you said Russian couple and immediately wanted to say "is for shutting out of mother for make glorious life living of child! Is making many happy happy time for not having of parent!"
Your post gives me the impression that you are mocking my people.

Moving on, I say you give her only one chance only if she finds a job. If not then go be freeloader elsewhere lady!
 

MikailCaboose

New member
Jun 16, 2009
1,246
0
0
Ouch. Personally, I wouldn't accept her. My one Great-aunt is pretty much like that, and almost my entire family basically ignores her. Although, she doesn't come around at all (she hates my Grandparents for the stupid reason that we helped her third ex-husband after she damn near took everything in the house after their divorce) and rarely talks to us in the first place. It may be tough, but with how you said your situation is it doesn't sound like you really have any other feasible choice.
 

Naheal

New member
Sep 6, 2009
3,375
0
0
Aylaine said:
I would try to find some middle ground. You ca n always give her a chance: she may be a B, but she is still your mom and she took you in and raised you, correct? I think you at least owe it to her to give her some middle ground to make a decent step in the right direction. That being, ask her to get a job. See if she will do that. I know that from your experience, she likely won't and you still don't want her around, but do you want to look back and say ''I shut my mom out'' when I could have helped her? You just have to look at it long term. While where she would go otherwise, how she will survive, will she be okay are all fine and dandy questions, how will things work out later in life? Regrets suck, and I wouldn't want you to have any because of something going on in the here and now. That's why some middle ground would be best, if she messes it up, then you can kick her out.

Just my opinion though. I'm a firm believer that if she supported you, even badly for some time, you should do the same for her and at least give her a chance. ♥
But what if kicking her out is exactly the wakeup call she needs? From the sounds of it, she's been using people for well over two decades and needs to start standing up herself rather than trying to work as a parasite living off of her so-called family, so it might be in the best interests of both parties for the OP to simply say "No" and have it be the end of it. If she doesn't improve, then she wasn't willing to actually work for herself in the first place. If she does, then it becomes "I helped my mom out by giving her the slap that she needed" rather than "I shut my mom out".
 

twasdfzxcv

New member
Mar 30, 2010
310
0
0
Alpha1089 said:
twasdfzxcv said:
Before you do anything you should consult with a lawyer and see if you have the responsibility to take care of your mom legally. If you're free in terms of legality (though I highly doubt that'd be the case), move and change your phone number.
What? Why would he legally have to look after her?

On Topic: I changed my mind. Tell your sister that you're going to call the cops out to cart her away if she turns up at your Dad's apartment. Crazy ***** causing problems needs to be kept well away.
http://graphics8.nytimes.com/packages/pdf/health/NOA/30states.pdf

While it seems that it's not often enforced, you should take into consideration that as medicaid budget dwindles, the government might start enforcing these law as a way to mitigate the cost.

Seem that you're fine in New York but New Jersey is on the list.